Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Bryce Young is a problem — what would you do if you were Dan Morgan?


OldhamA
 Share

Recommended Posts

It is just week 1.  CJ Stroud also looked bad.  Let's give Bryce a couple games before the pitch forks come out.  Canales is to blame for the team looking flat again to start the year.  The play calling is atrocious and why this team continues to try to run when the run isn't working, is baffling.  

  • Pie 1
  • Beer 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Waldo said:

If he is benched I would expect a repeat of last year. As for what those people will do well they set it up again this year thr same way so it shows intent of repeating. If I see Young sat then I fear we are going down that road. Nothing the people in charge has done this year leads me to think anything has really changed...yet

They will not fall for that type of resurrection again. His ceiling is a good backup that can come in and win you 2 or 3 games if your starter goes down. That is what he has proven so far. He has to prove he can do it for a full season before that is even considered. The clock is ticking. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Jon Snow said:

They will not fall for that type of resurrection again. His ceiling is a good backup that can come in and win you 2 or 3 games if your starter goes down. That is what he has proven so far. He has to prove he can do it for a full season before that is even considered. The clock is ticking. 

They they can't afford to play him again. If they sit him it's a bad sign. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, TheSpecialJuan said:

BREAKING: The Carolina Panthers have fired Charlie Rock, of the team's communications department, for an insensitive post regarding the murder of Charlie Kirk, a source familiar with the organization's decision tells me. Story to come.

Already in the tinderbox. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Waldo said:

Well the problem with that is how do they justify keeping their jobs after setting up a year like this and ending up with a top 5 pick

I'm sure everyone in the building knew that this was a possibility. I mean, if they went into the season thinking that the only outcome for Young would be that he would have an MVP season, then we are royally f*cked. We knew the odds and despite what they've said publicly, knew this was most likely outcome.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Jon Snow said:

I'm sure everyone in the building knew that this was a possibility. I mean, if they went into the season thinking that the only outcome for Young would be that he would have an MVP season, then we are royally f*cked. We knew the odds and despite what they've said publicly, knew this was most likely outcome.

If they did then Dalton wouldn't be here. We knew but your making a leap I can't follow yet eith them. Also hard to justify a year 3 for people basically tanking in your scenario. IdK just saying

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, jtm said:

It is just week 1.  CJ Stroud also looked bad.  Let's give Bryce a couple games before the pitch forks come out.  Canales is to blame for the team looking flat again to start the year.  The play calling is atrocious and why this team continues to try to run when the run isn't working, is baffling.  

Stroud has a wee bit more success than Bryce. Bryce looking bad is the norm, not the anomaly. He's not able to execute the most basic decision making during plays, especially when he was touted as this master processor. Its year 3 and he looked like a rookie in preseason. The play calling is blah but I'm not so sure its not because of Bryce being unable to do more. 

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interestingly very few have proposed a solution - they've just reiterated that the current Front Office won't do anything (which I agree with). Here's my answer:

 

Identifying the Problem

It’s becoming increasingly clear to most Panthers fans: Bryce Young is holding this team back. In a quarterback-driven league, we’re stuck with one who not only limits the playbook due to his physical constraints, but also stunts the offense with his inability to process and execute routine plays.

This isn’t a bare-bones roster anymore. The front office has invested heavily in the offense:

  • Offensive Line: One recent first-round pick and roughly 33% of our total Salary Cap
  • Wide Receivers: Two recent first-round picks
  • Running Backs: One recent second-rounder, one recent fourth-rounder, plus Hubbard and Dowdle

And let’s not forget the two first-round picks (and D.J. Moore) spent to acquire Young himself.

 

The Solution

We need to be proactive and move on from Bryce Young - immediately. Continuing to start him means writing off the season, which neither the GM, coaching staff, nor fans can afford. There’s simply too much invested in this offense to let it flounder under a quarterback who isn’t elevating the unit.

I’d explore cost-effective trade options for backup QBs around the league to staunch the bleeding. Dalton and Hooker aren’t viable starters. I'd re-evaluate in the offseason to see where we stand - and consider the Draft and Free Agency if the need arises. 

 

Identifying Value

Take Sam Howell, for example. The Vikings traded him and a 2026 sixth-round pick to the Eagles for a 2026 fifth and a 2027 seventh. That’s a low-risk deal for a QB who threw for 3,946 yards, 23 TDs, and 23 INTs in his lone starting season.

 

Potential Targets

Tier 1 – Younger QBs with upside

  • Tanner McKee
  • Malik Willis
  • Anthony Richardson*
  • Trey Lance

Tier 2 – Veteran or stopgap options

  • Gardner Minshew
  • Mac Jones
  • Aidan O’Connell
  • Davis Mills

 

What to Do with Young

Ideally, I’d include Young in a trade package if possible. If not, I’m fine with sitting him until the offseason and then exploring trade or cut options. His value is low now, but continuing to start him only makes it worse.

 

This team deserves better than what we’ve seen so far. The pieces are in place—we just need a quarterback who gives them a fair chance to compete. 

  • Pie 1
  • Beer 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, jtm said:

It is just week 1.  CJ Stroud also looked bad.  Let's give Bryce a couple games before the pitch forks come out.  Canales is to blame for the team looking flat again to start the year.  The play calling is atrocious and why this team continues to try to run when the run isn't working, is baffling.  

CJ Stroud also had one of the best rookie years of all time, and yes he had a downward trend last year that should be concerning but isn't cause for benching.

BY had a decent stretch of games and then poo the bed. That's it.

  • Pie 1
  • Beer 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Yesterday was predictable and some predicted it.  We were due for that bubble to pop. We were outclassed going into it, coaching staff and roster both.  It doesn’t feel that bad when you predict it but when you have to watch it In real time it is extremely deflating.    
    • Well they better sign him to a decent deal or he walks this year, and we get nothing for him. Actually they could get the same for Chuba and let it be known that Dowdle is our #1 back. I like him but I doubt he will be here next year.
    • The Bills are a well coached team.  I give them that.  They are a well run organization.  That’s no excuse.  The point of this thread is to point out that yesterday illustrated something much more troubling than losing to a good team.  My takeaways: * We still haven’t found a coach.  Canales isn’t it.  He is in way over his head.  Everyone knows how I feel about Bryce, but seeing Dalton yesterday, a lot of the issues Bryce deals with every week are now clearly thematic.  I thought to myself yesterday, “but Ron Rivera looked like he was drowning until that Buffalo game,” and now in hindsight, he ultimately became possibly our greatest coach in franchise history.  But before that Buffalo game with his seat as hot as ever, he did some of the dumbest things I had ever seen.  He refused to adjust.  He played guys that shouldn’t have been out on the field over guys who seemed like clearly better players.  For example, Josh Norman sat for how many seasons, mostly because of non-quantifiable stuff.  Canales suffers the same issues early in his tenure,  it without any of the reassurances or pedigree that Ron had.  Our offense stinks because of Dave, point blank, period.  We can only guess about play calls and scheme because we don’t know all the ins and outs of that, but what is clear is that he has no idea how to put our guys in positions to succeed.  Look at the number of players who have absolutely killed it that Dave tried his best to keep off the field - Rico, Mays, Christensen, Horn, etc.  Now look at the guys he played over them.  Ron only had a couple of those instances over several seasons albeit bad ones *cough* Nakamura *cough* Josh Norman *cough*.  But, Dave is multiplying that by the umpteenth power in one season.  And not only is it about the guys he is or isn’t playing, he doesn’t know how to use them.  All of the TEs.  The aforementioned Horn Jr.  XL.  Trying to make Corbett a center.  Both Rico and Chuba are healthy, but he can’t figure out how to use them together.  There is zero rhythm to the offense most games after that opening drive, and a lot of it is Dave playing guys that shouldn’t be playing and not knowing how to implement the ones that are that could help us the most.  I had held onto hope because Dave’s positivity and his track record with QBs.  But, the more I’ve watched, it has become clear, even in coaching extremely limited QBs, there are so many other issues that falls on coaching that he is responsible for.  He is not a good coach. *Speaking of Rico and Chuba, don’t know if anyone else caught that, but after scoring his garbage time TD that was force fed to him, when Chuba went over to the bench, he sat down seemingly alone.  Then the camera zoomed out and actually Rico was on the other side of that portion of the bench.  Another guy, I’m guessing a practice squad guy came and sat down closer to Chuba but between them, and from what I saw, Rico looked straight ahead.  They never looked at one another, didn’t appear to speak to one another, nothing.  Someone else correct me if I’m wrong, as I was heavily distracted, but if they interacted it would’ve been just a millisecond that I wasn’t looking…  the body language looked absolutely discouraging.  There is clearly a huge beef brewing there. *Back to Canales…  which is a further indictment that this isn’t just schematic or playcalling.  Another reason he is clearly not a good coach - when we lose this season we LOSE.  We lose big.  We lose ugly.  We lose unprepared.  We lose undisciplined.  We lose in every fundamental way.  You don’t go from stifling the #1 offense in the NFL two weeks ago, to getting blown out at home 40-3 (Chuba’s late TD is irrelevant).  In every facet of the game that we have shown improvement, we go out in losses like yesterday’s and make you question if it was fool’s gold.  That’s poor coaching.  It’s discouraging because the drop off isn’t incremental, these are huge wild swings.  From a top 10 defense who excels at stopping the run, to giving up the highest individual rushing day in the NFL this season.  From a functional offense, scoring around 20 points a game to 3 when it counted.  We are -5 turnovers on the season.  Outside of the obvious Rico Dowdle - Bryce Young, Jimmy Horn, and Travis Etienne are all statistically better rushers right now than Chuba, and yet, we are forcing Chuba touches.  Rico only started two weeks and is still our top rusher for the season.  That forcing Chuba the ball poo might’ve worked when we had no other options, but it literally is destroying the offense now and yet, he keeps doing it.  This insistence of square peg, round hole football is all coaching, and it is absolutely demoralizing.  We show zero consistency with any and everything, and that falls directly at the coach’s feet. Seeing all of this following the few weeks where it appeared the team was picking up some semblance of identity and momentum, and then to lose in such a fashion to where those staples we had begun to believe in were proven to be mirages is beyond discouraging.  Don’t get me wrong, I didn’t expect to beat the Bills.  I did expect to be competitive and still excel at the things we appeared to be making our calling cards.  From the best rushing team for two straight weeks to pedestrian.  From stopping the run and playing smash mouth football to getting blown out at him with opposing players averaging 12 yards per carry and receivers running wide butt naked open.  There is no consistency or leadership on this staff.  Period.  Yesterday’s loss brings us right back to the sobering reality that we still don’t have a head coach and all the problems rife within the Tepper Era.  
×
×
  • Create New...