Simms top QB prospects

[NAS]

 

[NAS]

 

[NAS]

 

[OldhamA]

9 minutes ago, 45catfan said:

The ACL is the only reason Hooker will likely not go in the first round.  Hooker is a more complete QB than AR at this point.

He's also like 4 years older.

[NAS]

Just now, OldhamA said:

He's also like 4 years older.

Right, by the time he gets to his second contract he’s already in his 30s

[MHS831]

52 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Simms is just a hot take artist. He had Zach Wilson over Lawrence. Mac Jones and Kellen Mond of all people over Justin Fields

 

Exactly-when I opened this thread, I was expecting some radical take.  As players, I do not see Young and Stroud on different levels.  I see the same level, different tools

[MHS831]

Hooker could turn out to be the best value--I do think he will emerge to be better than one or more of the top 4 QBs--AR or Levis-maybe.

[t96]

lol at Hooker in the same tier as Young but otherwise the order isn't too far off. But yeah give us Stroud and I'm happy, so he missed on Corral whatever, Stroud is legit.

[45catfan]

1 minute ago, OldhamA said:

He's also like 4 years older.

The ACL is a lot more worrisome than his age.  He's not 36-years old.  It's rare to hit on a QB in the draft and even rarer they stay with their draft franchise their entire career. To that end, being a few years older isn't that big of a deal.  It also means he's more experienced. 

[45catfan]

Unless he's a first rounder, he'll be 30 by his second deal.  That's not old in QB years.

Edited March 20, 2023 by 45catfan

[hepcat]

I have to wonder if the Panthers are gonna draft 2 QBs like the 2012 Redskins. 

[kass]

24 minutes ago, rebelrouser said:

No way in hell he thinks Young drops to second round so those figures on the left are their qb rank. LOL at Levis. 

Of course the one on the left is the rank. 

I was asking for the definition of the tiers. 

and especially the 4th tier with Dorian, DTR, if it says something about what round. (Doesn't seem so) Not heard DTR being suggested in rounds 1, 2,3 before so either he is high on him or really low on Levis. 

[Panthering]

Always enjoy Simms QB analysis, he's not perfect & no one is. But he dives in pretty deep and always has some insightful comments, looking forward to his breakdown of this.

[Wolfcop]

3 minutes ago, Panthering said:

Always enjoy Simms QB analysis, he's not perfect & no one is. But he dives in pretty deep and always has some insightful comments, looking forward to his breakdown of this.

Agreed - you have to put yourself out there when you do this sort of thing. He has nailed a few that GMs and coaches got wrong, but he has also missed significantly on a few. It happens to everyone.