Best draft picks ever at each slot (4 Panthers)

[CRA]

Before you click below....

The best NFL draft pick ever at every slot from No. 1 to 262 - ESPN

ESPN just put out a list.  4 Panthers made the list.   3 are DBs.   1 is OL.  Unlimited pie for the first to guess 3 out of the 4 WITHOUT cheating!  I will know if you cheated because you will have gotten it right. 

[L-TownCat]

Chris Gamble

Captain Munnerlyn

Mike Minter

Ryan Khalil.

 

[CRA]

2 minutes ago, L-TownCat said:

Chris Gamble

Captain Munnerlyn

Mike Minter

Ryan Khalil.

 

this contains 1 correct answer for guessers.  Captain.  

Captain is either the easiest or 2nd easiest.  2 are what I would deem near impossible. 

[Icy89]

Would have guessed Steve Smith in the 3rd but no WR.   

Can't fathom Taylor Moton in the 2nd as an OL but I don't have anyone else who could make that kind of list.

DB I got Josh Norman and no idea beyond that.  All the other DBs who were good were early rounders (Gamble, Minter, Horn, even Godfrey as a 3rd rounder)

[L-TownCat]

Just now, CRA said:

this contains 1 correct answer for guessers.  Captain.  

Captain is either the easiest or 2nd easiest.  2 are what I would deem near impossible. 

Nobody is getting  close without looking.  That’s a strange group of panthers.

[CRA]

2 minutes ago, Icy89 said:

Would have guessed Steve Smith in the 3rd but no WR.   

Can't fathom Taylor Moton in the 2nd as an OL but I don't have anyone else who could make that kind of list.

DB I got Josh Norman and no idea beyond that.  All the other DBs who were good were early rounders (Gamble, Minter, Horn, even Godfrey as a 3rd rounder)

Norman is correct.  

That's 2 that have been guessed. 

Captain and Norman.  IMO, those are the only 2 people got a shot at guessing.  The other DB would be wild for someone to guess.  And zero shot anyone guesses the OL.  Really goes to show how you shouldn't care much about late round picks.  Because not only did Panthers make the list but it isn't even good Panthers. 

[Jay Roosevelt]

Not cheating here. My guesses...

1. Ryan Kalil
2. Ricky Manning, Jr.
3. Josh Norman
4. Mike Minter

[AceMan]

Saw what ESPN put for the 1st pick and now I immediately disagree with the list overall

[L-TownCat]

28 minutes ago, AceMan said:

Saw what ESPN put for the 1st pick and now I immediately disagree with the list overall

I’m not one to get my pompoms for Peyton, but as far as #1 picks go, it’s a difficult task to advocate for a better pick.  There are others worthy but it’s a coin flip at best.

[Pejorative Miscreant]

I’m voting for Byron Bell.  He technically wasn’t drafted but we got a lot of starts and playing time out of him so I guess if you go for value then he’d be on the list.  Some would say a potted plant would have served the same purpose but not the guys fault.  Should have never been in that position.  

[UnluckyforSome]

No idea on the OL, but as for another DB, maybe Cota or Grant?

[Steves89]

Lester Townes was the first I thought of but he is lb. 

[Ornias]

1 hour ago, Icy89 said:

Would have guessed Steve Smith in the 3rd but no WR.   

Can't fathom Taylor Moton in the 2nd as an OL but I don't have anyone else who could make that kind of list.

DB I got Josh Norman and no idea beyond that.  All the other DBs who were good were early rounders (Gamble, Minter, Horn, even Godfrey as a 3rd rounder)

Steve Smith was the 74th pick and there are already 3 hall of famers from that slot. 

[SmokinwithWilly]

58 minutes ago, UnluckyforSome said:

No idea on the OL, but as for another DB, maybe Cota or Grant?

I liked Cota. I think it was his contract offer from NO that I first heard of the poison pill.