Is this real? (Trading Newton)

[PantherBrew]

Frank is a douche.  

[Mr. Scot]

random person with 30 follwers tweets something leading to 30 page debate on trading cam

 

I'm not really seeing any 'debate' here.

 

It's mostly a bunch of people piling on saying "no, this is stupid and the guy who started it is a douche'.

 

[uncfan888]

Lol, we'll of Cleveland radio says it, it must be true... Smh...

Maybe he just meant ham radio?

I hope he lives in Cleveland.. otherwise, who sits around listening to Cleveland radio?

I personally think he's lying and made it all up

[Cary Kollins]

#gettledouche

[rippadonn]

You mean saying it's true, or saying he would do the trade if it was on the table?

Either way, isn't this the same Garcia that gave away his money to a stranded Nigerian prince who contacted him by email for help?

It was the IRS scam

[PanthersUnited]

I'm sorry, I know im in the minority but my opinion has been that while Cam is good he is not elite good like Rodgers, Tom Brady or Manning and as such, if a good enough trade came about I would not be opposed. I like Stafford better as an overall passer. I just think he is overrated by Panther fans, don't get me wrong, he's a solid QB, I'm not saying he's bad, I just don't think he's elite and untouchable as some on here think he is

[Rags]

it's not even noon yet.

 

time for another great day on the carolina huddle

[uncfan888]

Stafford is a joke. Give Cam CJ and Tate and watch him work

[Rags]

I'm sorry, I know im in the minority but my opinion has been that while Cam is good he is not elite good like Rodgers, Tom Brady or Manning and as such, if a good enough trade came about I would not be opposed. I like Stafford better as an overall passer. I just think he is overrated by Panther fans, don't get me wrong, he's a solid QB, I'm not saying he's bad, I just don't think he's elite and untouchable as some on here think he is

 

so

 

trade for matthew stafford who has done so much less

 

with SO MUCH MORE talent around him.

 

 

Yeah. Okay.

[Mr. Scot]

I'm sorry, I know im in the minority but my opinion has been that while Cam is good he is not elite good like Rodgers, Tom Brady or Manning and as such, if a good enough trade came about I would not be opposed. I like Stafford better as an overall passer. I just think he is overrated by Panther fans, don't get me wrong, he's a solid QB, I'm not saying he's bad, I just don't think he's elite and untouchable as some on here think he is

 

You think Newton is overrated and you wanna trade for Stafford?

 

Stafford is a guy who puts up big stats but chokes and loses games in clutch situations.

 

I wouldn't trade a ham sandwich for a QB who fades when the chips are down.

[XClown1986]

So this is fake... Right?

[Hawk]

there was a guy who called into the nfl channel on sirius this morning claiming to be from North Carolina that suggested the panthers should trade Newton to the chargers for Rivers.

 

enjoying the offseason yet?!!!!

[stirs]

I don't think much of Stafford at all.

 

The only guy I could see in a trade might be Rivers.  He wants to come back to the South and bring his large family.

 

He is a better passer than Cam, but Cam the better athlete and runner.  Probably a toss up

[Car123]

Same Stafford that couldn't win the division when Aaron Rodgers was out for weeks.