Mike Minter & Hall of Honor

[NJPanthers12]

Pretty straight forward question. Is mike Minter in your mind worth of being inducted into the Panthers Hall of Honor down the road?

[Still Brooklyn]

If we just add names willy nilly, we'll need an entire stadium just for names. I don't even think Gross deserves it.

[CBDellinger]

I don’t think so.

I really worry how that that knob on his forehead would look in bronze.

But they should make the radio broadcasters say “MINTERception!!” whenever the defense gets a pick.  

win/win

[NJPanthers12]

7 minutes ago, Still Brooklyn said:

If we just add names willy nilly, we'll need an entire stadium just for names. I don't even think Gross deserves it.

I was hoping to keep this conversation to just Minter, but I am curious. If you could start the HOH over from scratch with retired players only, who would you include ?

[DamnItJake!]

Use the other threads stop the individual misses like John Kasay 

[Still Brooklyn]

4 minutes ago, NJPanthers12 said:

I was hoping to keep this conversation to just Minter, but I am curious. If you could start the HOH over from scratch with retired players only, who would you include ?

First I'd remove the PSL fans, and McCormick or whatever his name is. Should be players only.

But ... Mills, Smith, and Kasay. Eventually Peppers. Luke and Cam down the road.

Minter, Walls, Kevin Greene, Gross, Thomas Davis, Jake, etc. all have great stories, but they just aren't top tier. Hell, I'd even consider saying no to Kasay as it defeats my criteria. Hoover deserves it but he's a FB and no one cares about FBs.

[t96]

7 minutes ago, NJPanthers12 said:

I was hoping to keep this conversation to just Minter, but I am curious. If you could start the HOH over from scratch with retired players only, who would you include ?

The only players that aren’t still playing I would’ve included are Smitty and Pep. Walls and Gross are fine and great players but HoH should be a little more exclusive, otherwise it will just mean nothing at some point. TD once he’s done is a 100% no brainer and Cam and Luke are very likely, but otherwise there are no others currently that I’d consider.

[NJPanthers12]

18 minutes ago, Still Brooklyn said:

First I'd remove the PSL fans, and McCormick or whatever his name is. Should be players only.

But ... Mills, Smith, and Kasay. Eventually Peppers. Luke and Cam down the road.

Minter, Walls, Kevin Greene, Gross, Thomas Davis, Jake, etc. all have great stories, but they just aren't top tier. Hell, I'd even consider saying no to Kasay as it defeats my criteria. Hoover deserves it but he's a FB and no one cares about FBs.

I’m very surprised by the high standards. IF we were talking about retired numbers, I would agreee just 89 and 90. But the hall of honor should honor the best Panthers of all time. I think that includes Kalil, Muhammad, Rucker, Minter, etc.

[cookinbrak]

I would only include players who retired a Panther. If you retired as a member of another team, go there.

[Moo Daeng]

It's not that he is unworthy but I don't think anyone thinks of Mike Minter when they think of the Panthers.

[Moo Daeng]

1 hour ago, t96 said:

The only players that aren’t still playing I would’ve included are Smitty and Pep. Walls and Gross are fine and great players but HoH should be a little more exclusive, otherwise it will just mean nothing at some point. TD once he’s done is a 100% no brainer and Cam and Luke are very likely, but otherwise there are no others currently that I’d consider.

How do you argue against Walls and his significance to the first chapter of the teams history ? Were you following the team then?

[LinvilleGorge]

It seems like some are confusing the Panthers' HOH with the NFL HOF. Just Peppers and Smitty? Really???

Minter is a no for me and I love the guy. He's definitely the best safety in the organization's history, but then again that's kind of like being the tallest midget. I just don't see how a guy with zero Pro Bowls and zero All-Pros is in the HOH. Like I said, I love the guy and I won't complain a bit if he eventually gets in but I'd say no.

[Eazy-E]

If you are arguing for Minter then you have to accept Gamble as well imo.

[top dawg]

In before, "That's stupid and insane..."