was the armanti edwards trade the worst in franchise history?

[panthers55]

This is the same discussion we had about Brown last year and frankly could again. Like all rookies they get some time to evaluate them. At this point he is no worse than Jarrett. Lets see what happens in a new system.

[Panthro]

No, but it did prove that App Fans are the most annoying fanbase

[SnarkAttack]

Keep in mind that the pick we gave up was a 2011 2nd rounder, so it wouldn't be fair to judge anything prior to the 2011 season, b/c we wouldn't have had that pick anyway....

[tondi]

Until the guy actually gets on the field it's impossible to say. Of course, this throw away season would have been the perfect opportunity to get him some reps but we all know Fox would rather sign somebody elses reject off the street on Monday and play them on Sunday than give his own draft picks a chance.

[Panthro]

Until I get on the field it is impossible to say that I am not a Pro Bowl TE.

[Mvp2014]

Until I get on the field it is impossible to say that I am not a Pro Bowl TE.

i know man, I'm pretty sure I'm the next Brian Cushing but I never get on the field

[Sloth]

If burning a 2nd is in play as one of our franchises worst mistakes we're doing pretty ok.

[Kettle]

If burning a 2nd is in play as one of our franchises worst mistakes we're doing pretty ok.

I'd rather be positioned like the pats with 6 picks in the first 3 rounds.

[Sloth]

I'd rather be positioned like the pats with 6 picks in the first 3 rounds.

Yeah, but they need the extra ammo because of how terrible they draft.

[AceMan]

Keep in mind that the pick we gave up was a 2011 2nd rounder, so it wouldn't be fair to judge anything prior to the 2011 season, b/c we wouldn't have had that pick anyway....

That wouldn't work because if he was doing well, we wouldn't use that same logic

Also, I actually consider the Delhomme extension as one of the worst in franchise history despite the excuses that it saved cap, Peppers forced it on us, and/or it didn't hurt us in a cap-free season

[bigdog10]

IF AE performs better than the #33 pick in this draft then the answer is no

[pantherclaw]

I like the fact that the front office has had the conviction to go after a guI like the fact that the front office has had the conviction to go after a guy they think highly of.

Whether or not I agree with the player picked doesn't matter.

[ElkinPanthersFan]

Just goes to show who has been a Panthers fan since before the 03 Bandwagonning.

[mwright350]

There is absolutely no way in the world that this trade is worse than the Gilbert debacle.

No no no no