Jump to content

  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Assuming Smitty never gets a ring...

bLACKpANTHER

By bLACKpANTHER,
in Carolina Panthers

How high does Smith need to move up the chart?  

75 members have voted

  1. 1. Where does Smitty need to rank to get into HOF?

    • Top 10 -- +3,000 yards
      43
    • 11-15 -- +2,100-3,000 yards
      16
    • 16-20 -- +1,500-2,100 yards
      3
    • 21-25 -- +1,000-1,500 yards
      0
    • 26-29 -- +500 yards
      0
    • Already HOFer
      13

Recommended Posts

bLACKpANTHER Proficient

bLACKpANTHER

Posted
Posted

How high does he have to climb the charts to get into the HOF?

1. Jerry Rice - 22,895 :) x3

2. Terrell Owens - 15,934

3. Issac Bruce - 15,208 :)

4. Randy Moss - 14,946

5. Tim Brown - 14,934

6. Marvin Harrison - 14,580 :)

7. James Lofton - 14,004

8. Cris Carter - 13,899

9. Henry Ellard - 13,777

10. Tony Gonzalez - 13,552

11. Torry Holt - 13,382 :)

12. Andre Reed - 13,198

13. Steve Largent - 13,089

14. Irving Fryar - 12,785

15. Art Monk - 12,721 :) x3

16. Jimmy Smith - 12,287

17. Charlie Joiner - 12,146

18. Hines Ward - 12,083 :)x2

19. Derrick Mason - 12,061

20. Reggie Wayne - 12,002 :)

21. Michael Irvin - 11,904 :)x3

22. Don Maynard - 11,834

23. Mushin Muhammad - 11,438

24. Rod Smith - 11,389 :) x2

25. Keenan McCardell - 11,373 :) x2

26. Chad Johnson - 11,059

27. Joey Galloway - 10,950

28. Gary Clark - 10,856 :) x2

29. Stanley Morgan - 10,716

30. Steve Smith - 10,574 ???

Underlined = active player

HOFer = red

bP's IMO Future HOFer = green

:) = Superbowl Champion

Link to comment
Share on other sites
LA_Panther Newbie

LA_Panther

Posted
Posted

How high does he have to climb the charts to get into the HOF?

1. Jerry Rice - 22,895

2. Terrell Owens - 15,934

3. Issac Bruce - 15,208

4. Randy Moss - 14,946

5. Tim Brown - 14,934

6. Marvin Harrison - 14,580

7. James Lofton - 14,004

8. Cris Carter - 13,899

9. Henry Ellard - 13,777

10. Tony Gonzalez - 13,552

11. Torry Holt - 13,382

12. Andre Reed - 13,198

13. Steve Largent - 13,089

14. Irvin Fryar - 12,785

15. Art Monk - 12,721

16. Jimmy Smith - 12,287

17. Charlie Joiner - 12,146

18. Hines Ward - 12,083

19. Derrick Mason - 12,061

20. Reggie Wayne - 12,002

21. Michael Irvin - 11,904

22. Don Maynard - 11,834

23. Mushin Muhammad - 11,438

24. Rod Smith - 11,389

25. Keenan McCardell - 11,373

26. Chad Johnson - 11,059

27. Joey Galloway - 10,950

28. Gary Clark - 10,856

29. Stanley Morgan - 10,716

30. Steve Smith - 10,574

Underlined = active player

1. Jerry Rice - 22,895 = Beast

Link to comment
Share on other sites
PantherGuy Community Regular

PantherGuy

Posted
Posted

How high does he have to climb the charts to get into the HOF?

1. Jerry Rice - 22,895

2. Terrell Owens - 15,934

3. Issac Bruce - 15,208

4. Randy Moss - 14,946

5. Tim Brown - 14,934

6. Marvin Harrison - 14,580

7. James Lofton - 14,004

8. Cris Carter - 13,899

9. Henry Ellard - 13,777

10. Tony Gonzalez - 13,552

11. Torry Holt - 13,382

12. Andre Reed - 13,198

13. Steve Largent - 13,089

14. Irvin Fryar - 12,785

15. Art Monk - 12,721

16. Jimmy Smith - 12,287

17. Charlie Joiner - 12,146

18. Hines Ward - 12,083

19. Derrick Mason - 12,061

20. Reggie Wayne - 12,002

21. Michael Irvin - 11,904

22. Don Maynard - 11,834

23. Mushin Muhammad - 11,438

24. Rod Smith - 11,389

25. Keenan McCardell - 11,373

26. Chad Johnson - 11,059

27. Joey Galloway - 10,950

28. Gary Clark - 10,856

29. Stanley Morgan - 10,716

30. Steve Smith - 10,574

Underlined = active player

I love Smitty, but I just don't really see him getting in. He's a good receiver, but an all-time great? I don't know about that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
hepcat Grand Master

hepcat

Posted
Posted

He is one of the best WR's to ever play based on his sheer ability, at least IMO. He carried the passing game on his back for a number of years. If he had Cam as his QB from the start of his career, I don't think this would be a discussion right now. The injury year in '04 and the debacle in '10 hurt his status. He needs to play for 3-4 more years and put up big numbers in each to even have a sniff at the HOF.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • panthers81
      2025-26 First Goal Thread

      By panthers81 · Posted

      Aho tonight
    • ForJimmy
      Hey You, You Don't Know Quarterbacking

      By ForJimmy · Posted

      I only used it because it’s being said he can’t.  I’ve said this 100 times already but these deep passes people get obsessed with are much more on the WR than the QB. If Burrow throws a bomb to Chase and he is either wide open or makes a catch in tight coverage those both are more WR plays than QB to me.  Bryce has shown many flaws but I don’t think throwing the ball 20 yards to a player in coverage is something he or any NFL QB can’t do. He just gets sloppy under pressure and tries some Mahomes type backfoot throws that do require elite arm strength in which he does not have. 
    • kungfoodude
      Adam Thielen on Young

      By kungfoodude · Posted

      Again with the straw man arguments. You have Trump level of delusions about this subject.  Here, let me do you in this case.... I don't know if AT fuged your girl or your wife or whatever but your level of hatred towards a guy not even on the team is insane. I can't believe you keep hate watching all these Vikings games as a result. It's crazy behavior but, by all means, you do you.   Now...see how nutty that sounds? Go read this thread and see how emotional you are over something no one in this thread is talking about emotionally. 
×
×
  • Create New...