Is Kuechly the Panthers GOAT?

[luke nukem]

1 hour ago, MVPccaffrey said:

Smith, Luke and Pep are the top 3 and no one else is close

Cam

 

1 hour ago, Panthers2019 said:

top 5 Panthers Greats

1.Steve Smith

2.Luke

3.Peppers

4.Jake

5.Cam

Cam > Jake where is jake's MVP?

[luke nukem]

how you guys can just disrespect the ONLY NFL MVP WE HAVE EVER HAD is beyond me

[mc52beast]

When looking at who is the GOAT you have to take into consideration what Luke has to do as the MLB... he puts players in the right positions and he basically knows what the offense is doing. Players say that about him all the time.

Peppers is the best DE this team will probably ever have

Smitty is the best wr this team has ever had 

Luke, if he can continue his level of play for a few more years will be the Panthers GOAT

[MHS831]

Luke is the best football player this team has known and here is why--he is a leader, he is one of the best ever at his position, and he is a superior athlete.

Cam and Peppers are also superior athletes, but only Peppers (of the two)  is one of the best at his position, but he is no leader--Cam is a leader, but not one of the best ever at his position--depending on how you assess the position.  While Peppers and Luke are near locks for Canton, Cam is not so certain.

So Luke is the total package.

[Ricky Spanish]

4 hours ago, Panthers2019 said:

top 5 Panthers Greats

1.Steve Smith

2.Luke

3.Peppers

4.Jake

5.Cam

I'd put Cam over Jake these days.

And TD over Cam as well personally. 

[GeorgeHanson]

2 hours ago, luke nukem said:

Cam

 

Cam > Jake where is jake's MVP?

Jake = 59% win rate.

Cam = 56% win rate.

59% > 56%

[GeorgeHanson]

1 hour ago, mc52beast said:

When looking at who is the GOAT you have to take into consideration what Luke has to do as the MLB... he puts players in the right positions and he basically knows what the offense is doing. Players say that about him all the time.

Peppers is the best DE this team will probably ever have

Smitty is the best wr this team has ever had 

Luke, if he can continue his level of play for a few more years will be the Panthers GOAT

Well said.  Don't think Luke relies on anyone else to help him call sets/plays.

[bigskypanthersguy]

I'd put Luke above Cam and Peppers.  Smith is another story, but then I'm biased.

[OriginalPantherDan]

Luke is absolutely the best Panthers player of all time. He hasn’t had Peps longevity, but that doesn’t matter. He’s won so many awards and accolades already that he deserves the title even if he retired tomorrow. 

[t96]

4 hours ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Not amount the best Panthers? Of you want to say he isn't the defensive GOAT, that's fine. Thats understandable. But there's no argument against him not at least being #2. He's not just the Panthers all-time sack leader, he's nearly 30 ahead of #2.

I’m just saying Pep isn’t up there with the top tier of all time great Panthers in Smitty, Cam, Mills, TD, Luke

[LinvilleGorge]

5 minutes ago, t96 said:

I’m just saying Pep isn’t up there with the top tier of all time great Panthers in Smitty, Cam, Mills, TD, Luke

Interesting you list Mills when he only played three of his twelve season in Carolina. Peppers has played 10 of his 17 seasons in Carolina. He's absolutely a top tier Panther.

[nosuchthingasapanther]

steve smith offensive goat.

julius peppers defensive goat.

 

[Daddy_Uncle]

3 hours ago, Floppin said:

People still ranking Jake higher than Cam. Lofugingl

People forget just how great Jake was for us until his arm was done

[t96]

7 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Interesting you list Mills when he only played three of his twelve season in Carolina. Peppers has played 10 of his 17 seasons in Carolina. He's absolutely a top tier Panther.

It's about impact on the team. Mills was our veteran leader from the start and only player to start all our games the first 3 seasons, a huge reason for getting to the NFC Championship game so soon, and then obviously his impact as a coach and in 2003...