Cam or Russell - which would you take as your franchise QB

[Hawk]

call him whatever you want but just remember....forever it will be followed with "Superbowl Champion"

[SCP]

hell no....love his positive attitude and the team feeds off of it

His interviews are like nails on a chalk board. Guess I'm either just a hater or I don't trust people who are that damn positive and goofy all the time.

[KJ89]

Cam duh

[BigBoss]

Russel. I'd trust him more. Plus Cam is already way more banged up. Both are gonna be great in this league.

[Chief_Chokeaho]

call him whatever you want but just remember....forever it will be followed with "Superbowl Champion"

As will Trent Dilfer. So by your logic Russell Wilson is a better QB than Dan Marino.

[SZ James (banned)]

The question was, who would you take as your franchise QB. They are both the definition of a franchise player, but Wilson has proven that he can win a SB and that is what a franchise player is, it doesn't mean they are the best player on the team. All counterarguments so far deal with IF's.

IF cam had seattle's defense or lynch... IF wilson had our o-line... IF wilson suddenly became eli manning... etc.

Right now though the answer is wilson.

[FuFuLamePoo]

it's pretty close.  but i'll give the edge to cam 

[SCP]

The question was, who would you take as your franchise QB. They are both the definition of a franchise player, but Wilson has proven that he can win a SB and that is what a franchise player is, it doesn't mean they are the best player on the team. All counterarguments so far deal with IF's.

IF cam had seattle's defense or lynch... IF wilson had our o-line... IF wilson suddenly became eli manning... etc.

Right now though the answer is wilson.

That's your answer. My answer is Cam. All day.

[SZ James (banned)]

That's your answer. My answer is Cam. All day.

according to what metric? aside from homerism?

[Mol3m4n]

according to what metric? aside from homerism?

This is the United States. Fug the metric system.

[Hawk]

As will Trent Dilfer. So by your logic Russell Wilson is a better QB than Dan Marino.

 

 

nope...didn't say that....what I said was it doesn't really matter to me what anyone calls Russell Wilson....he is and always will be a Superbowl Champion....that was my logic

[panthers55]

You can't go wrong with either. Honestly I think that tomorrow night will tell a lot. If Cam plays well in that environment then it is him definitely. We all know he is the more athletic and has the build to be a linebacker. What he has lacked is poise and patience and maturity. Attributes that everyone ascribes to Wilson for good reason. But imagine Cam having similar qualities in his bionic body.

Cam needs to take the next step to make this choice a no brainer. Otherwise it is going to be open for serious debate with good reason.

[CRA]

I'd be happy with either....

I'd take the overall team Wilson has had around him for 3 years over the one Cam has had

Overall Sea has given there QB a better D, better OL and better traditional rush to date....I'd take that

[mc52beast]

Say what you want about Wilson but the kid can ball. Unlike Cam, he scrambles while looking to extend plays with his arm, Cam scrambles and uses his legs. I.believe Cam would have equal numbers and wins if he was surrounded by the right staff and talent. Wouldn't mind having either one.