shough vs tmac off rookie of the year

[Pejorative Miscreant]

14 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

Look at inspector clouseau over here solving mysteries 

[mav1234]

Shough was 22/27 for 333 yards (12.3 ypa) with 2 tds, a 142.7 rating, and a 81.9 QBR.

Still not enough to get OROTY but he's now got 2125 yards on the season, pretty impressive.

[csx]

Bryce and Canales are going to cost him the award. 

[CRA]

34 minutes ago, mav1234 said:

Shough was 22/27 for 333 yards (12.3 ypa) with 2 tds, a 142.7 rating, and a 81.9 QBR.

Still not enough to get OROTY but he's now got 2125 yards on the season, pretty impressive.

Moves to 5-3 as a starter.  Good odds to finish 6-3.   With his starting numbers he might have an outside shot if both WRs lay an egg in the finale.  Still a long shot but I bet Vegas makes a noticeable change 

[csx]

Shough was a very close second in odds before today's games 

[Moonraker]

Shough should win it, he deserves it.

Edited December 29, 2025 by Moonraker

[CRA]

Shough is now 5-3 in his starts

69.6 comp %, 249 pass yards per game, QB ratings of 97.2 in his 8 starts.   

If he closes out the season w/ a win and plays well?  It will be tough not to give it to him in all honesty if he finishes 6-3 on a 5 game win streak. 

[Sir Big Spurr]

12 minutes ago, CRA said:

Shough is now 5-3 in his starts

69.6 comp %, 249 pass yards per game, QB ratings of 97.2 in his 8 starts.   

If he closes out the season w/ a win and plays well?  It will be tough not to give it to him in all honesty if he finishes 6-3 on a 5 game win streak. 

He’s shown more development/ability in 8 games than Young has in 3 years. 

[CRA]

3 minutes ago, Sir Big Spurr said:

He’s shown more development/ability in 8 games than Young has in 3 years. 

 I do think he has a good playcaller but from watching him play Carolina.......a good amount is just Shough. 

[Panthering]

Shough might just snag this award and it wouldn't be that controversial, would love to see TMac show out against TB and get us into the playoffs though. Ultimately, both teams made good selections here and I was convinced Shough was a joke of a pick. 

[trueblue]

I really wish we could see what TMac could do if he:

1. Had an NFL level QB throwing to him

2. Actually brought both hands with him each time he runs a route.. 

 

 

 

[fanpanther]

if u could trade byounf for shough straight up would u....i would say yes

[kungfoodude]

1 hour ago, trueblue said:

I really wish we could see what TMac could do if he:

1. Had an NFL level QB throwing to him

2. Actually brought both hands with him each time he runs a route.. 

 

 

 

This obsession with the one handed catch is absurd. Not saying he isn't capable but you have to try and get two hands on the ball in more of the scenarios.

[acwimby24]

10 hours ago, Moonraker said:

Shough should win it, he deserves it.

Nah TMac should win iut of sympathy because of who’s throwing the ball to him.