Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

would you be opposed to moving back up for Bijan Robinson?


micnificent28
 Share

Recommended Posts

9 minutes ago, Wundrbread33 said:

Basically runningbacks with so so hands are a dime a dozen, yes.
 

A Marshall Faulk type player will always be insanely valuable in the NFL. 

How did that work out for us in terms of wins? How has that worked out for the Giants with Barkley in terms of wins?

RBs just have too short of a shelf life, are too injury prone, and there's too much bargain production at the position to justify huge resources into the position.

  • Beer 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Wundrbread33 said:

Every runningback thread contains people talking about CMC like he is just a runningback.

 

He’s a defense breaking offensive weapon. He’s the best runner and has the best hands on the team as soon as he walks in the building. 
 

Slot corners have issues with him, let alone the linebackers he abuses every play. 
 

Watch some 49er tape if McAdoo’s usage of him is stuck in your head. 

And with all that going for him, he still couldn’t bring more than what amounted to a mid 2nd round pick. Why wasn’t every team throwing 1sts at the team for him? 

  • Beer 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

56 minutes ago, micnificent28 said:

I mean if your fine with Chubba Hubbard being your starting RB. There are exceptions to the rule. Barkley was one of them. when you get one of those guys at their best look what he did for the Giants carried their offense single handedly. I think you look hard at special talents. only reason he would be available at 20 or less is hes at a position thats undervalued.

Barkley was good, but he didn't carry the team by himself. Jones was really the cog that made the Giants go.  The Giants will sacrifice Barkley in a New York minute if it comes down to between Jones and Barkley.

  • Beer 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, kungfoodude said:

It's not really about his best or not his best. Even at his best, it didn't have a dramatic impact on wins and losses. I posted the article here a few seasons ago(around the time we were talking about extending him) and it was a detailed statistical analysis that specifically resulted in win shares for RB's being one of the lowest positions on any NFL offense.

And that has always been the big problem with paying money like that to a RB. This isn't the 70's or 80's or even 90's. It isn't "featured" backs anymore that have 400+ carries a year until they are ground to dust because that is what wins. That's not modern NFL football. RB's are complimentary players and the decline in overall top paid players at the position very much reflects the league recognizing that this has been the trend.

That's the problem a lot of the irrational CMC fanboys have with this argument. It literally has NOTHING to do with CMC the player. It's about the position and how it has evolved into something that doesn't need a $8+ mil/year player. Much less one double that cost.

I don’t disagree.  I think CMC and Barkley are the top 2 RBs in the league and both have lost significant time with injuries.  RBs just don’t last.  They take too much punishment.  Paying them big contracts on their second deal is a huge risk that tends to bomb

I would definitely say CMC had a serious impact on San Fran last season.  They won like every game once he played until Philly.

Edited by Shocker
  • Beer 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Shocker said:

I don’t disagree.  I think CMC and Barkley are the top 2 RBs in the league and both have lost significant time with injuries.  RBs just don’t last.  They take too much punishment.  Paying them big contracts on their second deals is a huge risk that tends to bomb

Yeah, I didn't want to do that at the time and very sadly I was 100% correct in the reasons why we shouldn't have done it. 

It would have been nice to be very wrong and watch him have a Frank Gore-like career here but the data just showed how rarely that happens. 

It is what it is.

So, no to spending a 1st round pick on Robinson. I love him as a player but I have zero desire to fall into that trap again.

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, kungfoodude said:

Yeah, I didn't want to do that at the time and very sadly I was 100% correct in the reasons why we shouldn't have done it. 

It would have been nice to be very wrong and watch him have a Frank Gore-like career here but the data just showed how rarely that happens. 

It is what it is.

So, no to spending a 1st round pick on Robinson. I love him as a player but I have zero desire to fall into that trap again.

Naw…I definitely don’t want to spend a first for us even if we move down on Bijan.
Absolutely not. 

  • Beer 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, kungfoodude said:

CMC's return was legitimately terrible. That's very little his fault but the return was insanely bad. We are 24-34 when he starts games in his career here(for reference we are 15-24 when he doesn't start/play, including after he was traded in 2022).

His stats were great, but the missed games were nuts and I think it's also kind of clear that he isn't quite as explosive as he once was. 

Will always be in the discussion for best RB in franchise history but he is also a case study in why you don't spend money on the position anymore. Unfortunately for us, it was about case file 25 or so. It isn't like there aren't ample examples of why not to pay big money for RB's over the past 20 years.

 

Your talking in terms of contracts? yeah sure it was awful. But im speaking in terms of draft capital and return. You got arugably the best rb in the game who redefines the position. An all time leader for our franchise in a franchise that has invested heavily in the position historically.  On the back end of that you were were able to trade him for a 2,3,4,5 i think which is of huge value for a rb on his secone contract.

Rbs this day and age never return a second. you got almost 1st round value for a guy you rode into the ground.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, Shocker said:

I don’t disagree.  I think CMC and Barkley are the top 2 RBs in the league and both have lost significant time with injuries.  RBs just don’t last.  They take too much punishment.  Paying them big contracts on their second deal is a huge risk that tends to bomb

I would definitely say CMC had a serious impact on San Fran last season.  They won like every game once he played until Philly.

CMC was injured during the majority of 2 seasons, he should have less “wear and tear.” 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, micnificent28 said:

Your talking in terms of contracts? yeah sure it was awful. But im speaking in terms of draft capital and return. You got arugably the best rb in the game who redefines the position. An all time leader for our franchise in a franchise that has invested heavily in the position historically.  On the back end of that you were were able to trade him for a 2,3,4,5 i think which is of huge value for a rb on his secone contract.

Rbs this day and age never return a second. you got almost 1st round value for a guy you rode into the ground.

He didn't redefine the position, TBH. Faulk and LT existed before him, even today there are backs or hybrid players with great catching ability/production. He might be the best overall package, to be sure but he wasn't some new thing.

The trade we made for him was fantastic. WAY more than I ever figured we would get for him given the value. 

But, again, the results were that we didn't win. That is ultimately what matters. You want painful? Mahomes, Watson, TJ Watt, Ryan Ramczyk, etc....those guys were drafted later in the 1st and would like have had a much bigger impact on wins and losses. Because all those guys play much more valuable positions. Not to mention in that draft Dalvin Cook was a 2nd round pick and Alvin Kamara a 3rd. So you could have gotten another elite RB AND an impact player at an high value position.

That will be the problem with taking a 1st round RB for the foreseeable future. 

You think the Giants would still take Barkley at 3? When they could have drafted Allen or Jackson at QB and probably still have gotten Nick Chubb(a better RB than Barkley)? Probably not.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Puravive Reviews (Blissful with Successful Achievements) 21 MAy 2024 Update 27 seconds ago, Tuesday 21 May 2024 07:32:34 Are you looking for an effective weight loss product that can help you achieve your fitness goals? Look no further! Introducing Puravive, a revolutionary weight loss product designed to support your weight loss journey. In this guide, we will explore the key features and benefits of Puravive, how it works, and how you can incorporate it into your weight loss routine. JSH%^GY Click here to buy Puravive from Puravive Official Website at Discounted Rate + Get FREE Shipping + Get 2 FREE Bonus    Puravive is a natural beacon of hope for those on a weight loss journey. It sets itself apart by offering a unique, pure, and natural composition. Its proprietary blend comprises eight powerful tropical nutrients and plant-based compounds, all with clinically proven abilities to enhance brown fat levels, a key component in weight loss. Safety and quality are top priorities for Puravive. Crafted in an FDA-approved and GMP-certified facility, the formula is plant-based, non-GMO, and free from adverse side effects. It comes in an easy-to-swallow capsule form, offering a user-friendly experience. Positive user feedback highlights both its effectiveness and affordability, with occasional bonuses, discounts, and special offers to make the journey to a healthier self accessible and rewarding. Click here to buy Puravive from Puravive Official Website at Discounted Rate + Get FREE Shipping + Get 2 FREE Bonus    Click here to learn more What are the Key Features of Puravive? Natural Ingredients: Puravive is made using a blend of carefully selected natural ingredients that are known for their weight loss properties. These ingredients work synergistically to help you shed those extra pounds. Metabolism Boost: One of the key features of Puravive is its ability to boost your metabolism. A faster metabolism can help you burn calories more efficiently, leading to weight loss. Appetite Suppression: Puravive contains ingredients that can help curb your appetite, making it easier for you to stick to your diet plan and reduce calorie intake. Energy Boost: Puravive provides a natural energy boost, helping you stay active and motivated throughout the day.   What are the Puravive Ingredients? Puravive Formulation and Science Behind Its Ingredients: Puravive’s formulation consists of eight clinically proven ingredients and essential vitamins designed to increase calorie-burning brown adipose tissue (BAT) levels. These ingredients include: Holy Basil: Reduces stress and supports brain function. Kudzu Root: Rich in antioxidants, promoting heart health. White Korean Ginseng: Boosts the immune system and combats oxidative stress. Luteolin: Enhances BAT levels, supports brain health, and regulates cholesterol. Amour Cork Bark: Relieves digestive issues and fortifies cardiovascular health. Propolis: Packed with antioxidants and supports balanced blood sugar levels.   How Does Puravive Works? Puravive works by targeting multiple aspects of weight loss to provide comprehensive support. Here's how it works: Fat Burning: The natural ingredients in Puravive help stimulate fat burning by increasing your metabolism and thermogenesis, allowing your body to burn more calories. Appetite Control: Puravive helps control your cravings and suppress your appetite, making it easier to stick to a healthy eating plan and avoid overeating. Energy Boost: The energy-boosting ingredients in Puravive help combat fatigue and keep you energized, so you can stay active and motivated to exercise regularly. Mood Enhancement: Puravive contains ingredients that promote a positive mood, helping you stay focused and motivated on your weight loss journey. How to Incorporate Puravive into Your Weight Loss Routine? To get the most out of Puravive, here are some tips on how to incorporate it into your weight loss routine: Follow the Recommended Dosage: Take Puravive as directed on the packaging or as advised by your healthcare professional for optimal results Maintain a Healthy Diet Stay Active: Combine the use of Puravive with a consistent exercise routine to maximize your results. Click here to buy Puravive from Puravive Official Website at Discounted Rate + Get FREE Shipping + Get 2 FREE Bonus    End of article     . puravive   puravive reviews                                                                                                                                                                      
    • Last updated 34 seconds ago, Tuesday 21 May 2024 FitSpresso Reviews: Overall, the reviews of FitSpresso are mostly positive (Rating 4.92/5). It seems to be a safe and effective way to help you lose weight without having to make any major lifestyle changes. If you're looking for an easy and convenient way to lose weight, then this product may be worth considering. This FitSpresso reviews will explore whether this weight loss powder can deliver on its claims to increase energy, burn fat, and improve wellbeing using natural ingredients. Fitspresso contains metabolism-activating compounds like green tea, probiotics, and Guarana seed to ignite fat burning while curbing hunger. Click here to Buy FitSpresso and Get Up to 75% DISCOUNT NOW   Click here to Learn More about Fitspresso Coffee   Users say mixing one scoop of FitSpresso into water or a smoothie gives them sustained energy and focus to power through healthy habits and workouts. Keep reading this FitSpresso review to learn more about how its research-backed formula provides an advantage for achieving your weight loss goals. With FitSpresso, get ready to rediscover your zest for life! Losing weight is about more than dropping pounds – it’s about achieving better health. A supplement like FitSpresso that addresses overall wellbeing may offer an adjunct to diet and exercise for those struggling to slim down. Read on for the full FitSpresso Review and decide if it could be right for you. FitSpresso Coffee: A Novel Weight Loss Supplement! The report published by the US National Institutes of Health should raise everyone’s eyebrows as it states one in three adults is overweight. The modern age has offered lots of advantages and people in general lead a life of comfort. It has manifested itself in ways like obesity that most of us tend to ignore. Click here to Buy FitSpresso and Get Up to 75% DISCOUNT NOW   Click here to Learn More about Fitspresso Coffee     What Is FitSpresso? FitSpresso is a weight management formula that promotes healthy weight loss along with multiple health benefits. It is an organic blend of potent natural substances branded as effective in dealing with most of the health ailments we face in our daily lives. The FitSpresso weight loss supplement is made in an FDA-approved facility that is certified by the GMP. It does not have any trace of GMOs or chemical stimulants added in its formulation. It is a natural weight loss aid that can be taken by all adults without age restrictions.   How Does FitSpresso Work? FitSpresso is an herbal weight loss formula that makes use of exogenous ketones that promote weight loss in a fast and effective manner. The supplement’s potent ingredients do not allow fat deposition in the body and help to burn stored fats in a sustainable manner. Besides, it also contains ingredients that help to manage stress and thereby speed up the process of weight loss. It works round the clock and supports metabolic processes in the body throughout. Another advantage that FitSpresso fat burner has is its ability to maintain healthy blood sugar levels. The FitSpresso supplement suppresses sugar cravings and helps you stay mentally focused on your daily activities. It helps consistent fat-burning through thermogenesis, a process in which the body raises its temperature.   FitSpresso Real Customer Reviews FitSpresso has the reputation of receiving maximum numbers of positive feedback in short time frames. The FitSpresso users have opened up their minds and minced no words in complementing the supplement for its effective results. However, not all FitSpresso customer reviews received were positive. We could also see some criticism against it for the delayed action in producing results.   Scientific Evidence Behind Key Ingredients The FitSpresso weight loss supplement is backed by solid scientific evidence. Plenty of studies are available on the ingredients used in the formula and the working principle that it follows. The supplement consists of a proprietary blend of 6 ingredients. All the FitSpresso ingredients used in the supplement are listed below along with scientific studies on the benefits that they offer:   FitSpresso Side Effects FitSpresso, unlike many other supplements, has no chemicals added to its formulation. It is due to this fact that the supplement does not induce any health problems in the long run. There haven’t been any single instances of side effects for it anywhere to date. Please follow the label instructions strictly to avoid overuse of the supplement.   FitSpresso Reviews: Conclusion FitSpresso is a novel weight loss supplement that is formulated using core natural materials specifically designed to manage your body weight. It is made using organic and herbal compounds which have a record of aiding us in health matters. In this FitSpresso review, the supplement is made in high-quality production centers registered under the FDA and certified by GMP which are located in the US. It is made available in the form of healthy capsules which are ideal for oral consumption. FitSpresso has garnered a lot of positive feedback in short periods. In the FitSpresso reviews for weight loss, the user community has made their approval for the supplement public in their positive reviews. The supplement is affordable at lower rates along with added discounts.         Click here to Buy FitSpresso and Get Up to 75% DISCOUNT NOW     Click here to Learn More about Fitspresso Coffee   Click here to Buy FitSpresso and Get Up to 75% DISCOUNT NOW Click here to Learn More about Fitspresso Coffee FitSpresso customer reviews FitSpresso Coffee Reviews FitSpresso FitSpresso Review FitSpresso Real Reviews FitSpresso Reviews Australia FitSpresso Reviews FitSpresso Coffee FitSpresso Coffee Loophole Reviews is Fitspresso Safe?   JHSYUE@^%&*^BJKIO&(*
    • Prodentim Reviews (Critical Customer Warning!) ShOcKinG PRoDeNtim Update May21P$49 18 seconds ago, Tuesday 21 May 2024 07:32:34 Welcome to this review of Prodentim Supplement! In this article, we will take a closer look at this dental health supplement and provide you with an informative and unbiased review. We will explore the ingredients, benefits, potential side effects, and customer feedback to help you make an informed decision about whether Prodentim is right for you.  𝐒𝐚𝐥𝐞 𝐈𝐬 𝐋𝐢𝐯𝐞 𝐒𝐡𝐨𝐩 𝐍𝐨𝐰 𝐎𝐟𝐟𝐢𝐜𝐢𝐚𝐥 𝐖𝐞𝐛𝐬𝐢𝐭𝐞 Click here What is Prodentim Supplement? Prodentim Supplement is a dietary supplement specifically designed to support dental health. It is formulated with a blend of natural ingredients that are believed to promote oral hygiene and support overall gum and teeth health. Click here to buy Prodentim from Prodentim Official Website and Get 75% Discount What are the Ingredients in Prodentim? The Prodentim Supplement contains a unique combination of natural ingredients that work together to support dental health. Some of the key ingredients include: Vitamin Known for its antioxidant properties, vitamin C is essential for collagen production and helps maintain healthy gums. Coenzyme Q10: This powerful antioxidant helps reduce inflammation and supports gum health. Zinc: Zinc plays a crucial role in maintaining healthy teeth and gums and is involved in wound healing. Cranberry Extract: Cranberry extract is believed to help prevent bacteria from sticking to the teeth, reducing the risk of plaque formation. Probiotics: Probiotics are beneficial bacteria that can help maintain a healthy balance of oral microflora, promoting oral health. What are the Prodentim Benefits?  Prodentim Supplement offers several potential benefits for dental health.Some of the key benefits of Prodentim include: Supports Gum Health: The blend of ingredients in Prodentim Supplement, such as coenzyme Q10 and vitamin C, may help support gum health and reduce inflammation. Maintains Healthy Teeth: The inclusion of zinc and cranberry extract in the formula may contribute to maintaining healthy teeth by preventing plaque formation. Promotes Oral Hygiene: The probiotics present in Prodentim Supplement may help maintain a healthy balance of oral microflora, which is essential for good oral hygiene. Prodentim Side Effects Prodentim Dental Supplement is generally considered safe for most individuals when taken as directed. However, it is always recommended to consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new dietary supplement, especially if you have any pre-existing medical conditions or are taking medication.  Prodentim Reviews Customer feedback on Prodentim Supplement has been largely positive. Prodentim has an average rating of 4.85/5. Many users have reported improvements in their gum health and overall oral hygiene after incorporating this supplement into their daily routine. However, individual results may vary, and it is important to keep in mind that dietary supplements may not work the same way for everyone.  Prodentim Conclusion In conclusion, Prodentim Supplement is a dental health supplement that aims to support gum health, maintain healthy teeth, and promote oral hygiene. With its blend of natural ingredients, including vitamin C, coenzyme Q10, zinc, cranberry extract, and probiotics, Prodentim Supplement offers potential benefits for those seeking to enhance their dental health. As with any dietary supplement, it is advisable to consult with a healthcare professional before starting it. Click here to buy Prodentim from Prodentim Official Website and Get 75% Discount Click here to learn more GRE@#@$@@(^**_)( #prodentim prodentim reviews . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . #prodentim                    
×
×
  • Create New...