How many more times will Philly Brown muff a punt before he's pulled?

[Sam Mills Fan]

I fully believe if Cason hadn't recovered that muff from earlier, we would have lost that game. That's how close we came. How many more times can the coaches afford to send him out there?

[osd22]

It wasn't muffed, it got punched out.

[Sam Mills Fan]

I don't think you're remembering that correctly, doesn't really matter though. We don't have confidence that Philly Brown won't just give the ball back when he's back there. What do we do? Suck it up and pray it doesn't cost us the playoffs or cut someone and sign a known returner off the street?

[cbully]

and who do you have in mind to replace him... ?

[Sam Mills Fan]

and who do you have in mind to replace him... ?

 

I'd rather sign a recently retired old-ass returner that can at least field punts cleanly than risk Philly Brown back there.

[La Pantera]

Regardless,he has an issue holding onto the ball. I think he'll work it out, but he has to learn the basics. He should've called fair catch. I'm to the point where I'm worried every punt.

[TheCandyMan]

I don't think you're remembering that correctly, doesn't really matter though. We don't have confidence that Philly Brown won't just give the ball back when he's back there. What do we do? Suck it up and pray it doesn't cost us the playoffs or cut someone and sign a known returner off the street?

 

Armanti Edwards is available.

[t96]

I don't think you're remembering that correctly, doesn't really matter though. We don't have confidence that Philly Brown won't just give the ball back when he's back there. What do we do? Suck it up and pray it doesn't cost us the playoffs or cut someone and sign a known returner off the street?

 

 

No you're not remembering it correctly. He caught it cleanly then after a second or two he got hit from behind and it came out. Poor awareness in not calling the fair catch was the only problem with that play. Philly will improve once he goes through film. Even if it just takes him calling a fair catch every single time, then so be it.

[csx]

I'd rather sign a recently retired old-ass returner that can at least field punts cleanly than risk Philly Brown back there.

Who?

[nickzz]

No you're not remembering it correctly. He caught it cleanly then after a second or two he got hit from behind and it came out. Poor awareness in not calling the fair catch was the only problem with that play. Philly will improve once he goes through film. Even if it just takes him calling a fair catch every single time, then so be it.

 

he never caught it cleanly. it was bobbling around and then got punched out.

[KillerKat]

Who?

Cribbs

[4Corners]

I like him as a WR prospect - but he isn't our PR. He's shook. Could end up costing us down the road. He didn't lose the Pitt game for us but his fumble was the nail in the coffin. I'd be willing to bet we lose today if Cason doesn't recover his fumble in the 2H.

[t96]

he never caught it cleanly. it was bobbling around and then got punched out.

 

No.

[Sam Mills Fan]

Who?

 

How about Micheal Spurlock?