Should #89 be Replaced?

[tiger7_88]

50 minutes ago, Bronn said:

You do realize, that we have this guy named Cam Newton playing QB right now, right?

The same Cam Newton that Steve Smith publicly threw under the bus to the media as a teammate?

[Kakarot]

I agreed with the decision to let him go when Gettleman did a few years ago. With that being said, 89 should not be replaced. He was the Panthers for a long time, and is the best player in this franchises short history. Well, he is at the moment...eventually that will be Cam.

Of course, if he doesn't want to retire a panther, then I don't care if his number is replaced.

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

1 hour ago, Bronn said:

You do realize, that we have this guy named Cam Newton playing QB right now, right?

Nobody is saying that the Panthers suck without Steve Smith, so your rhetorical questions are basically you just talking to yourself.

yeah i didn't say that.  here, i'll explain one more time -

it's just as stupid and overly simplistic and black and white to say "wow steve sure showed us by whooping that ass in 2014 when we played the ravens!" which is what aceboogie said as it would be if someone hypothetically said "wow we went 15-1 and won two straight division titles and a conference title without steve smith!  clearly we don't need him"

so no, i'm not talking to myself.  i'm directly addressing something someone said.  and it is overly simplistic and doesn't take a billion other things into account to look at one game and say "well there's your answer if you're wondering whether releasing this guy was the right move".  it's an analogy.

 

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

and yeah fight me bro i'm waiting

[Devil Doc]

Im a Lover not a Fighter... and when I do fight I fight Dirty..

[Cpt slay a ho]

man i really like TD but saying his number should be retired before smith is ridiculous.......

[Bronn]

14 minutes ago, The NFL Shield At Midfield said:

and yeah fight me bro i'm waiting

[TheRumGone]

13 hours ago, tiger7_88 said:

You mean the guy who made sure the media was always there every time he did anything in the nature of community service looks like he did more than the other guys?

INCONCEIVABLE!

 

Stop fuging posting dude you're embarrassing

[TheRumGone]

For the record I was super pissed with smittys comments after his release and at the time didn't want him back but time heals.

these posters like tiger_87 who just started watching the panthers play need to stay out of threads like this. You have ZERO say in something like this when you didn't watch smitty destroy DBs game after game, year after year for the panthers. His charity work off the field has been the best this organization has had. So bringing up TC fights and acting like you know what the fug you're talking about is pathetic. You're a grown fuging man.

 

 

[KillerKat]

Yes Smith was a Saint and treated everyone with respect. He didn't have a strong me first attitude that rubbed anyone the wrong way. That's why Gettleman let him go. He was just too nice.

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

he's still my favorite panther of all time.  don't think otherwise based on my comments in this thread.

i've still got his jersey and it's going to be un-retired once he's out of the league.

[Devil Doc]

9 minutes ago, The NFL Shield At Midfield said:

he's still my favorite panther of all time.  don't think otherwise based on my comments in this thread.

i've still got his jersey and it's going to be un-retired once he's out of the league.

I have 2 of his Jerseys, Just bought them last year. I have a Reebok Blue Jersey with Sewn Twill Numbers, and a Black Nike with Screenprint (Which was only sold for 2 Years)

[Jon Snow]

He's dead to me.  Give that number to someone else cause there's no way it should be retired.  He was great while here but not great enough to retire that number.  Sorry to all you player worshipers out there but there's only one player that might deserve it currently on the team but I highly doubt even his number will be considered for retirement and that's 58.

[Bronn]

3 minutes ago, Bogart said:

He's dead to me.  Give that number to someone else cause there's no way it should be retired.  He was great while here but not great enough to retire that number.  Sorry to all you player worshipers out there but there's only one player that might deserve it currently on the team but I highly doubt even his number will be considered for retirement and that's 58.

lmgdao... probably will end up in the top 10 WRs of all time list, easily, and that with a majority of poo-scrub QBs around him... but if you're a fan, you are a player worshiper... HAHA

Put Steve Smith in Marvin Harrison's position and Steve Smith is currently #2 or #3 all time WR right now... GTFO with that bullshit...