Jump to content

  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

If there was a re draft when would Young be taken?

Shotgun

By Shotgun,
in Carolina Panthers

 Share

If there was a re draft when would Young be taken?  

176 members have voted

  1. 1. If there was a re draft when would Young be taken?

    • #1
      24
    • #2-#5
      70
    • Not in the top 10
      35
    • Not in the first round
      47

Recommended Posts

stratocatter Mentor

stratocatter

Posted
Posted (edited)

 

11 hours ago, recceice said:

A lot of opinion with no facts.. We don’t know what Bryce weights right now and yes I refuse to quibble over 2 inches being that big of a difference…

And you can miss me with all that “my man “ poo.. I’m a panther fan and he is a panther player now.. I will support him as long as he represents that jersey.. If you’re a panthers fan he is your QB now so deal with it..

1st, not my job to deal with it. it is their job, and I am complaining about dereliction of common sense in gambling. Lol.

 

Anyhow, no he will only get on scales after ballooning himself up and everyone knows that is what he did. You can look at him on the field and at Alabama (finally, a still relevant use for his college tape ha).

It really is disingenuous to pretend you do think he weighs close to 209, or not 184 or maybe okay 186, he is factually freaking smaller than Brees. By a percentage and that is going to stay relative. 

It is a totally valid point and it doesn't fit what you want things to be. That's about it.

Next there is nothing that says to be a fan a person has to blindly blindly praise what is looking like a clusterfug of the highest order. I am not emotionally attached to this player, so many seem to be. 

"as long as he wears that jersey". How noble of you. Does TMJ or Icky or Sanders, or CJ or Fitt or Reich, or any other underperforming Panther get the same pledge?

And the 2" it may or may not have been noted that I only made mention of the height difference and did not extrapolate but it is definitely there and it is definitely a fact that Young is not a one to one comp with Drew Brees. It's not that close and if you would open your mind and look at what I am trying to illustrate, it could be helpful. 

And please do go ahead and define that as my opinion, if that makes you feel better. 

Edited by stratocatter
  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
recceice Proficient

recceice

Posted
Posted
12 hours ago, stratocatter said:

 

1st, not my job to deal with it. it is their job, and I am complaining about dereliction of common sense in gambling. Lol.

 

Anyhow, no he will only get on scales after ballooning himself up and everyone knows that is what he did. You can look at him on the field and at Alabama (finally, a still relevant use for his college tape ha).

It really is disingenuous to pretend you do think he weighs close to 209, or not 184 or maybe okay 186, he is factually freaking smaller than Brees. By a percentage and that is going to stay relative. 

It is a totally valid point and it doesn't fit what you want things to be. That's about it.

Next there is nothing that says to be a fan a person has to blindly blindly praise what is looking like a clusterfug of the highest order. I am not emotionally attached to this player, so many seem to be. 

"as long as he wears that jersey". How noble of you. Does TMJ or Icky or Sanders, or CJ or Fitt or Reich, or any other underperforming Panther get the same pledge?

And the 2" it may or may not have been noted that I only made mention of the height difference and did not extrapolate but it is definitely there and it is definitely a fact that Young is not a one to one comp with Drew Brees. It's not that close and if you would open your mind and look at what I am trying to illustrate, it could be helpful. 

And please do go ahead and define that as my opinion, if that makes you feel better. 

Lol.. 

Im not spending 3 paragraphs to quibble about weight we don’t know and 2 inches.. 

You don’t think Brees and BY are comparable in size.. Okay I do.. 

Agree to disagree..

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • 4 weeks later...
  • 4 weeks later...
Green-Ghost Rising Star

Green-Ghost

Posted
Posted

Hmmmm,, this might be an “apples and oranges” kind of question.  This question could easily be reworded as, “if I knew then what I know now.”  The problem is there is no way to know back then.

I do have a question however, I would like to know what factors went into the decision to draft young?  What criteria did they use?in other words, why did they make the decision to draft young in the first place, other than some of the other quarterback talent.


did they take the time and effort to compare young with the other quarterback candidates or did they draft young because he was a product of Alabama.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • d-dave
      Does anyone actually think Bryce will actually be good?

      By d-dave · Posted

      The problem that Bryce faces is his lack of prototypical tools.  He's not the tall, strong armed mobile QB that tends to get drafted first overall.  His game is not played in underwear on a practice field.  His best asset are his intangibles.  They aren't sexy like a cannon arm or a fast 40 yard dash. OK, so we took the lesser athlete.  Bryce put up a pretty bad season with a bad team around him.  The coaching staff, for all it's platitudes, sucked.  They made sure Bryce could run a huddle, but didn't help him get better as a player.  Bad choice. Compare that to what other teams did to their Rookies:  they put them in position to succeed with better personnel and better play calling.  Sure, there are physical differences which are going to affect the outcomes, but you can't change it. Am I trying to ride to the defense of Bryce?  Only a little.  He's my favorite team's QB, and I believe in him.  Now, he's got this year to show that he's "the No. 1 for a reason" (Thanks CJ Stroud).  Will he, won't he?  I don't know at all.  That's on the D&D crew to put Bryce is position to play well.  Running the ball is going to make things a lot easier for Bryce.  Does that discount his success if he plays well?  For some of y'all it will.  Some of y'all just don't like Bryce, like he stole you DoorDash or something. Regardless, let's see what happens in 2024.  If Bryce stinks it up, then we're going back to the QB well again.  
    • rayzor
      Does anyone actually think Bryce will actually be good?

      By rayzor · Posted

      we may think we know, but we don't know. we won't know what effect upgrades on the OL, coaching staff, and WR room will have. we don't know what scheme canales is going to put together. we don't know a lot of things.  that's why we play the games...to see what shakes out. plenty of reasons to think Bryce is limited this year...again. Plenty of reasons to see an improvement in his play. 
    • MHS831
      Does anyone actually think Bryce will actually be good?

      By MHS831 · Posted

      He did not elevate the players around him, but they de-elevated their QB.  A QB like Bryce needs a system, a strong OL, a Running game, and WRs that can get open.  Call him a manager at best, but so is a point guard.  That is all we should need.  He is smart enough to grow into a very effective player.  I once saw a Coach talking about the OL--i forget who it was Schottenheimer comes to mind--and he said, you can succeed if you have one weak link on the OL.  If you get 2 weak links, success comes 10x harder.  If you get three weak links, your season is over.  Your QB is injured, and you are unemployed (paraphrasing).  I would say that we had 4 weak links (Icky does not get a pass) and a RB who was not good at pass blocking. I am not saying the Bryce is the answer at QB--but I am saying we don't know yet. I know QBs (college) and when the OL sucks, they collapse mentally over time.  That is what we saw--a QB who had never played without the advantage.
×
×
  • Create New...