Barnwell trade value article

[Peon Awesome]

Barnwell trade tiers

Good read on which players on every team he thinks would net a 1st round pick or more. His assessments seem quite reasonable.

To summarize:

Burns - 2 1sts

Bryce Young - 1 1st and change

Jaycee Horn - 1 1st

Has Moton, Ekwonu and Derrick Brown slightly missing the cut. Acknowledges that Bryce hasn't played close to that value but some team would probably give that much off his potential. And Horn is "only" a 1st due to his significant injury history. He has Surtain as worth 2 1sts for what it's worth.

 

[LinvilleGorge]

That seems extremely generous. If I could turn Burns and Horn into three 1sts I'm absolutely doing that.

It just seems like we don't want to pay Burns' asking price and given that he's kind of a one trick pony I don't really have an issue with that. Horn is a very good CB when available but you're only as good as your availability and he's rarely available.

[4Corners]

I would take four first round picks and a swift kick to the nuggets Liu Kang style for those three players right the F now 

Prob a reason why Barnwell is writing articles tho and not actually working for an nfl team 

[Jaxel]

I mean Bryce Young will not be traded, so no idea why he would even be listed. No one is giving up on a QB they just payed out the nose on after 5 games.

[Wanderlai]

That’s like a Christmas list of what you hope to get in reality your Christmas presents are coming from the Dollar Store.

[Ricky Spanish]

I can't take this seriously if he doesn't think Brown is worth a 1st rounder. He's one of the only good things we have going on defense right now. 

[ForJimmy]

If Fitt can get 2 firsts for Burns, I’ll forgive him for passing on that Rams deal.

[philw5289]

Nobody would give up a first for Horn. The best ability is availability 

[top dawg]

Not quite sure why there seems to be a mood of devaluing Burns here, but I suspect that the proof will be in the pudding very soon. 

 

[MasterAwesome]

OP is one of the biggest Bill Barnwell shills...may even be the man himself if you ask me.

[Peon Awesome]

1 hour ago, Jaxel said:

I mean Bryce Young will not be traded, so no idea why he would even be listed. No one is giving up on a QB they just payed out the nose on after 5 games.

The article is just trying to assess players' values. He's not factoring in whether the team would actually make the player available. To drive the point home, he has Patrick Mahomes on the list for the Chiefs. 

[Peon Awesome]

It's the epitome of Huddle arrogance to think as a fan you've got your finger on the pulse of the league better than a guy who spends his life analyzing the NFL. If you read the rest of the article the assessments seem pretty on cue. I think we need to acknowledge how much we undervalue our players. DJ Moore and McCaffrey are recent reminders of that. 

[4Corners]

Friendly reminder to the huddle:

these writers speculating about trades and making personnel decisions;  if they knew WTf they were talking about they would be working for NFL teams no Sports Illustrated or CBS

[CRA]

2 hours ago, Peon Awesome said:

Barnwell trade tiers

Good read on which players on every team he thinks would net a 1st round pick or more. His assessments seem quite reasonable.

To summarize:

Burns - 2 1sts

Bryce Young - 1 1st and change

Jaycee Horn - 1 1st

Has Moton, Ekwonu and Derrick Brown slightly missing the cut. Acknowledges that Bryce hasn't played close to that value but some team would probably give that much off his potential. And Horn is "only" a 1st due to his significant injury history. He has Surtain as worth 2 1sts for what it's worth.

 

Not sure how anyone can argue a higher trade value for Horn than Brown.