47 QBs drafted since 2022.

[Tbe]

….and only Jayden Daniel’s and Purdy look they will be something.

Maybe JJ McCarthy and Penix.

Stroud seems to be on a extended downward trajectory.

The Panthers chose poorly picking Bryce, but did they ever have a chance given our hypothetical top options were Bryce, CJ, Richardson, and Caleb the following year?

I doubt we would have chosen Jayden with the #1 pick.

In hindsight, our best option was sticking with Baker. 

[jb2288]

Finding a QB is very hard. Finding a QB for the Tepper's Panthers is impossible. 

[dep]

I remember people were actually excited about Matt corral 

[Waldo]

Meh the Texans struck gold with Stroud and then showed their normal standards. I couldn't belive that GM did good but he is blowing it now. I would bet he will flourish elsewhere when he walks. Caleb was always going to take time with his mental maturity but at least he has the coaching now. I would take anyone but Richardson over Young in a heartbeat. 

[Tbe]

1 minute ago, Waldo said:

Meh the Texans struck gold with Stroud and then showed their normal standards. I couldn't belive that GM did good but he is blowing it now. I would bet he will flourish elsewhere when he walks. Caleb was always going to take time with his mental maturity but at least he has the coaching now. I would take anyone but Richardson over Young in a heartbeat. 

The entire list is trash. 

[Jackie Lee]

I would say one of my biggest problems is lack of attempts at drafting qb's in the mid to late rounds all the way back to since we drafted Cam. Just complacent with the position from a developmental side for some reason. Between the Cam and Bryce drafts pretty sure our only attempts were Grier and Corral lol. 

[LinvilleGorge]

There's a reason why proven QBs - even mid-level ones - get PAID. NFL QBs are hard to find and if you have one you can compete. If you don't you can't. It's pretty much that simple.

[Jon Snow]

1 minute ago, Jackie Lee said:

I would say one of my biggest problems is lack of attempts at drafting qb's in the mid to late rounds all the way back to since we drafted Cam. Just complacent with the position from a developmental side for some reason. Between the Cam and Bryce drafts pretty sure our only attempts were Grier and Corral lol. 

This team has never drafted a qb to develop, tuly develop to take over if and when the starter proves ineffective.  They only draft one a couple of years after the starter has been ineffective. They never plan ahead. 

[Waldo]

6 minutes ago, Tbe said:

The entire list is trash. 

If you include the teams the QB went too it absolutely is trash. I still stand by what I said. Top picks usually go to trash or dysfunctional teams. That's why there is a trend of guys getting another shot and proving they aren't trash these days. 

Now add in the trash coaching at thr school level effecting the quality in the NFL. None of this happens in a vacuum and player quality is declining due to that. This last drafts first round was filled with normal 2nd round talent. It's not just QBs

[Khyber53]

NIL money has changed the college game, particularly at the QB level. There's a character development aspect that isn't happening anymore and not just in leadership, but in the idea that you have to pay the dues, earn your spot and overcome. 

And then we ask these half-baked products to come out on opening week in their first year (or second or third even) and take the world by storm. They didn't have to back up  Brett Favre or Joe Montana or anyone for that matter. The only one I can think of that had to ride the pine before taking the reins was Love in Green Bay and once he took over for Rodgers he showed maturity and an understanding of not just the game but his place within it.

I know, I know, old fart yelling at the clouds.  Yadda yadda.

[Tbe]

1 minute ago, Khyber53 said:

NIL money has changed the college game, particularly at the QB level. There's a character development aspect that isn't happening anymore and not just in leadership, but in the idea that you have to pay the dues, earn your spot and overcome. 

And then we ask these half-baked products to come out on opening week in their first year (or second or third even) and take the world by storm. They didn't have to back up  Brett Favre or Joe Montana or anyone for that matter. The only one I can think of that had to ride the pine before taking the reins was Love in Green Bay and once he took over for Rodgers he showed maturity and an understanding of not just the game but his place within it.

I know, I know, old fart yelling at the clouds.  Yadda yadda.

You’re not wrong.

[Candler Cat]

So we should have kept all our picks and not moved up?

[amcoolio]

14 minutes ago, Candler Cat said:

So we should have kept all our picks and not moved up?

Yes. QBs are less than a coin flip now. Absolutely no way of knowing if they are going to be good or not. Fitterer ruined the decade for this team

[CanadianCat]

54 minutes ago, Tbe said:

….and only Jayden Daniel’s and Purdy look they will be something.

Maybe JJ McCarthy and Penix.

Stroud seems to be on a extended downward trajectory.

The Panthers chose poorly picking Bryce, but did they ever have a chance given our hypothetical top options were Bryce, CJ, Richardson, and Caleb the following year?

I doubt we would have chosen Jayden with the #1 pick.

In hindsight, our best option was sticking with Baker. 

In hindsight, honestly we should have stuck with Teddy and built the team up before dropping a drafted QB into place. 

We traded for Darnold, dumped him and seen him get success. 

We picked up Baker, dumped him and now will see him beat us 2x a year. 

Sometimes its not the player..