Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

About that #6 pick and QB..


Cam's New Arm
 Share

Recommended Posts

Everybody agreed Horn was an elite talent before the draft.  And in the guy's short tenure with the Panthers before his injury, he did nothing to dispute that.  

A great CB takes away the opposing team's top receiver.  Or shuts down 1/2 of the passing area for the opposing QB.  You can build a defense around guys like that.  And CB play was a huge problem for the Panthers the previous season.  

My best guess to what happened at the draft was that when Penei Sewell got selected the pick before, the team was stuck.  It knew it needed OL but the guys left had some deficiencies (short armed Rashawn Slater) and was maybe a G in their eyes.  Misguided scouting but whatever.  So the team went with the best "sure thing" available at that pick in a shutdown CB.  The BPA at a position of team need.

I can't really scream at the club too much for this decision.  It is defensible in a lot of ways.  

  • Pie 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, BlitzMonster said:

Everybody agreed Horn was an elite talent before the draft.  And in the guy's short tenure with the Panthers before his injury, he did nothing to dispute that.  

A great CB takes away the opposing team's top receiver.  Or shuts down 1/2 of the passing area for the opposing QB.  You can build a defense around guys like that.  And CB play was a huge problem for the Panthers the previous season.  

My best guess to what happened at the draft was that when Penei Sewell got selected the pick before, the team was stuck.  It knew it needed OL but the guys left had some deficiencies (short armed Rashawn Slater) and was maybe a G in their eyes.  Misguided scouting but whatever.  So the team went with the best "sure thing" available at that pick in a shutdown CB.  The BPA at a position of team need.

I can't really scream at the club too much for this decision.  It is defensible in a lot of ways.  

But it still doesn’t change the fact that CB was a luxury for the place this team is at right now. The fact that we were able cover that position by later acquiring Gilmore shows that we did not get the best value for our #8 pick last year.

  • Pie 2
  • Beer 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've mentioned this before, but can I caution the Huddle to slow down on the Horn evaluation. Many parts of the team looked much better the first three weeks than they turned out to be over the course of the season. Imagine, for a moment, that it is Darnold who gets knocked out for the year in Week 3 rather than Horn. Most of the Huddle would have a very different view of Sam right now if all we had seen was the same three weeks we are crowning Horn for.

  • Pie 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, trueblade said:

I've mentioned this before, but can I caution the Huddle to slow down on the Horn evaluation. Many parts of the team looked much better the first three weeks than they turned out to be over the course of the season. Imagine, for a moment, that it is Darnold who gets knocked out for the year in Week 3 rather than Horn. Most of the Huddle would have a very different view of Sam right now if all we had seen was the same three weeks we are crowning Horn for.

Na, thats a bad comparison. Darnold has four year body of work that shows he isn’t the guy you want. Even his first three games hardly moved the needle to say otherwise.

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, firefox1234 said:

Na, thats a bad comparison. Darnold has four year body of work that shows he isn’t the guy you want. Even his first three games hardly moved the needle to say otherwise.

Go back and look at some of the threads before the Cowboys game and I think you'll see the needle has indeed moved on Darnold.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, BlitzMonster said:

Everybody agreed Horn was an elite talent before the draft.  And in the guy's short tenure with the Panthers before his injury, he did nothing to dispute that.  

A great CB takes away the opposing team's top receiver.  Or shuts down 1/2 of the passing area for the opposing QB.  You can build a defense around guys like that.  And CB play was a huge problem for the Panthers the previous season.  

My best guess to what happened at the draft was that when Penei Sewell got selected the pick before, the team was stuck.  It knew it needed OL but the guys left had some deficiencies (short armed Rashawn Slater) and was maybe a G in their eyes.  Misguided scouting but whatever.  So the team went with the best "sure thing" available at that pick in a shutdown CB.  The BPA at a position of team need.

I can't really scream at the club too much for this decision.  It is defensible in a lot of ways.  

I highlighted the portion that resonated the most with me. My problem with the Rhule regime is how they evaluate talent.

I'd never pass on a player if his arm length is 1 inch shorter than ideal if I had a pressing need at LT. That one inch made them view Slater as a guard? Now Slater is a Pro Bowl LT after his first year in the league.

Same thing with BC.  Rhule made him the highest O-lineman we've drafted in the two years he's been here with expectation of turning him into a guard, a position he's never played and that doesn't play to his natural ability.

TMJ was picked in the 2nd round after Robbie received a contract extension; and despite the fact that the two best centers in the draft still being available at his draft slot. Before that we had already traded down twice and passed on several lineman that could've helped us this year.. Of course we saw how little he contributed this year.

I'm still pulling for D. Brown, but I don't know why he was our first pick in the 2020 draft. But, knowing what we know now, we should have picked someone else, or traded down to pick up extra choices.

Jeremy Chinn was almost defensive rookie of the year in 2020. He's still a great player, but by moving him farther from the line on scrimmage for most snaps he wasn't nearly as effective/impactful in 2021.

Somehow he was convinced that Bridgewater was a big money/potential franchise QB despite never throwing more than 15 TD's in a season prior to 2020.

I'm just hoping that the new and more seasoned coaching staff can get the best out of what we have on the roster. These moves were needed, but even these new hires are an indication of how unprepared Matt Rhule was for the NFL. These are the type of moves he should made as soon as he entered the league, not on in your third year after as a major regression in year two.

Edited by SCO96
  • Pie 1
  • Beer 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, therealmjl said:

Fit (Rhule’s yes man) hasn’t made many good decisions since he got here.

Fit has no power. His current role is essentially a scouting manager. He has relationships in the NFL that make trades possible, and Rhule decides how to use those relationships.

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, SCO96 said:

 

I still don't think we made a major mistake passing on Fields or Jones.….

Of course time will ultimately tell but Denver, who also needed a QB had the pick right after the Panthers and they passed on Fields and Jones also.  That put me more in the camp passing on them wasn’t a mistake.  

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Most of this conversation is in hind sight. Sure given Horn got injured and missed most of the season, and Darnold was worse than we expected and our line was worse than expected it may have been a wasted pick but at the time he was drafted our secondary was abysmal and we were looking at a bunch of good opposing wide receivers. I still think it will end up being a good move.

  • Beer 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

38 minutes ago, panthers55 said:

….and Darnold was worse than we expected and our line was worse than expected 

Ok

first, everybody knew what Sam Darnold was, is and will be as a NFL Qb

second, the injury history and performance of the two OL free agents was abysmal 

The failure of the offense should not be shocking to anyone, most of all, Matt Rhule 

I know of no other pro coach in the league who would make two simultaneously egregious evaluation errors like that 

 

Edited by raleigh-panther
  • Pie 1
  • Beer 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

56 minutes ago, panthers55 said:

Darnold was worse than we expected

He has finished with the worst QBR in the league the last two seasons. The only people that didn't expect him to continue turning the ball over at a high rate were Matt Rhule and Scott Fitterer and they didn't even bother to watch his game film 😂🤦‍♂️

Edited by frankw
  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, SCO96 said:

Even those who hated the pick will acknowledge that Jaycee is going to be a Pro-Bowl (may be even All-Pro) player if he stays healthy.

It's way too early to say that. Horn showed promise in the three games he played against two rookies making their first QB starts and a depleted Saints team. It's unknown if he'll be a pro bowler, a bust, or just some average guy.

  • Pie 1
  • Beer 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • i find this to be alarming on so many levels  im going to change the order of the portions i copied from Joe’s article i  really have serious doubts   about Canales’ common sense  1. A running team forgetting to run  2. Making this game plan about Young’s passing game momentum .  Total idiot.  It is about winning games not about young’s momentum. That is what practice is for , not live games  god help us all.    Article below  Confused by the Panthers’ pass-heavy play calls vs. 49ers? Rico Dowdle probably was, too   CHARLOTTE, N.C. — In two seasons here, Canales has juggled offensive play calling with his head coach responsibilities. Sometimes the balls end up on the floor. In two critical moments Monday night, Canales chose to go with a pass in situations where a handoff would have been the more direct approach. The first was the disastrous, first-and-goal play from the 1 where Bryce Young opted against running in for the score and instead lobbed the ball toward rookie Mitchell Evans, only to see safety Ji’Ayir Brown come down with it. The second one was just as perplexing. When the 49ers were whistled for roughing long snapper J.J. Jansen on Ryan Fitzgerald’s successful PAT pulled the Panthers to 17-10, Canales took the point off the board and went for a 2-pointer from the 1. But Canales ran a play that didn’t take advantage of the spot, with Young missing Jalen Coker in the back of the end zone. (Rookie wideout Jimmy Horn Jr. appeared to be the first read in the flat.) Canales said after the game he wanted to build on Young’s record-breaking passing performance in Atlanta, and thought the line was protecting well. But that lack of rhythm Canales mentioned was the result of never giving Dowdle the opportunity to get into it. When Dowdle ripped off a 17-yard gain on the first offensive play of the second half, Canales came back to him two plays later. It was his final carry.   After an overnight, cross-country flight, Rico Dowdle began his Tuesday — at least on social media — with an emoji. Dowdle’s post on Xcontained no words accompanying the face with spiral eyes emoji, which EmojiTerra tells us symbolizes “confusion, dizziness, overwhelm or being utterly shocked.” Per the website, it’s often used to convey “feeling dazed, hypnotized, or caught off-guard in troubling or surprising situations.” It’s not hard to figure out why the Carolina Panthers running back would be feeling some or all of those emotions. Dowdle has been one of the Panthers’ fun, feel-good stories this season, an Asheville native who signed a prove-it deal with his home-state team and then got right to the business of proving it. Before the Panthers hosted the Dallas Cowboys in Week 6, Dowdle warned his former team to “buckle up,” then backed up his words by running for 183 yards and racking up 239 yards from scrimmage. But in a 20-9 loss to the San Francisco 49ers on Monday night, it was Dowdle who was buckled up. And the guy who strapped Dowdle into a safety harness and threw on the child-safety locks was none other than Panthers coach Dave Canales. Dowdle led all backs Monday — including Christian McCaffrey — by averaging 6.3 yards per carry. But while 49ers coach Kyle Shanahan was feeding McCaffrey a cornucopia of 24 carries and 31 touches, Dowdle finished with a meager six rushing attempts. That matched his season low from a loss at Arizona in Week 2, when Chuba Hubbard was still RB1 and the Panthers were throwing nearly every down in the second half trying to catch up. Dowdle wasn’t the only back Canales dissed. Hubbard had just three carries and the Panthers finished with 13 as a team, tied for the fifth fewest in franchise history. Some of it was about opportunity, or lack of it. With the 49ers’ two touchdown drives consuming more than 16 minutes, the Panthers ran just 43 offensive plays, which matched their low under Canales and tied for the second fewest in team history. But Canales, who arrived in Charlotte last year preaching the balanced offense gospel, conceded Tuesday that he didn’t emphasize the running plays on his call sheet nearly enough. “Offensively, just could not get our rhythm going. And really it just started off with the run game. I have to make sure that that comes alive,” he said during an opening statement to reporters. “That’s a part of who we are. It’s a part of what we believe in. We have two great backs that contribute to this team. The offensive line was blocking well and that was a missed opportunity by me. And I’ll do better in that regard.”        
    • IMO 2027 is the year we draft a QB. But for 2026 we should bring in a vet or 2 AND Bryce.  Canales says he wants to promote competition.. let them duke it out. Top 2 make the team.  I honestly done care who wins, but whoever does is on a short leash.   
    • The charge of a head coach is to win games. The rest of it is just horseshit. So, ultimately, he is to blame for the perplexing losses when he willingly sets us up to fail. I have zero use for a head coach that is some stooge worried about front office or ownership decisions above the goal of success and winning. That's Dave Canales. He is the one that seemingly cares more about every aspect that doesn't have to do with winning. 
×
×
  • Create New...