Curtis or Robbie?

[Icege]

Curtis Samuel has performed well this year, making threads like this one and this one oh so fun to revisit. 

Robbie Anderson has also been a solid player for the team.

With Curtis being an upcoming UFA and Anderson costing $12M next season with only $4M in dead cap if he is cut: IF the Panthers find themselves in a situation where they have to choose one or the other, who should they go with?

(fwiw I think there's enough moves that the Panthers can make to retain both as well as Moton)

[Fox007]

We need a QB that can actually get the ball to Robbie deep and also to DJ Moore...we have great deep threats and duck arm TB at the helm...
The answer then is it doesn't matter if TB is the QB either one of them can do a slant route as good as it was to finally see this team figure out that is an actual football route that is ran by football teams it was basically the only pass TB can do with any consistency.

[Icege]

2 minutes ago, Fox007 said:

We need a QB that can actually get the ball to Robbie deep and also to DJ Moore...we have great deep threats and duck arm TB at the helm...
The answer then is it doesn't matter if TB is the QB either one of them can do a slant route as good as it was to finally see this team figure out that is an actual football route that is ran by football teams it was basically the only pass TB can do with any consistency.

So... cut Robbie and let Curtis walk?

That's a bit self destructive.

[BrizzMachete]

I personally like Curtis better but it wouldn’t be smart to cut Robbie after what he showed this year . I wanna keep all 3 

[WarHeel]

I like Curtis for his multitude of options. Not discrediting Anderson but I feel like the early success he and Bridgewater had was not as pronounced as the season progressed. 

[*FreeFua*]

There are a lot of dudes in this draft class that can be had in the 2nd and 3rd round that could replace Curtis for a fraction of the cost. Curtis at this point might be a luxury we can’t afford given our other needs.

[philp]

I loved how we were able to show Rivera and Scott Turner how Samual is supposed to be used. 
 

Rivera has had to deal with more dysfunctional front offices than most, but none of that has to do with player development. I’m honestly curious to see how he does without Cam, though I’m not really rooting for or against him.

[Fox007]

4 minutes ago, Icege said:

So... cut Robbie and let Curtis walk?

That's a bit self destructive.

No, how do you come to that conclusion lol.
The question is curtis or robbie? I said it doesn't matter which one with TB as your QB it's all the same and you gonna come up with some cut both lol.

[Jared Patterson]

Keep all 3

[Moo Daeng]

4 minutes ago, Icege said:

So... cut Robbie and let Curtis walk?

That's a bit self destructive.

Just get used to these dumb comments derailing every thread from now own.

Both guys had career years yet.......

I don't see it as a choice between Curtis and Robbie but between Curtis and Taylor Moton. In that situation I have to go with Moton. I don't want to lose either but I feel utility offense players might be a little easier to find and less critical than a solid experienced young O lineman.

[Moo Daeng]

3 minutes ago, Fox007 said:

No, how do you come to that conclusion lol.
The question is curtis or robbie? I said it doesn't matter which one with TB as your QB it's all the same and you gonna come up with some cut both lol.

If you were looking at it from that perspective genuinely than you keep Curtis over Robbie. Saying it doesn't matter isn't looking very deeply in o the scenario.

[Lemory]

We dont deserve Curtis, let him sign with a team like LAC or KC and take the comp pick. He'd be sooo good with a legit QB.

[GoobyPls]

We are not cutting Anderson. I want to keep Samuel 

[Car123]

If I could, I would sign Samuel now and not re-sign Anderson when his contract expires.