Is CMC ...

[The Huddler]

[ok2h8pep]

John Riggins.   Game was so different that it's hard to make a head to head comparison though

[Khyber53]

The kid is great, so far, but I don't think he's seen the field enough yet to be bandying about the term "greatest" yet. And John Riggins set the mark pretty high. Like get to 100 touchdowns before we can really say.

 

[jfra78]

3rd choice should be "Don't Care"

[Hoenheim]

Its probably safe to assume you mean in the Super Bowl era . TLDR, he's only played 2 seasons. 

Which case, nope. Its mostly an issue of him having an insanely small sample size and no rings. Really if you think about it, hes had one "great" year and there have been plenty of backs who flashed their first few seasons but flamed out pretty quickly.

The key mark of a great RB is how long he can skillfully play. Or if his tenure is a little on the shorter side, he'd benefit from having a ring or two . 

 

[Pantha-kun]

He has only played 2 fuging seasons with 0 playoff wins to his name. 

Really only one great season. Its way too early to say that.  

John Riggins was a while ago but he played 14 seasons,  amassed over 11,000 rushing yards and over 100 rushing TDs 

IMO CMC has got to play at least 10 seasons to even get his foot in the door with that conversation. 

[Pantha-kun]

36 minutes ago, Hoenheim said:

 

The key mark of a great RB is how long he can skillfully play. Or if his tenure is a little on the shorter side, he'd benefit from having a ring or two . 

 

 

[WarHeel]

Who cares if he’s white?

[ForJimmy]

You can make an argument for best in the league right now, but all time.... not yet.

[shaqattaq]

36 minutes ago, WarHeel said:

Who cares if he’s white?

Wait! CMC is white?!?

[raz]

csonka at 64 td's too

[jfra78]

A better poll would be "Is CMC the best Panthers RB" which im not sure he is even that yet.  Being the best white RB means absolutely nothing.

[MountaineerChemist10]

I thought it was blue? Maybe purple? Looks like he has pinch of magenta.

Who the hell cares what skin color CMC has. 

[Piff]

Being the best "white RB" is like being the tallest midget.