Game on the line... you going with Beason, Morgan or Keuchly....

[bleys]

Nah, it is a simple question asking for opinion.

Pick one. There is no wrong answer. It is an opinion based question. Not a pass fail type question. Just a simple question designed to illicit debate. In that vein, it worked.

Exactly what I said.

And it works...

[PantherBoy95]

As they said this is very situational. If I needed a sure fire tackle I would go with Kuechly he doesn't try to do too much, and the majority of the time gets the job done. If I needed a big game changing hit/turnover whether it be FF or INT I would go with Beason.

[Kakarot]

Give me Beason.

[SuperMan]

In what world would you take Jenkins over peppers lol. One of the best defensive ends in NFL history over a(pro bowl caliber) run stuffing DT? Sorry but give me pep and it's not even close. On any given play pep could not be blocked.

Before overheating and acl tears Jenkins was lot more than a run stuffer but I am willing to be you haven't been a fan long enough to remember that.

[micnificent28]

Before overheating and acl tears Jenkins was lot more than a run stuffer but I am willing to be you haven't been a fan long enough to remember that.

I've been a fan probably longer than you sir. But,even before all of the injuries he still was not the caliber of player peppers was.

[AceBoogie]

If its one play to win the game I'm going with Beason. Simple enough?

[rico6]

Thomas "Repri-MAN" Davis all day. I've never seen the guy miss a BIG tackle since his position switch.

[L-TownCat]

My money is on Keek. This kid is already on another level. He has innate abilities that you just can't teach or find. He will be the definition of Middle LB for years to come.

[fieryprophet]

I have nothing to add other than the fact that we can actually have this discussion shows that this team knows its linebackers, as we've had excellent MLBs for a number of years.

[micnificent28]

He was virtually unblockable in any aspect of the game. You'd have to be asinine not to place him on par with Peppers. Jenkins was the NFL's best DT, and it wasn't close. Even when he left Carolina with a weaken mindset and knees, Kris was the frontrunner for DPOY with The Jets.

Comparing a pro bowl dt to one of the greatest pass rushed and most freakiest athletes ever? This isn't a real conversation is it?

[Wundrbread33]

Comparing a pro bowl dt to one of the greatest pass rushed and most freakiest athletes ever? This isn't a real conversation is it?

 

The thing with Jenkins is that his body just broke down carrying the weight that he did.

 

Peppers is an athletic freak yes, which has led to a prolonged and healthier career.

 

Now in his prime, Jenkins was the top DT in the league and everyone knew it. He consistently blew up double teams and he made our defensive line.

 

Unlike Jenkins, it was always a debate whether Peppers was the best end in the league because some games he just wouldn't show up. His lack of consistency will always be talked about. Maybe expectation was too high, but with his body and athleticism, he should have had 20+ sack seasons. He never had that drive though.

 

Jenkins caused chaos to the interior line every play during his prime and I have yet to see a DT perform like he did since.

[Mr. Scot]

Jenkins caused chaos to the interior line every play during his prime and I have yet to see a DT perform like he did since.

 

There is the possibility that may change this season.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Give me Na'il Diggs.

[The Golden Child]

Sean Tufts