Best QB? Stroud or Young

[Shocker]

Lets stop messing around…who is your #1 QB in this draft?  Your choices are CJ Stroud or Bryce Young

[Shocker]

On record…Bryce Young

Why?  I love QBs that step on campus and dominate immediately.  Both players started a game and were the guys. No transferring and no questions.  Young has been the best QB IMO from day 1.  He missed a few games diving for a first down and returned quickly.  
Posting my comps I would say this…

Young is similar to Mahomes

Stroud is similar to Goff

 

Edited February 3, 2023 by Shocker

[therealmjl]

Want either but I’m team Young all day

[LinvilleGorge]

If Young was 3" taller and 30 pounds heavier I'd confidently say Young. But he's not so it's a debate.

Honestly, I'd probably draft Stroud. Young's size scares me. I just really struggle seeing him hold up to NFL hits. Maybe it's because of watching former Bama QB get ragdolled and concussed repeatedly.

[Wolfcop]

Young is the best pure QB. Stroud may last longer, though. 

[GOAT]

wow wasn't expecting the Young love.

Young is too short for me. Great QB, amazing ability to escape and pin point accuracy. I'm just too scared to take a chance on a guy with that frame and in a league where everyone is taller, faster, stronger.

My player comp for Young is Russ Wilson.

Stroud is the best QB, he has the size and the arm to be great. He was a missed FG away from beating the best team in college over the last two years with his arm AND legs which is not usual for him.

My player comp for Stroud is Justin Herbert.

[ncfan]

Bryce

if he was the same size as Stroud.  People would be speaking about him in the same level as Andrew Luck and Trevor Lawerence level prospect 

I still say he’s the better prospect but Stroud is one heckuva consolation prize.

Some are scared by the size.  But the height to me is the most overblown thing by people and honestly a non issue.  The frame?  If he comes in at sub 190, I may be a little nervous.  But don’t see that happening.

Edited February 3, 2023 by ncfan

[TheCasillas]

Team Levis. I will eat crow if I’m wrong a couple years from now. However, I think Levis will be one of the top QBs from this draft. 
 

note: I will retract these thoughts if Levis flops his combine. So leave me that reservation.

[JawnyBlaze]

The only thing Young has on Stroud is escapability. Stroud has been my #1 from the beginning. 

[Shocker]

Hearing many folks here that know QBs talk about size concerns is interesting.  If a player might drop it is probably Bryce.  Damn…I hope so.  
I personally can’t see any team taking Levis before Bryce.  

Edited February 3, 2023 by Shocker

[ncfan]

1 minute ago, Shocker said:

Hearing many folks here that know QBs talk about size concerns is interesting.  If a player might drop it is probably Bryce.  Damn…I hope so.  

Weight is my only issue.  If he comes in at sub 190.  That when I have a problem.  The height is a non issue.

[jayboogieman]

Young is the best QB in this draft. That said, Stroud is a fairly close second.

[Shocker]

1 minute ago, ncfan said:

Weight is my only issue.  If he comes in at sub 190.  That when I have a problem.  The height is a non issue.

I hear you.  He is like historically small.  This can’t be denied.  I wonder what Doug Flutie would have done in the league but he isn’t as small.  If we draft Young I think we have the best QB in the NFC next season.  And no…he doesn’t sit.  He starts.

[ForJimmy]

12 minutes ago, TheCasillas said:

Team Levis. I will eat crow if I’m wrong a couple years from now. However, I think Levis will be one of the top QBs from this draft. 
 

note: I will retract these thoughts if Levis flops his combine. So leave me that reservation.

I think Levis will dominate the combine for what it’s worth.