Huddle Big Board

[Stumpy]

Here you have guys, the official Carolina Huddle big board... :leaving:

I was hoping to have more lists to use for this, but the "where do you rank" thread seems to be just about dead. Anyways after compiling everyone's top 10 lists in that thread, it seems the Huddle's "consensus" top 10 players in the draft are as follows...

1--Peterson

2--Green

3--Dareus

4--Miller

5--Fairley

6--Bowers

7--Newton

8--Quinn

9--Jones

10-Gabbert

Link

And, in an attempt to take away in any irrational biases, (ie "nuthuggers"/"haters") if you take away everyone's #1 and #10 it looks like this...

1--Peterson

2--Green

3--Dareus

4--Miller

5--Fairley

6--Quinn

7--Bowers

8--Jones

9--Gabbert

10-Newton

Link

...take this for what you will.

[Ricky Spanish]

that's actually very interesting.

cool stuff sir.

[JawnyBlaze]

That's a pretty small Big Board :) Good work though, interesting to see.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Kemba Walker for #1 overall.

[davos]

Cool stuff. That's telling on how more chill the majority of posters are here. Its just the occasional loud ones that make you forget that most of us are pretty much open to all possibilities, consequentially liking the BPA: Patrick Peterson. Peace. :)

[Jackofalltrades]

Rep.

[Catalyst]

Seems odd that Newton is so low when so many of us here want him. I'd have expected him to be top-5 at least, if not top-3.

[Stumpy]

Seems odd that Newton is so low when so many of us here want him. I'd have expected him to be top-5 at least, if not top-3.

Everyone who had Newton in their top 5 had him at number one. I actually did another one where I looked at everyone's list as a weighted top 5 ballot a la Heisman voting. If you look at it that way, Newton comes in 5th in voting.

1--Peterson-164

2--Green----144

3--Miller------92

4--Dareus----86

5--Newton---50

6--Fairley----32

7--Quinn-----14

8--Jones-----12

9--Bowers----10

10-Harris-----4

11-Gabbert---0

1st=10, 2nd=8, 3rd=6, 4th=4, 5th=2

[Marguide]

The first one listed looks reasonable to me, other than Bowers. Given the situation with his knee, he may end up falling far.

You know there's another way to look at this. Let's say you had a team made up of 21 average players. You can only add one.

Which one has the biggest impact?

[pantherj]

The first one listed looks reasonable to me, other than Bowers. Given the situation with his knee, he may end up falling far.

You know there's another way to look at this. Let's say you had a team made up of 21 average players. You can only add one.

Which one has the biggest impact?

QB.... :yikes: so we should take a QB! Well done worthy foe. Just d!cking around with you, but yes QB.

[chef17]

The first one listed looks reasonable to me, other than Bowers. Given the situation with his knee, he may end up falling far.

You know there's another way to look at this. Let's say you had a team made up of 21 average players. You can only add one.

Which one has the biggest impact?

Depends. If you add an average player than no impact is made.

[MadHatter]

Seems odd that Newton is so low when so many of us here want him. I'd have expected him to be top-5 at least, if not top-3.

Not really.

It is not that so many people want him....it is just that those that do are the loud mouths on the board....:sifone:

[JawnyBlaze]

Because even the ones that want him, that aren't blind fanatics, admit he's not a top ten football player right now. Maybe in the future...but not now.

Seems odd that Newton is so low when so many of us here want him. I'd have expected him to be top-5 at least, if not top-3.

[MHS831]

This thread is practically hugger free. People are making rational comments and not being attacked for their insolence. Freedom of speech and the ability to express logical, reasonable perspectives without scorn or ridicule from Cult Cam is nice.