Hypothetical: You're The Panthers GM And Richardson Swears He Won't Intervene With One Move Of Your Choosing. You Have A First Round Pick...

[rayzor]

[JakeDel5674]

Joe Thomas in 2015 for a first rounder?  Absolutely.  Josh Gordon in 2017-2018 for a First Rounder?  fugKKKKKKKKKKKKK NO.  Maybe a 3rd & a 5th, but that's it.  

[Nails]

5 hours ago, bull123 said:

I’m looking for younger faster quicker stronger versions of stew, TD, Olson, Pep, Adams, Coleman, Kalil 

focusing on more pass rush and more speed 

the only way I give up a first rounder is for a second or third yr superstar

I might have considered giving up a 1st for JJ Watt or Eric Berry this offseason.  And I bet they would have taken it with their salaries, injury histories and no 2018 1st rounders.  But after the hurricane Watt’s never leaving Houston, and the Achilles with Berry makes me leery.

[X-Clown]

I think we've had 800 threads proposing this trade offer since 2013. I thought that surely after he's been out of the league for almost three years that this would be the end of them, but lo and behold the guy is able to play in 2 consecutive games and catches 7 whole passes before the idea circles back again.

[jumpman910]

3 hours ago, top dawg said:

Not a chance!  Now,  we do have an extra third round pick, do we not? 

Kelvin Benjamin is but a memory who gave us two solid seasons, but we live on, and we've proven that we could win without him, so what did we really lose?  So if we can turn an injury risk into a pot risk, but with an infinitely higher skill set,  I'd say, "Let's do it for a third and we got a deal!"

Giving up the extra 3rd and swap out KB for Gordon is a no brainer from a talent prospective. 

[imminent rogaine]

Counter offer. Bersin for one of their first rounders.

[top dawg]

2 hours ago, X-Clown said:

I think we've had 800 threads proposing this trade offer since 2013. I thought that surely after he's been out of the league for almost three years that this would be the end of them, but lo and behold the guy is able to play in 2 consecutive games and catches 7 whole passes before the idea circles back again.

That's  what happens when a guy has likely top five talent. 

[The Huddler]

OP is retarded

 

i wouldnt want it any other way

[top dawg]

2 minutes ago, The Huddler said:

OP is retarded

 

i wouldnt want it any other way

Yeah,  even though he got on my last nerve trying to tell me that Jamison Crowder is greater than Jarvis Landry (to the point of disrespect), and tried to sell me how Russell Shepard was the best thing since sliced bread,  I unblocked him.

[Pantha-kun]

14 hours ago, bobsfoodbasics said:

a 3rd for josh and 2 1st's for antonio brown.

sign me up.

that might wreck the team for a while talent wise without 2 first rounders for 2 years in a row. 

[over the legal limit]

Hell no. Too much of a risk. 

 

Two 3rds and call it a deal

[Pantha-kun]

5 hours ago, top dawg said:

Not a chance!  Now,  we do have an extra third round pick, do we not? 

Kelvin Benjamin is but a memory who gave us two solid seasons, but we live on, and we've proven that we could win without him, so what did we really lose?  So if we can turn an injury risk into a pot risk, but with an infinitely higher skill set,  I'd say, "Let's do it for a third and we got a deal!"

indeed, thats not too bad. once you start getting into the mid rounds the draft is even more of a crapshoot anyways

[Pantha-kun]

1 minute ago, over the legal limit said:

Hell no. Too much of a risk. 

 

Two 3rds and call it a deal

keep in mind we're also missing a 4th this year. big ass hole in the middle of your draft, and we really could use some good talented youth at DE and saftey

[SmokinwithWilly]

32nd pick in the 3rd is like a 4th anyway. I'd offer our 3rd for Gordon, if he fails a drug screen in the next 2 years we get their 4th in the following years draft.