How do you feel about CJ Stroud

[ForJimmy]

1 minute ago, TheCasillas said:

his left hand is covering up part of the ball because the ball has already passed him.... Tom Brady wouldnt get this kind of defense on an errant pass...  If you want to believe that this was on the RB ... go ahead... its assinine, but go ahead.

I don’t think it was on the RB. Most RBs can’t make that high catch. It was overthrown. If you watch the actual video you can see it get deflected off his hands though. Then the commentator actually says it got deflected off Montgomery’s hands. Your picture is misleading is all I’m saying, but I think you know that.

[Varking]

Just now, LinvilleGorge said:

How did this turn into a spat about Fields?

Somebody compared him to Stroud and then claimed Fields is getting no better as a passer from last year lol

[Sgt Schultz]

1 minute ago, LinvilleGorge said:

How did this turn into a spat about Fields?

Isn't it obvious?

 

 

 

If it is, somebody please let me know what I am missing.  I haven't even started drinking yet today.

[cookinbrak]

Just gonna say that the Mich QB had a damn fine game.

[TheCasillas]

3 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

I don’t think it was on the RB. Most RBs can’t make that high catch. It was overthrown. If you watch the actual video you can see it get deflected off his hands though. Then the commentator actually says it got deflected off Montgomery’s hands. Your picture is misleading is all I’m saying, but I think you know that.

i wasnt trying to lead to anything with that photo... the point of the photo was to show that the ball is way over the dump offs head.. and should never ever have been deemed as a "catchable" ball by any party. 

[TheCasillas]

Just now, cookinbrak said:

Just gonna say that the Mich QB had a damn fine game.

hell yeah he did. Kid has wheels too.

[ForJimmy]

3 minutes ago, Varking said:

Somebody compared him to Stroud and then claimed Fields is getting no better as a passer from last year lol

Pretty much. Then used his 1 INT as proof he can’t read a defense…. He needs work as a passer, but that’s getting just silly.

[TheCasillas]

i guess the thread title should be "How do you feel about OSU QBs"

 

my bad for taking it off track.

[TheCasillas]

4 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

Pretty much. Then used his 1 INT as proof he can’t read a defense…. He needs work as a passer, but that’s getting just silly.

thats not at all what I did... I called out that his last pass was an INT, while alluding to the fact that protecting the ball is an issue he has had since he came into the league.

 

but go ahead make this a thing.

 

Edited November 26, 2022 by TheCasillas
added "alluding" (missing from original)

[Bear Hands]

32 minutes ago, Growl said:

so weird watching these posters who watch these games hoping to see these players make a mistake (and obsessing over every one) because they so desperately want to avoid drafting a QB

(or draft some mid round future backup they “discovered”)

This^^. Evolving opinions based on evolving play be damned, some just want to bash when the opportunity is given. 

I've been lurking here and decided to join in on this prospect talk, it's just silly.  And now we're dissecting a single throw by Justin Fields lol.  

We should all want to see ALL of these guys looks as awesome as possible, it's only for our benefit to have some great QBs to choose from.  I want Levis to look better, I want Richardson's accuracy to improve, I want Stroud to look absolutely perfect.  It's as if some are actually more intent on having hard-lined unwavering stances and being right about it, waiting for the second to say a guy blows. 

Stroud had some really damn nice anticipation throws today, great moments, had a bad end of game.  That's really it. 

Showed strong ability, lived up to his hype, the D fell apart, and he couldn't will the team downfield and made some mistakes at the end. It doesn't mean he's #1, doesn't mean he's not worth it either.  

 

[RJK]

You should know that if you have some childish allegiance to schools and the reason you like/don’t like a prospect is based entirely on that, your opinion has zero value. Thank you for coming to my TED talk 

[WOW!!]

Great WIn !!

GO big Blue!!

Still would take Stroud in a heartbeat..

[ForJimmy]

16 minutes ago, WOW!! said:

Great WIn !!

GO big Blue!!

Still would take Stroud in a heartbeat..

Yeah, love seeing OSU take a loss, but also still high on Stroud.

[SmokinwithWilly]

I'll be happy to take Stroud as long as I never have to see Baker suit up again as a Panther.