Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Patriots Cheating Could Be Worse with Machine Learning


johnnydefence

Recommended Posts

If the Patriots know their opponents substitution, signals and compared that to key elements like down, distance, and time it would take them less than a half to predict all the opponents calls (not tenancies) with a machine learning application. Imagine playing a game and your opponent pretty much knows everything you're doing. 

I might be giving them too much credit but they do have a Director of Data Science and Software on staff and this is what these guys do. I stumbled across the video explaining how a machine learning application could work in baseball and I suspect it would be similar for football. The more data they have the higher probability they can predict what their opponent is doing, much like the Astros were doing. This is sad and if they are doing something like this they should be punished. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, jasonluckydog said:

"If you ain't cheating you ain't trying"

 

Joe Montana 

What good is a dynasty if it isn’t won with integrity. This video pretty bad and damning. 
 

How does it feel to officially know the Patriots cheated super bowl 38?

Just makes you realize what sham professional sports can be. The so called greatest combo of all time won by knowing everyone else’s plays. Meanwhile our stud QB gets trashed by the media and head hunted out of a Super Bowl  so another “legend” Peyton Manning can get his retirement trophy at the expense of our franchise. Just shows yet again that the NFL doesn’t care about putting out a fair product.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, OneBadCat said:

What good is a dynasty if it isn’t won with integrity. This video pretty bad and damning. 
 

How does it feel to officially know the Patriots cheated super bowl 38?

Just makes you realize what sham professional sports can be. The so called greatest combo of all time won by knowing everyone else’s plays. Meanwhile our stud QB gets trashed by the media and head hunted out of a Super Bowl for  so another “legend” Peyton Manning can get his retirement trophy at the expense of our franchise. Just shows yet again that the NFL doesn’t care about putting out a fair product.

Well, to be completely fair our OL was juiced to the gills that year so...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I more or less agree with, "if you're not cheating, you're not trying".

But there's a problem with this logic when it comes to the NFL.

Only the Patriots are allowed to get away with such blatant cheating, because they have 'the halo of a winner', and the media/public perception when they're caught cheating is that everyone is just a sore loser who is jealous of their success.  So Goodell doesn't really have much incentive to go after them, since the public doesn't care, and it hurts the integrity of the NFL to focus on the issue.

Look at the response to the Bengals incident (people thought, "as if the Patriots would need to cheat against the Bengals").

On the other hand, try to imagine if the Panthers or say, Titans, got caught cheating.  The league would throw the book at them.

So while every team would love to get an edge, and do what the Patriots do, they don't have the sort of clout to get away with it.

Another confounding variable is how close Robert Kraft is to Roger Goodell. It's very known he was the owner most instrumental in pushing for him to be commissioner all those years ago.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I firmly believe the Patriots, as an organization, knowingly and willfully cheat in almost every game they play.  The effectiveness of that cheating may be up for debate, but there's absolutely no doubt that they are masters at coming up with ways to cheat.  I would love to see the NFL actually grow some balls and strip a couple titles from them.  I know it can be done in college, but no clue if the NFL even has a mechanism for such a thing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They are innovative as cheaters--deflated footballs (laundered after inspection), filming "walk throughs" sidelines, etc.   Brady has shown that he is willing to lie about cheating--BB showed it too recently.  I wonder about bugging the visitor's locker room or having spy cameras focused on the white boards.  It would be consistent.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, OneBadCat said:

What good is a dynasty if it isn’t won with integrity. This video pretty bad and damning. 
 

How does it feel to officially know the Patriots cheated super bowl 38?

Just makes you realize what sham professional sports can be. The so called greatest combo of all time won by knowing everyone else’s plays. Meanwhile our stud QB gets trashed by the media and head hunted out of a Super Bowl  so another “legend” Peyton Manning can get his retirement trophy at the expense of our franchise. Just shows yet again that the NFL doesn’t care about putting out a fair product.

Against Michael Vick once when we finally beat them and gave them a bad game, it was said in interviews by defensive linemen that we figured out Vick’s cadence. I remember this very well.

i take getting signals much like watching tape on people.

when I played my little Amateur British American Football League in England teams always sent moles over to watch practices.

so we changed calls 15 minutes before game time.

To me this isn’t cheating any different than competitive intelligence.

you still have to play, execute, and many times it doesn’t matter if you know they are going to run or pass— they impose their will on you.

cheating for me would be like poisoning the locker room of the opposing team and making them harshly sick or sneaking ringer players on the field with real player jerseys to impersonate etc.

this whole thing is sour grapes. I hate the Patriots but they truly are better than everyone else. People can’t take it so they look for some way to make themselves feel better.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, JARROD said:

Against Michael Vick once when we finally beat them and gave them a bad game, it was said in interviews by defensive linemen that we figured out Vick’s cadence. I remember this very well.

i take getting signals much like watching tape on people.

when I played my little Amateur British American Football League in England teams always sent moles over to watch practices.

so we changed calls 15 minutes before game time.

To me this isn’t cheating any different than competitive intelligence.

you still have to play, execute, and many times it doesn’t matter if you know they are going to run or pass— they impose their will on you.

cheating for me would be like poisoning the locker room of the opposing team and making them harshly sick or sneaking ringer players on the field with real player jerseys to impersonate etc.

this whole thing is sour grapes. I hate the Patriots but they truly are better than everyone else. People can’t take it so they look for some way to make themselves feel better.

They got caught red handed doing something against the rules. That's cheating, not sour grapes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, JARROD said:

Against Michael Vick once when we finally beat them and gave them a bad game, it was said in interviews by defensive linemen that we figured out Vick’s cadence. I remember this very well.

i take getting signals much like watching tape on people.

when I played my little Amateur British American Football League in England teams always sent moles over to watch practices.

so we changed calls 15 minutes before game time.

To me this isn’t cheating any different than competitive intelligence.

you still have to play, execute, and many times it doesn’t matter if you know they are going to run or pass— they impose their will on you.

cheating for me would be like poisoning the locker room of the opposing team and making them harshly sick or sneaking ringer players on the field with real player jerseys to impersonate etc.

this whole thing is sour grapes. I hate the Patriots but they truly are better than everyone else. People can’t take it so they look for some way to make themselves feel better.

Except that the league prohibits it, and tries to actively enforce that prohibition.

The issue is that in the NFL, the talent differences are not generally great enough to mitigate somebody knowing what is coming at them.  If we were back in 1974, and we were the Houston Oilers playing the Dolphins, Steelers, or Raiders, there is a good chance they could send over every single play they were going to run and when, and we would still not be able to stop them.  Those teams (in the AFC, the Vikings, Rams, and maybe Cowboys in the NFC) were good enough that they were going to impose their will on the opponent unless they just had a bad day. 

But that era ended.  Now, the difference between winning and losing often boils down to five or six plays over the course of 60 minutes.

If I were playing the Patriots, I would change up signals, too.  And perhaps have a couple of different sets during the game. 

But none of that really matters, as the league has banned the practice.  Everybody associated with the league knows it is a banned practice, in large part due to the Patriots' previous actions.  And yet, they apparently continue to do it.

Fines apparently have no impact.  Loss of draft choices apparently have no impact.  Would the loss of salary cap dollars get somebody's attention?  I do not know, but it is worth a try.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

49 minutes ago, Shufdog said:

They got caught red handed doing something against the rules. That's cheating, not sour grapes.

So you are telling me that everyone would care just as much if it was the Lions, Bengals or Jacksonville? Or Carolina?

we had the Steroid scandal and nobody cared. Did we lose draft picks and have every Tom dick and Harry blowing up boards and ESPN?

no.

they win, we don’t, so everyone gets mad.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Let's say we have a LT for 2026, because we do.  After that, let's say we Ickey could be back and we would have the option of extending Walker.   Don't get me wrong--I LOVE drafting OL.  Teams obviously get desperate for OTs and if they enter the draft without 2 solid tackles, they are almost obligated to reach for a first round OT.  This year, I see 1 OT who is probably worth first-round consideration, and I am not putting him in the top 10 players in the draft.  Lomu, Freeling, Miller, and Proctor, for example, probably and arguably have second-round value.  So why would you reach for an OT in round 1 when you already have starters at both T positions but you have other needs? We do need depth, however, and I think there is decent OT depth that needs development on day 3. They are no slouches, by the way.   Drew Shelton (could drop to round 4): Surrendered 1 sack as Penn State's LT in 2025. 33 3/8" arms.  Pass pro improved every year (4 years--experienced).  "For a team running a zone-heavy scheme that values lateral movement and reach-blocking ability over phone-booth mauling, Shelton has real appeal. He is not a plug-and-play starter, but the athletic tools and the clear year-over-year improvement suggest a player who can develop into a capable starter if a coaching staff invests in his strength base and cleans up his technique. The ceiling depends entirely on how much stronger he can get and whether his feet can stay alive after initial contact."   Austin Barber  (could drop to round 4): I see him as a RT at best and a probable kick inside to Guard where his strengths would switch from secondary to primary tools.  Considering Lewis and Hunt may be gone in a year or two, this would give the Panthers a chance to work him at RT and then move him inside if he is not effective, and there is confidence that G may be his best position. Jude Bowery (4th round projection) was LT on a Boston College OL that was effective in the run game.  Bowery is one of the most athletic OTs in the draft.  His arms are not ideal but not too short (33.75") to play LT.  He surrendered 2 sacks. He is raw, and needs some technical refinement with his hands.  I think he has the best upside and value for this offense.   Dametrious Crownover  TexAM (5th round projection; 35 3/8" arms) is one of the more fascinating developmental tackles in this class because the physical tools are legitimately rare. A strong run blocker who should be better in pass protection with his tools.  "You do not find many 6-7, 336-pound men with that foot speed and who have the athletic background of a converted tight end. When everything clicks, he looks like a starting right tackle in a gap-heavy run scheme, smothering defenders at the point of attack and using his length to erase speed off the edge. The 2024 tape, when he anchored one of the best rushing attacks in the SEC, is the version of Crownover that gets offensive line coaches excited."  THIS is the kind of player our coaches could develop until Moton is done. What made World intriguing coming out of Eugene was the untapped ceiling, a fifth-year transfer who arrived as the top-ranked offensive tackle in the portal and looked the part for stretches. The improvement he showed against Big Ten competition in his one Oregon season was real, and the physical foundation, length, athleticism, and improving technique in pass protection, is still there. The ACL tear suffered in the College Football Playoff semifinal against Indiana doesn't erase that, but it changes the conversation significantly. The injury clouds the immediate projection. Most ACL recoveries for offensive linemen run nine to twelve months, which means World is likely unavailable for meaningful action well into his rookie season at the earliest. The combine absence removes his chance to reset the narrative physically, and teams will be making decisions almost entirely off pre-injury film and medical evaluations. The contrast between his polished pass sets and his inconsistent run blocking was already a developmental concern, and now those technique issues get deferred further while he rehabs. Isaiah World  (Oregon, injured ACL in playoffs, 5th round projection--could slide to 6th).  World will not play much if at all in 2026, which is why he might fall.  For the Panthers' purposes, however, this would give the OL coaches time to work with him. "What made World intriguing coming out of Eugene was the untapped ceiling, a fifth-year transfer who arrived as the top-ranked offensive tackle in the portal and looked the part for stretches. The improvement he showed against Big Ten competition in his one Oregon season was real, and the physical foundation, length, athleticism, and improving technique in pass protection, is still there. The ACL tear suffered in the College Football Playoff semifinal against Indiana doesn't erase that, but it changes the conversation significantly." "That said, the investment argument isn't crazy for the right organization. This is still a tackle with first-round portal grades and the kind of athletic profile that doesn't just disappear. A team with patience and a strong offensive line room can afford to stash World on the roster, let him develop his lower-body power and pad-level consistency during the recovery process, and potentially unlock a starting-caliber right tackle somewhere in his second or third season. The path is longer now, but the destination hasn't changed for a scout willing to bet on the physical tools." You get the idea. If we do not need the OT immediately, draft one later and develop him as depth and for next season.  Most college players drafted in round 1 were not first rounders if they had entered the draft the year before,  so why not grab a player with upside?      
    • Its never the QBs fault, so if we get a new WR and he looks bad he must be a bust
    • Based on what? Its certainly not his in game coaching prowess. 
×
×
  • Create New...