Starting QB

[Mr. Scot]

I'll just take a moment here to say damn that touchdown pass to Theilen looked good

[scratched]

42 minutes ago, WUnderhill said:

I love how people just assume you can pick and choose which draft you will have the ability to choose a franchise QB.

The last 4 drafts have produced 15 QBs that will start week one. So getting a possible franchise QB happens in nearly every draft. 

[Jon Snow]

9 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

I'll just take a moment here to say damn that touchdown pass to Theilen looked good

I can't wait to see the offense they plan to run. This vanilla crap is tough to watch them try to get open so that Bryce has someone to throw to.  The running game should help with that.

[WUnderhill]

2 hours ago, scratched said:

The last 4 drafts have produced 15 QBs that will start week one. So getting a possible franchise QB happens in nearly every draft. 

Are they all franchise QBs? I assume you must be in the crowd of thinking that just because of outliers like Tom Brady you can just get a franchise QB whenever you please. Brock Purdy is in that list of QBs you mentioned. I suppose we can just make Mr. Irrelevant a good QB whenever we want because that’s definitely how things work. It’s so easy to get QBs up and down the draft, how’s Corral working out? Will Grier? Tony Pike? Jimmy Clausen? Do we need to keep going?

No, what you were talking about is trying to get Maye or Williams, as if we could just hire a HC and attract a decent staff and ask them to tank. Or do you believe it’s every year the team picking #1 with a legit #1 QB available would trade the pick? You’re either a troll or just ignorant.

[Jon Snow]

3 minutes ago, WUnderhill said:

Are they all franchise QBs? I assume you must be in the crowd of thinking that just because of outliers like Tom Brady you can just get a franchise QB whenever you please. Brock Purdy is in that list of QBs you mentioned. I suppose we can just make Mr. Irrelevant a good QB whenever we want because that’s definitely how things work. It’s so easy to get QBs up and down the draft, how’s Corral working out? Will Grier? Tony Pike? Jimmy Clausen? Do we need to keep going?

No, what you were talking about is trying to get Maye or Williams, as if we could just hire a HC and attract a decent staff and ask them to tank. Or do you believe it’s every year the team picking #1 with a legit #1 QB available would trade the pick? You’re either a troll or just ignorant.

He's both.

[scratched]

22 minutes ago, WUnderhill said:

Are they all franchise QBs? I assume you must be in the crowd of thinking that just because of outliers like Tom Brady you can just get a franchise QB whenever you please. Brock Purdy is in that list of QBs you mentioned. I suppose we can just make Mr. Irrelevant a good QB whenever we want because that’s definitely how things work. It’s so easy to get QBs up and down the draft, how’s Corral working out? Will Grier? Tony Pike? Jimmy Clausen? Do we need to keep going?

No, what you were talking about is trying to get Maye or Williams, as if we could just hire a HC and attract a decent staff and ask them to tank. Or do you believe it’s every year the team picking #1 with a legit #1 QB available would trade the pick? You’re either a troll or just ignorant.

I clearly stated getting a POSSIBLE franchise QB. Why do we need the #1 pick to get a franchise QB? Maybe you are the ignorant one? 

Edited August 26, 2023 by scratched

[jfra78]

Bryce's 3rd down play was phenomenal, something we haven't seen here in a long time.  Not since Cam have I thought we had a chance for a fist down on 3rd and long

[scratched]

And for the record.... I've not once said I didn't like Bryce, or didn't think he could be our franchise QB. In my opinion I thought we should have kept DJ, traded down in the draft to acquire more picks. With those picks we could have gotten a few possible starters and built depth. Then we go after our franchise QB. 

[Mr. Scot]

28 minutes ago, scratched said:

And for the record.... I've not once said I didn't like Bryce, or didn't think he could be our franchise QB. In my opinion I thought we should have kept DJ, traded down in the draft to acquire more picks. With those picks we could have gotten a few possible starters and built depth. Then we go after our franchise QB. 

We got our franchise QB.

[Green-Ghost]

On 8/25/2023 at 11:28 AM, Jmac said:

Once they get the Oline fixed and if the WR Corp can stay on their feet....then yes, he is the right guy.

I agree.  The biggest problem I see is the offense line.  Even a GOAT cannot perform if he doesn’t have the time.

 

Edited August 27, 2023 by Green-Ghost

[Ricky Prickles]

19 hours ago, WUnderhill said:

Are they all franchise QBs? I assume you must be in the crowd of thinking that just because of outliers like Tom Brady you can just get a franchise QB whenever you please. Brock Purdy is in that list of QBs you mentioned. I suppose we can just make Mr. Irrelevant a good QB whenever we want because that’s definitely how things work. It’s so easy to get QBs up and down the draft, how’s Corral working out? Will Grier? Tony Pike? Jimmy Clausen? Do we need to keep going?

No, what you were talking about is trying to get Maye or Williams, as if we could just hire a HC and attract a decent staff and ask them to tank. Or do you believe it’s every year the team picking #1 with a legit #1 QB available would trade the pick? You’re either a troll or just ignorant.

You may have to throw Will Grier out here as he looked pretty good and pretty developed last night. Night and day to where he was. It takes a special person to make a starting NFL QB and then even more special to be good at it but unfortunately we have not had good coaching to develop a QB and looks like Grier could be one who slipped through the cracks because of piss poor unskilled coaching that could not develop anything or anyone pertaining to an NFL team. 

[ladypanther]

 

https://www.nfl.com/videos/david-carr-steve-wyche-on-which-rookie-qb-has-impressed-during-preseason

 

 

[PootieNunu]

On 8/26/2023 at 1:19 PM, scratched said:

And for the record.... I've not once said I didn't like Bryce, or didn't think he could be our franchise QB. In my opinion I thought we should have kept DJ, traded down in the draft to acquire more picks. With those picks we could have gotten a few possible starters and built depth. Then we go after our franchise QB. 

Or we could have traded down and drafted a bunch of crap. How many late round guys have we hit on? 

https://www.panthers.com/history/draft

Look at this since Rhule was here, we have hit on our 1st guy I guess and only really one 2nd rounder in Chinn, the rest are jags. 

 

[PootieNunu]

22 hours ago, Ricky Prickles said:

You may have to throw Will Grier out here as he looked pretty good and pretty developed last night. Night and day to where he was. It takes a special person to make a starting NFL QB and then even more special to be good at it but unfortunately we have not had good coaching to develop a QB and looks like Grier could be one who slipped through the cracks because of piss poor unskilled coaching that could not develop anything or anyone pertaining to an NFL team. 

He was playing against nobodies, Grier is a journeyman, not a franchise QB. He played a full game against one of the worst teams in the league, it was also the guys that are going to be cut from said shitty team, running vanilla plays.