One Simple Hypothetical

[Jeremy Igo]

If you could magically heal Kelvin Benjamin and have him back this season,  but the cost would be Byron Bell comes with him and starts at left tackle.....  would you? 

 

Seems like a silly queston,  but cuts to the quick on if you think the offense has been upgraded. 

[LUUUUUKE]

Where do I sign?

[Snake]

No,  Cam with time is more deadly than KB. I think that's why the football gods took KB away. It would have been unfair and we need to be punished for using a black cat as our mascot. 

[Dunn]

No....God no.  What use is KB when cam has no time to throw it to him or anyone else for that matter.  

 

 

[Cuttinedge]

I wish KB the best and hope he heels quickly. But there's nothing in this world that could make me want to see Bell in a panthers uni at LT ever again. 

[PhillyB]

nope. the funch can be just as effective as KB if the offensive line gives him time to get open.

[uncfan888]

Jeremy, I think you forgot to switch to your alt account before posting this topic

[KJ89]

Nope. 

[PanthersUnited]

I wouldn't do it. One thing to keep in mind is we are a better team than last year and maybe even the year before. We can spread out and make up for KB's numbers, an example would be Ginn in the return game getting those extra yards that we just couldn't get last year with Bersin, that will go a long way in making up for the lost yards KB would have gotten, I think people underestimate how huge having Ginn back will be in the return game.

 

Really a better question would be, "would you rather have KB back but have Byron Bell back at LT and Bersin back returning punts." 

[PantherWake]

Is that PU? lol but in all seriousiness no. Oher looks like a Average LT so I'd rather have him than Bell and KB

[kungfoodude]

Eh....that depends on if I could be sure that the knee injury won't be nagging. If it ends up hampering the rest of his career, this is obviously a no-brainer(we can jettison Bell in the future). However, if KB bounces back strong next year and in the future, I can stomach one year of not having him to have a serviceable LT option.

[Jangler]

we need KB,,,, but without Cam we might as well close down 2015..hypothetically that is,

[bobsfoodbasics]

no. this can't be a serious question.

[tiger7_88]

My answer.

Not only no, but hell no.