Corral to IR is a good thing….

[Panthers Fan 69]

Officially forces Rhule to Redshirt him. For him to go from one read zone read to full read and progressions he needs to sit and study. It worked for Rodgers and Mahomes.  THIS IS A GOOD THING 

[Popsickle]

He would have gotten a “redshirt year” without being hurt. 

[Panthers Fan 69]

Just now, Popsickle said:

He would have gotten a “redshirt year” without being hurt. 

Key word “forces”. Do you trust Rhule to make the right decision in time of need?

[Carolina Cajun]

Without even reps, it's not gonna help too much.  Rodgers and mahomes sat, but both were on the active roster taking real reps in practice, ir kills corral for this season.  He might bulk, but he's not gonna be much if at all further along next year compared to now because if this designation.

[toldozer]

5 minutes ago, Panthers Fan 69 said:

Officially forces Rhule to Redshirt him. For him to go from one read zone read to full read and progressions he needs to sit and study. It worked for Rodgers and Mahomes.  THIS IS A GOOD THING 

Yeah him missing a year worth of practice is a good thing.  Now if we suck this year we have no choice but drafting a qb making him 2 wasted picks

[top dawg]

2 minutes ago, Popsickle said:

He would have gotten a “redshirt year” without being hurt. 

Obviously, the better thing...

[top dawg]

Now he can't get anything but get those (oh so important) mental Reps that Rhule so highly praised.

[Popsickle]

9 minutes ago, Panthers Fan 69 said:

Key word “forces”. Do you trust Rhule to make the right decision in time of need?

I don’t think he would make a good decision ever, so it’s clearly worse that he is hurt and will be limited. 

[top dawg]

1 minute ago, stbugs said:

They were also 1st round picks with a poo load more talent. Comparing Corral to Wilson because he was a 3rd round pick or Rodgers and Mahomes because he’ll sit a year is a losing strategy. I was hopeful but honestly, he doesn’t look the part and he’s not likely to make big strides this year. I’m right back on my let’s draft a first round QB this year in what appears to be a solid draft class.

We almost have to draft a QB, especially if Baker flops--which in that case Rhule will be fired. Bring in a new coach who gets his guy, and it's conceivable that Corral ends up in the same boat. He's certainly not going to make any big strides this year. Being drafted by the Panthers might have been the worst thing that could've happened to Corral. 

[Jon Snow]

[WOW!!]

8 minutes ago, top dawg said:

We almost have to draft a QB, especially if Baker flops--which in that case Rhule will be fired. Bring in a new coach who gets his guy, and it's conceivable that Corral ends up in the same boat. He's certainly not going to make any big strides this year. Being drafted by the Panthers might have been the worst thing that could've happened to Corral. 

That was probably going to happen anyway if he didn't get injured..

[top dawg]

5 minutes ago, WOW!! said:

That was probably going to happen anyway if he didn't get injured..

You don't know that, and neither does anyone else.

[mav1234]

this is not a good thing - as a 3rd rounder he had an uphill battle to even make it as a backup. A significant injury makes that even less likely.

[Davidson Deac II]

26 minutes ago, top dawg said:

We almost have to draft a QB, especially if Baker flops--which in that case Rhule will be fired. Bring in a new coach who gets his guy, and it's conceivable that Corral ends up in the same boat. He's certainly not going to make any big strides this year. Being drafted by the Panthers might have been the worst thing that could've happened to Corral. 

The problem comes if Baker is not a flop, but not great, ie he is somewhere in between.  Then we have to decide whether we draft another qb (assuming we can get one we want), or resign Mayfield, or something else.