PFF: What's wrong with the Carolina Panthers offense?

[TheSpecialJuan]

The weather is changing as we move deeper into winter, but there’s been an ugly storm brewing in Carolina since early September, as the Carolina Panthers are 0-6, remain the last winless team in the NFL and the offense is in a funk. To make matters worse, they don’t own their 2024 first-round pick and are showing little sign of turning the ship around. But what’s gone wrong?

Hopes were high for the Carolina Panthers heading into the 2023 NFL season. After walking through the desolate quarterback wilderness for the last few years, with everyone from Kyle Allen to Baker Mayfield taking snaps under center in the post-Cam Newton world, the Panthers finally got their quarterback in the 2023 NFL Draft, selecting Alabama’s Bryce Young with the No. 1 overall pick.

With a new quarterback and the NFC South up for grabs, hopes were high for the Panthers. Through six games, those hopes for success have been replaced by hopes for a semblance of competency on offense. The Panthers have the 29th-graded offense and rank 26th in EPA per play and 19th in +EPA%, which measures consistency and success rate. Those numbers don’t bear particularly great reading, but it looks worse the deeper you dive.

It’s fair to say that Young hasn’t played well so far. His 51.0 overall grade ranks 34th out of 35 quarterbacks this season, and he’s completed 63.2% of his pass attempts for just 967 yards, six touchdowns and four interceptions. The raw numbers, aside from the low passing yards totals, are fine. However, Young’s play has been erratic at times.

Young's essence is creativity. We saw it in college. He likes, occasionally maybe needs, to work and move around the pocket, evading pressure to hunt for the big play. It’s not all he is, but it’s a big part of his aura. However, that aura hasn’t manifested itself in the NFL yet.

Young’s average time to throw is the ninth-highest in the NFL at 2.74 seconds and, so far, bad things have happened when he holds onto the ball. He has a 47.0 overall grade when he holds onto the ball for more than 2.5 seconds, the second-lowest in the league, and averages just 5.3 yards per pass attempt. On top of that, Young’s big-time throw rate is the second-lowest in the league at 1.9%. Those big plays that he’s been hunting? They’re not coming.

And it’s hard to blame Young for that. Despite his spotty play, the flesh and bones of a real starting NFL quarterback are there. His accuracy rate is one of the highest in the NFL at 63.7%, and his plus-accuracy rate (call it pass attempts with excellent ball location) is also seventh-highest. The arm talent is still there, evidenced by the touchdown pass that Young ripped to Adam Thielen in the back of the end zone against the Miami Dolphins.

Thielen has been the rare bright spot in the receiving department for Young, and that in itself is a worry. Thielen’s 86.1 receiving grade ranks 11th in the NFL, and he comfortably leads the Panthers offense in targets, catches, receiving yards and touchdowns. No other Panther comes close to his 49 receptions on the season — the next closest is Terrace Marshall Jr. with 16. 

This is a team that just lacks playmakers. Receivers that can consistently get open and make plays. That makes things tough for Young. Sometimes the post-snap picture is too muddy because there’s nothing for Young to look at, everyone is covered. There’s little to suggest that anything will change soon with this set of receivers. Aside from Thielen, no other wide receiver on the team has better than a 59.0 receiving grade. Yikes.

It doesn’t stop there. Even when the picture is clear downfield, Young often isn’t even afforded the time to navigate his surroundings in the pocket. The Panthers' 46.9 pass-blocking grade ranks 29th, and Young is being pressured on 39.1% of his dropbacks. The amalgamation of everything is that that’s no way to live and survive as an NFL quarterback.

However, when Young is on time and working within the rhythm of the offense, things look good. When he holds onto the ball for less than 2.5 seconds, Young is playing well. He’s completing 75% of his passes, throwing five touchdowns and zero interceptions, and has a 63.2 passing grade. It’s not perfect, but it’s a stark improvement compared to when Young holds onto the ball for too long.

Getting the ball out quickly can’t be the only answer though. Sometimes it’s just not viable. The look you want isn’t always there, and it’s there even less when you don’t have a set of playmakers that can consistently create separation and win their matchups. Yet, Young doesn’t have the freedom to hold onto the ball without being pressured. That’s where the struggles really begin. It’s a vicious cycle. 

It would help if the Panthers had a counter-punch in a consistent running game, but they don’t. Miles Sanders has been an abject disappointment after signing a four-year, $25 million contract in the offseason. He’s averaging just a career-low 3.1 yards per carry and his 0.08 missed tackles forced per attempt is sixth-lowest among all ball carriers with at least 25 attempts. It also doesn’t help that he’s averaging just 0.9 yards before contact. That’s down to the poor play from the offensive line again. Things looked better with Chuba Hubbard against the Miami Dolphins, but there’s still a long way to go.

https://www.pff.com/news/nfl-whats-wrong-with-the-carolina-panthers-offense

[BrianS]

Ok, PFF has no freaking clue.  Their stats don't even line up with . . . anything.  (I'm not calling out the OP here - just PFF who remain crazy)

42 minutes ago, TheSpecialJuan said:

His accuracy rate is one of the highest in the NFL at 63.7%, and his plus-accuracy rate (call it pass attempts with excellent ball location) is also seventh-highest.

Love to know how they measure that.  His completion percentage is 63.2%, which is good for 23rd in the league.  His on target percentage is 73% - good for 23rd among QB's with at least 50 attempts.  His bad throw percentage is 20.9%, good for 31st (again, QB's with at least 50 attempts).  He is 33rd in drops - he's only had three passes dropped all year.

53 minutes ago, TheSpecialJuan said:

This is a team that just lacks playmakers. Receivers that can consistently get open and make plays. That makes things tough for Young. Sometimes the post-snap picture is too muddy because there’s nothing for Young to look at, everyone is covered.

Keep seeing this dragged around, and it's just an excuse.  I worked it out a week or so ago.  Our receivers on average have 9 inches less separation than the overall NFL average.  It's not ideal, but it's just not that far off.  Of course you'd like to see your receivers running Travis Kelce open, but that's ALSO not anywhere near the NFL average.

56 minutes ago, TheSpecialJuan said:

It would help if the Panthers had a counter-punch in a consistent running game, but they don’t. Miles Sanders has been an abject disappointment after signing a four-year, $25 million contract in the offseason. He’s averaging just a career-low 3.1 yards per carry and his 0.08 missed tackles forced per attempt is sixth-lowest among all ball carriers with at least 25 attempts.

There is a bit of a point here, however, there's more to the story.  100% agree, Sanders has been eleventy kinds of awful this year.  The real story however is that our defense isn't keeping the games close enough for a run game to really take root.  We are next to last in points surrendered per game.  It's very hard to run the ball when you are down multiple scores.

I really despise superficial reporting.  I wish someone would take the time to do real analysis.  C'est la vie.

[Varking]

Lots of words to say our offense has been one of the worst in the NFL and outside of AT, nothing has been great. And y'all can sleep on him but AT has been great. Better than expected for a WR of his age. 

We average 5.5 yards per pass attempt as a team so far in 2023. The last time Carolina was that low was 2010 when we averaged 5.4 for the season. Clausen averaged 5.2 and Bryce is currently averaging 5.3. 

We have a new playcaller tomorrow and Bryce gets more and more experience under his belt each week. I am expecting a pretty good game from him in a game that should be close the entire way.

[LinvilleGorge]

Honestly, Thielen might be the only piece of our offense I'd give a passing grade thus far.

[Varking]

3 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Honestly, Thielen might be the only piece of our offense I'd give a passing grade thus far.

That is where I am at 6 games into the season. He is the only thing that has been a slam dunk positive on offense. 

[LinvilleGorge]

3 minutes ago, Varking said:

That is where I am at 6 games into the season. He is the only thing that has been a slam dunk positive on offense. 

Agreed. You're having to try to make an argument for anyone else.

[UnluckyforSome]

I am shocked beyond belief at how this offense has struggled, especially given that we have Panthers legend Hayden Hurst. It must be all the other non-legend players that are dragging it down.

Edited October 29, 2023 by UnluckyforSome

[SmokinwithWilly]

A lot. 

[pantherj]

I wrote an article starting with what's right with our offense. See below.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited October 29, 2023 by pantherj

[Khyber53]

Lot of different opinions here. And that's probably what's wrong... too many things not working to the point it seems impossible to fix one and move on. 

Let's see if two weeks of preparation against a team that was demonstrably worse than us last season with a rookie QB and HC will show any improvement.

 

[top dawg]

10 hours ago, BrianS said:

Keep seeing this dragged around, and it's just an excuse.  I worked it out a week or so ago.  Our receivers on average have 9 inches less separation than the overall NFL average.  It's not ideal, but it's just not that far off.  Of course you'd like to see your receivers running Travis Kelce open, but that's ALSO not anywhere near the NFL average.

Man, I told you before: in this game of inches, nine inches of separation is huge. That's a big deal. Don't minimize it. 

And, sure, it's average, but that is not the standard we're shooting for. I'd guess that the top tier teams have even more than nine inches. We need a better TE, or at least to start throwing to TEs.

Edited October 29, 2023 by top dawg

[top dawg]

I'd also add that play calling absolutely matters in terms of receiver separation. The few inches that you gain with pre-snap motions and play action plays could be the difference between a catch made and a pass break up, or a busted play or a big play. All this stuff makes a difference and works together (or not).

[CamWhoaaCam]

Remember those Mingo/TMJ hype threads in the off-season?

 

 

[top dawg]

13 minutes ago, CamWhoaaCam said:

Remember those Mingo/TMJ hype threads in the off-season?

 

 

No, but I remember the usual fluff material put out by the Panthers social media team.