Would you trade Anderson to St Louis?

[Jeremy Igo]

They need a pocket passer for their offense.

Are you comfortable enough with Webb as a backup to trade Anderson to St Louis to start for them?

Sent from Carolina Huddle App for Android.

[stirs]

Ha, I just posted this in the NFL section.

 

They have 3 tackles

[t96]

Yes but we'd get more value for Webb. DA is no better than Hill for them. Webb has shined a lot this offseason and we could get something for nothing out of him.

[La Pantera]

For a 2nd, Tackle or S???......yes!

[cookinbrak]

If we could get a decent player in exchange, yeah. I think Webb brings something to the table that DA can't.

[OneBadCat]

Hell no. If Cam's hurt and we don't have Anderson we are toast.

 

 

Anderson can at least make us competitive. I'm not sold on Webb. He's made some nice throws but we don't know that he can handle a whole game against starters. Also, trading Anderson makes Cam the most experienced QB on the roster. Although I think Cam is just about on his way to handling things on his own I think a vet like Anderson is still valuable to him as a mentor and teacher.

[CarolinaSamurai]

Webb is more similar to Cam so I like keeping Webb so that most the plays are the same.

Sent from my iPhone using CarolinaHuddle

[Pox 08]

No.  I would trade Webb to them though.

 

 

I prefer DA to Webb.  DA has been in the fire,  he has taken the abuse,   he has started many games and is a true journeyman veteran.

 

 

I would hate to see Webb out there,  trying to deal with a ton of pressure.

[*FreeFua*]

Hell no. If Cam's hurt and we don't have Anderson we are toast.

Anderson can at least make us competitive. I'm not sold on Webb. He's made some nice throws but we don't know that he can handle a whole game against starters.

If Cam's hurt we are toast.

[hepcat]

How many people thought this same thing as soon as they saw Bradford went down?  Well what the hell happens if Cam goes down?  Anderson's been here for going on 4 seasons now and knows the offense.  He's looked sharp in preseason.  No way you trade him because he's easily one of the best backup QB's in the game.  How many teams have a former Pro Bowler as their backup?  The Jets?  lol

[*FreeFua*]

Maybe Philly can get the 7th back for Sanchez

[Cary Kollins]

Yes.

Offensive line depth > backup QB needs

[tondi]

If we lose Cam for any significant time our season is over, just like the Rams season was over last year.  Doesn't really matter who the backup is unless you are dying to win 6 games instead of 4 games.  I would give up either of our backups to whoever wanted them if it netted us a solid return. 

[Ruff]

Yes but we'd get more value for Webb. DA is no better than Hill for them. Webb has shined a lot this offseason and we could get something for nothing out of him.

We would get more for Webb, a guy most likely to not make the team? Ok.