If you could add one player from any team in the NFL to the 2025 Panthers to make them Super Bowl contenders, who would it be?

[thunderraiden]

On the offensive side i can only legit say a proven top 3 TE would be the most effective single player... on defense it gets much harder.. like yeah Jessie Bates would fill a major hole but is he really gonna increase our win shares?

 

And if its any player do you just take Myles Garrett? The whole reason i thought of this was because of the Trey Henderickson saga and the only way it make sense after we got rid of Clowney was if we told ourselves he gets us to a deep playoff run... but would Stingley with Horn provide more win shares than letting our rookies on the d-line play in the hypothetical or could a Henderickson type player push us up more?

Just a thought experiment in the dog days of the offseason.

[BrianS]

The heck?  How is this even a question?

The answer is Mahomes.  There is no other answer.

[jfra78]

Seriously Mahomes or Lamar Jackson 

[thunderraiden]

I thought about removing QB from the equation because of Bryce but damn yall went there already

[PantherChris]

2 minutes ago, jfra78 said:

Seriously Mahomes or Lamar Jackson 

Yea no its Mahomes if you can have anyone its best to get the guy who actually WINS playoff games.

 

 

[jfra78]

6 minutes ago, thunderraiden said:

I thought about removing QB from the equation because of Bryce but damn yall went there already

QB is really the only 1 position that would guarantee more wins

Edited 9 hours ago by jfra78

[LinvilleGorge]

Yeah, definitely Mahomes.

[PNW_PantherMan]

3 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Yeah, definitely Mahomes.

The answer for 31 teams.

[coffee]

Patrick Mahomes

Myles Garrett

Taylor Swift

[Basbear]

 

Brehs, I don't know Mahomes is the clear answer if Andy Reid doesn't come with him....

[Basbear]

1 minute ago, coffee said:

Patrick Mahomes

Myles Garrett

Taylor Swift

[PantherBoy95]

44 minutes ago, thunderraiden said:

I thought about removing QB from the equation because of Bryce but damn yall went there already

I was literally thinking just as I came across this post "This would be a much harder question and more entertaining thread if you couldn't say a QB." lol

The answer is Mahomes, Lamar, or Josh

Non-QB: I think I'd love Jamarr or JJ. Then I might even go Myles Garrett for this years team.

[Basbear]

1 minute ago, PantherBoy95 said:

I was literally thinking just as I came across this post "This would be a much harder question and more entertaining thread if you couldn't say a QB." lol

The answer is Mahomes, Lamar, or Josh

Non-QB: I think I'd love Jamarr or JJ. Then I might even go Myles Garrett for this years team.

what about the retiree Aaron donald??

Just to keep up with my "what about this"

Garrett is 4-3 right, Parsons would a monster OLB end if heathly.....

TJ watt should get votes too, he's got numbers with anyone..

 

[PantherBoy95]

5 minutes ago, Basbear said:

what about the retiree Aaron donald??

Just to keep up with my "what about this"

Garrett is 4-3 right, Parsons would a monster OLB end if heathly.....

TJ watt should get votes too, he's got numbers with anyone..

 

You know what's also funny....I literally thought about that too lmao
I'd take Aaron Donald for sure. But if I can play what if....

I may actually take a healthy CMC lol. 

Because I'm indecisive, I'll put in my final bid for a top tier TE, idk about Kelce at this stage in his career though.

Edited 8 hours ago by PantherBoy95