Another hypothetical Bryce poll

[strato]

41 minutes ago, rodeo said:

You guys have circlejerked so hard that you've convinced yourselves it's better to lose in the playoffs if the QB is a guy you don't like. Unhinged behavior on the Huddle these days.

Ooohh I am a bad fan. Make it the Super Bowl instead of this week on that poll and after I quit laughing I will vote to win the game.
 

And it isn‘t “don’t like” it is, he is third tier on a good day.  

 

[nogoodbum]

No vote, missing plays so-so option. 

[Navy_football]

Anyone think Jalen Hurts took Philly to the Super Bowl?

[Waldo]

18 minutes ago, Navy_football said:

Anyone think Jalen Hurts took Philly to the Super Bowl?

Lol he was in a top 10 offense carried by a top 2 defense. Youbg has never been out of the bottom 3rd regardless of the talent around him.

Hurts would be a huge improvement. The Panthers would be 12+ wins with him under center.

Edited yesterday at 09:39 PM by Waldo

[toldozer]

Easy vote for the win. No guarantee that if they bring in a replacement that they'll be any better 

[Cuttinedge]

4 minutes ago, toldozer said:

Easy vote for the win. No guarantee that if they bring in a replacement that they'll be any better 

I vote for the win also but he needs some real competition and there’s plenty to be had 

[PNW_PantherMan]

1 hour ago, Navy_football said:

Anyone think Jalen Hurts took Philly to the Super Bowl?

He was a major part of that offense yeah.  You know that whole unstoppable 1 yard play they made a name for themselves on?  Hurts added value to that offense despite not being an elite passer.  He was good enough.  Something we have not seen here.

[strato]

This doesn’t even matter. In no reality will Bryce Young be gone if we lose this game, because of this poll. Or how we vote. 

And I won’t be hoping we lose. 
If we do somehow win it All I will bow down on my knees and apologize for doubting Bryce Young and all of his stans.

[jfra78]

As much as i want Bryce gone, and hate the way we got in.  If we win and Bryce ahows out, I will be okay with him starting next year 

[strato]

21 minutes ago, jfra78 said:

As much as i want Bryce gone, and hate the way we got in.  If we win and Bryce ahows out, I will be okay with him starting next year 

I think that’s fair. But that 5th year, he has to get two. Or ball out and win one and then play a great game but lose a heartbreaker, I would probably take that. But legit balling out. Playoff heroics and stuff. 

 

[Navy_football]

2 hours ago, Waldo said:

Lol he was in a top 10 offense carried by a top 2 defense. Youbg has never been out of the bottom 3rd regardless of the talent around him.

Hurts would be a huge improvement. The Panthers would be 12+ wins with him under center.

So you think Hurts took Philly to the Super Bowl then, right? 

I disagree. I think he was a passenger but he wasn't driving the ship. 

[Navy_football]

1 hour ago, PNW_PantherMan said:

He was a major part of that offense yeah.  You know that whole unstoppable 1 yard play they made a name for themselves on?  Hurts added value to that offense despite not being an elite passer.  He was good enough.  Something we have not seen here.

Now come on. So Bryce Young offers no value to this offense? Ever? Come on PNW. I think Bryce Young would be a much more successful player if he was drafted by Philly. 

[PNW_PantherMan]

1 hour ago, Navy_football said:

Now come on. So Bryce Young offers no value to this offense? Ever? Come on PNW. I think Bryce Young would be a much more successful player if he was drafted by Philly. 

Correct.  I think he’s a minus out there.  I’m sorry that’s just what I see.  That’s what the numbers say.

[OldhamA]

10 hours ago, CarolinaNut said:

Who would want us to lose?!?  I want to win but also have a coaching staff and front office be objectively smart enough to look at the complete body of work and know it can be better and lead to more sustained success.

Why is everyone getting so up in arms about this?

OP provided two extreme solutions. Short term success, sacrificing long term benefits or the reverse.

There are shades of grey in life, which this poll doesn't account for.