Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

4 the draft guys: mid- tier draft: QB with some talent


Jmac

Recommended Posts

This QB class kinda sucks from everything I've read. Now that doesn't mean there won't be one or two decent to good guys, but I'm hesitant to spend a draft pick on a QB in a bad class when we have SO many other needs. 

Lack of young talent has really hurt this team this year imo. Not that Rivera would have played the young talent anyways. 

Off the top of my head these are absolute needs this offseason in no order: DE x 2, NT (esp. if/when Poe gets cut), LT, LG, C, Nickel Back, FS, SS (if Reid isn't re-signed), LB (esp if Davis is gone and we don't re-sign Shaq). That's a TON of needs. 

Realistically our draft could go:

1-DE

2-DT

3-FS

3-DE

4-NB

5,6,7 BPA

In this scenario we go defense super heavy and would have to address o-line in FA. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, SOJA said:

This QB class kinda sucks from everything I've read. Now that doesn't mean there won't be one or two decent to good guys, but I'm hesitant to spend a draft pick on a QB in a bad class when we have SO many other needs. 

Lack of young talent has really hurt this team this year imo. Not that Rivera would have played the young talent anyways. 

Off the top of my head these are absolute needs this offseason in no order: DE x 2, NT (esp. if/when Poe gets cut), LT, LG, C, Nickel Back, FS, SS (if Reid isn't re-signed), LB (esp if Davis is gone and we don't re-sign Shaq). That's a TON of needs. 

Realistically our draft could go:

1-DE

2-DT

3-FS

3-DE

4-NB

5,6,7 BPA

In this scenario we go defense super heavy and would have to address o-line in FA. 

Does fix some major problems...so what do they do at QB if Cam is down for a while? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Jmac said:

Does fix some major problems...so what do they do at QB if Cam is down for a while? 

If Cam is out we are fuged anyways imo. This team desperately needs talent all over the place. A huge core group that has carried us for years is old/washed up/about to retire. It wouldn't matter if we drafted Russel Wilson in the third round 

Again that's just my opinion - if we do draft a QB I'll be on board but I think we have more pressing needs 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think this should be the plan:

If Cam ends up sitting next year, we tank the season and get a QB in the top 5. 

If Cam then comes back healthy and ready for another 5 years, we trade our new QB to get our 1st round pick back. If Cam isn’t better, we have a replacement. 

Either way, we use this draft to get DL and OL help so a new QB has the tools around him to succeed if I comes to that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

45 minutes ago, Tbe said:

I think this should be the plan:

If Cam ends up sitting next year, we tank the season and get a QB in the top 5. 

If Cam then comes back healthy and ready for another 5 years, we trade our new QB to get our 1st round pick back. If Cam isn’t better, we have a replacement. 

Either way, we use this draft to get DL and OL help so a new QB has the tools around him to succeed if I comes to that.

You can't tell 60 other guys - some of whom will see this as their final shot, others of room will have this be their only shot - to tank the season just because one guy can't play (even if that guy is your starting quarterback).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, BrianS said:

A lot of folks have been saying Bridgewater recently, and honestly it's not a terrible idea if he'll come at the right price.  He should be willing, given he's thrown exactly three passes since 2015 ended.

We'd be fortunate to get him, even if only on a one year deal.  It would give Bridgewater a chance to showcase his talents and secure a long term deal (not necessarily with the Panthers) if things work out.

It would also give the organization an additional year to assess Cam's health status, allowing the Panthers to make an informed decision as to whether to stay the course or move in another direction.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It’s not an option right now but if Kyler Murray reworks his contract with the Athletics (I believe there is a clause that prohibits him from entering the NFL draft but I could be wrong) then he could potentially enter the NFL draft. At that point we could spend a 6th round pick on him or so and hold his rights during spring baseball. If he realizes at that point he doesn’t want to play baseball he can sign with us. He would be the Panthers property for one year and if he remains unsigned he would just enter the draft pool again. Many scouts believe this will happen.

I do also like Will Grier and think the positivity of his accuracy far outweighs the negatives of his arm strength. I’d spend a fourth on him but I don’t see him falling out of the second.

I also like Gardner Minshew as a late round prospect. He seems to be more of a back up type player but I like how hard he works. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Sure it does, maybe not every position and not every draft.  You have to admit the hit rate goes down the further in the draft you get.  Would you more readily find a generational talent at the #2 pick or #19 pick?  High picks are considered "busts" if they doesn't pan out, whereas guys drafted later don't have that level of scrutiny upon them.  Different expectation levels.  If Styles does indeed go #2, I already listed the rarefied air that he would be in.  Maybe he doesn't set the League on fire, but my gut feeling is he does.  Again, you don't take an off-ball LB #2 if he is just a 'really good' player.
    • To illustrate my point, I watched (and commented on the Huddle) that Rozeboom would often wait a full second (or close to it) before taking his first step.  I assume that he probably had issues with false steps, a faulty practice that can take an ILB out of the gap completely.  Watch Luke and you see a step with the snap, and rarely was it a false step.  Rozeboom may have had 100 tackles (speculating) but initial contact was 2-3 yards on the defensive side of the ball.  Luke's 100 tackles were made 1-2 yards from the LOS.  Over the course of a year, Luke was much more productive (more fumbles, fewer long gainers, more OL penalties, fewer first downs, etc) that Rozeboom, but on the stat sheet, they both had 100 tackles.  In fact, Rozeboom's inefficiency kept him on the field more (more first downs, fewer OL penalties, turnovers, and punts) so he should have MORE tackles.   I would like to see stats that break down those things.   For example again, Josh Norman was slow--4.68 or so at CB.  However, his anticipation speed was incredible.  He made as many plays as a 4.4 CB.  I had one coach (college--later became the head coach at WCU) tell me that slower players have to use their brains more to still be around.  Elite athletes can just get by on their physical superiority.  He added, "Rarely does a football player run full speed.  Most of the time, they are not, so the 40 time is misleading stat.  Smart players overcome shortcomings--when the elite athlete becomes average (slows with age, advances in level of competition) they struggle against smarter (football IQ) competition.  
    • Obviously tongue in cheek hyperbole. But we do not need a first round RB to compete for a championship. We need intelligent roster building. That to me is the complete opposite of intelligent roster building because it is a prime resource at a devalued plug and play position when we have needs across the defense.
×
×
  • Create New...