Has there been a bigger Carolina miss in the NFL draft?

[tiger7_88]

Than picking Amini Silatolu instead of Cordy Glenn?

Discuss.  :)

[Mr. Scot]

Tshimanga Biakabutuka over Eddie George...

DeShaun Foster over Clinton Portis...

[Squirrel]

There have been plenty.  Biggest one was Eric Shelton.  

[bga71]

Jason Peter instead of anyone else.  Same for Rae Carruth.

[rodeo]

Yeah Cordy Glenn, or imagine if we had Gettleman and his tendency to double dip that year. Kuechly in the first and Bobby Wagner or Lavonte David in the 2nd.

[electro's horse]

Amini just couldn't stay healthy. I don't really think you can blame the player for that   .

Biggest draft bust, taking into consideration what was spent to get them and what the panthers received, has to go to either Everette brown, armanti Edwards, or Eric Shelton. 

Everette brow was weird, had no position in the nfl, and didn't want to play. Eric Shelton got hit once in training camp after never really playing anyone at Louisville and said fug this. Armanti just didn't belong on the field. 

[beckersteen]

Trading up for Armanti Edwards instead of literally anyone else. Dude should never have been drafted and we traded up lmao

[YourMomsLover]

Drafting Cam Newton instead of Blaine Gabbert

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I kid

[Snake]

20 minutes ago, Squirrel said:

There have been plenty.  Biggest one was Eric Shelton.  

Jarret was just as bad

[Snake]

9 minutes ago, beckersteen said:

Trading up for Armanti Edwards instead of literally anyone else. Dude should never have been drafted and we traded up lmao

That has to be the worst 

[KillerKat]

COLLINS OVER STEVE fuging MCNAIR. 

[jbland]

26 minutes ago, bga71 said:

Jason Peter instead of anyone else.  Same for Rae Carruth.

Disagree. Carruth was on his way to being a super star in the league. No way we could know he would have his gf killed. 

[cbarrier90]

Based on draft position, the trade up for Armanti was bad, but the pick it garnered was used on Ras-I Dowling and none of the players around the 3rd where we selected Armanti were of any consequence.

The trade of a future first to select Jeff Otah cost the Panthers a pick that could have been used on Hakeem Nicks and Patrick Chung among others. The Otah pick itself could have been used on Aqib Talib or Chris Johnson, but Hurney had already chosen Stew earlier that round.

The Everette Brown trade is hands down the worst based on lost draft capital. The Panthers could have selected Connor Barwin or LeSean McCoy and the next year's FIRST ROUNDER they gave up to move into that slot was used on Mike Iupati and could have been used on Maurkice Pouncey, Demaryius Thomas, Jermaine Gresham, Dez Bryant, or Devin McCourty.

[csx]

Edwards wasnt as bad as Everette Brown. We traded a freakin 1st for Brown.