Bryce = Alex Smith

[Panthers Fan 69]

The format is clear as day. Both are 1 overall picks. Both are super conservative and game managers. Smith lead the cheifs to Mahomes. Bryce will lead us to our next true franchise QB.  

[frankw]

Alex Smith was a more efficient passer and had a higher YPA.

They are comparable in some ways but at 6'4 213 Alex Smith was not limited the way Bryce is.

[dep]

i thought Bryce was our franchise QB

Edited January 13 by dep

[kungfoodude]

Smith didn't really pan out until his 7th year in the NFL.

[electro's horse]

Bryce can’t hold Alex smiths jock 

[PleaseCutStewart]

13 minutes ago, kungfoodude said:

Smith didn't really pan out until his 7th year in the NFL.

So you are saying to trust the Matt Rhule 7 year plan with Bryce?

[kungfoodude]

1 minute ago, PleaseCutStewart said:

So you are saying to trust the Matt Rhule 7 year plan with Bryce?

[Dingo_ate_Babies]

18 minutes ago, kungfoodude said:

Smith didn't really pan out until his 7th year in the NFL.

Ding ding ding. Some people here aren’t old enough to remember. Alex Smith was considered a bust for years. He didn’t really start figuring it out until he was about 28 when he went to the Chiefs. 

 

[NAS]

Ok, Colin Cowherd

[electro's horse]

Smith also kept getting hurt because they hadn’t changed the rules yet to let someone that small survive in the nfl.

like how many games do you think Bryce has missed by this point if Defenders are still allowed to land on him?

[kungfoodude]

6 minutes ago, Dingo_ate_Babies said:

Ding ding ding. Some people here aren’t old enough to remember. Alex Smith was considered a bust for years. He didn’t really start figuring it out until he was about 28 when he went to the Chiefs. 

 

It was right at the end of his SF time.

Hence why it makes zero sense to extend Bryce. If your ceiling is Alex Smith(Bryce has nothing near that as his ceiling) then there is no reason to invest in that.

Let's focus on building a team for the future Pat Mahomes, not Alex Smith.

[Aussie Tank]

This is gonna be a long offseason with these types of threads with the same amigos commenting isnt it? 

[toldozer]

If y'all wanna steal my poo at least say so

[h0llywood]

While I'm not the biggest Bryce Young fan, BY's first 3 season's beats Alex Smith's first 3 seasons' out the water, as hard that is to fathom, and it's not even particularly close (even factoring injuries).
 

Alex Smith

Bryce Young