Which Panther was the GOAT?

[jfra78]

14 minutes ago, Cookie Lyon said:

You know they ALWAYS have to make Jake out to better than he actually was. So much ''grit.'' 

[Navy_football]

Steve Smith was a 5'9", 185 lbs BULLY. 

On and off the field. In a sport with the biggest, baddest, meanest mofos in the WORLD! 

He is without a doubt the GOAT. You could scheme Luke. You could scheme Cam. The only way to stop 89 was to keep throwing bodies at him until you eventually slowed him down. Which usually started at around 3 defenders. Personification of a junk yard, 50 pound chain wearing, no shelter from the elements, raw meat eating, pit bull. You bet not go in that yard - if you know what I know!

[Delhomme2Muhammad]

Steve Smith being the GOAT Panther is a reflection of him being the first guy to have a lengthy career as a top tier player for a new team that has no history.

He'd be a respected, but another receiver for other teams. In some cases, wouldn't even make the slot position for their all time team.

The only player in the history of the Panthers to play in both bottom ranked teams.

Newton would be, or challenge to be, the best player and/or qb in the history of other teams.

[Sgt Schultz]

50 minutes ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

Hands down smith, than cam and luke tied I might give the slight edge to cam due to position  

It this is not right, it is very close.  Pretty much the order I was thinking of.

[top dawg]

8 hours ago, LegioX said:

Steve Smith. No question...and it’s not even close

LOL

Luke was the closest thing to the GOAT that we've ever had at his position. Smith was top 10. 

[micnificent28]

Cameron jerrell Newton

[beo]

1. smith

2. luke

3. peppers

4. cam

5. olsen

6. mills

7.  delhomme

8. walls

9.  gross

10. CMC 

 

 

 

[WarHeel]

1 hour ago, Cookie Lyon said:

You know they ALWAYS have to make Jake out to better than he actually was. So much ''grit.'' 

Who is “they?” What’re you implying?

[WarHeel]

3 minutes ago, beo said:

1. smith

2. luke

3. peppers

4. cam

5. olsen

6. mills

7.  delhomme

8. walls

9.  gross

10. CMC 

 

 

 

I like this but I think CMC climbs way up this ladder before his career is over.

[beo]

1 minute ago, WarHeel said:

I like this but I think CMC climbs way up this ladder before his career is over.

that's what i was hinting at, was deciding between him and minter but ultimately went CMC since CMC had one of (if not the) the greatest statistical seasons ever by panther last season. can't in good faith put him over gross yet though, too young and hasnt been here long enough just yet. i think CMC has the potential to maybe even leapfrog peppers and cam later down the line tho

[WarHeel]

1 minute ago, beo said:

that's what i was hinting at, was deciding between him and minter but ultimately went CMC since CMC had one of (if not the) the greatest statistical seasons ever by panther last season. can't in good faith put him over gross yet though, too young and hasnt been here long enough just yet. i think CMC has the potential to maybe even leapfrog peppers and cam later down the line tho

No doubt. Will be a tough act to follow at the RB position though. But if anyone had a chance and has proved their ability to stay healthy while still being a workhorse it’s CMC. 

[JawnyBlaze]

Smitty is my favorite but Cam has the biggest impact. No other player could carry a subpar supporting cast and inept coaching to the Super Bowl like Cam did. 

[Gesualdo]

7 hours ago, jfra78 said:

Sure, but those guys weren't even the greatest Panthers at their positions 

nailed it to the f*cking floor right here

[kungfoodude]

1. Steve Smith

2. Cam Newton

3. Julius Peppers

4. Luke Keuchly

 

Lots of players could be #5 for me.