Bryce vs. Maye which Qb has the higher upside

[Shotgun]

27 minutes ago, Jay Roosevelt said:

But it's not right now. If Bryce doesn't get any better at all for the rest of his career then what we've seen since his return as the starter is better than Maye's floor.

I think I have a different view of what "floor" means then. 

[mrcompletely11]

1 minute ago, Shotgun said:

I think I have a different view of what "floor" means then. 

maye is bigger stronger faster more athletic with a cannon of an arm.  I feel pretty confident his floor is probably at bryces ceiling

[electro's horse]

6 minutes ago, Shotgun said:

I think I have a different view of what "floor" means then. 

You can only judge Bryce from after his benching. Talking people on tv said it so his defenders have said it to. 

[Wolfcop]

They both still have a lot to prove. At this point, it is impossible to know which will be better. 

[LinvilleGorge]

58 minutes ago, Jay Roosevelt said:

But it's not right now. If Bryce doesn't get any better at all for the rest of his career then what we've seen since his return as the starter is better than Maye's floor.

The issue you're having here is that you're acting as if the best of what we've seen from Bryce is his floor.

Is Baker Mayfield's new floor 5 TDs and nearly 400 yards? Of course not.

[The Lobo]

1 hour ago, mrcompletely11 said:

maye already has better stats as it is  Say what?

And he’s working with way less talent and it isn’t even close. 

[GamecockSmitty4]

7 hours ago, jimfear said:

Yep - no agenda at all - nothing to see here

Last I checked…Bryce went to Bama not South Carolina. 
And before anyone says anything, XL has been really bad. I also thought at the time we picked him too high and he is not a WR1. 

[MechaZain]

On 1/1/2025 at 11:32 AM, electro's horse said:

You can only judge Bryce from after his benching. Talking people on tv said it so his defenders have said it to. 

It's fair to believe that Young's worst is behind him and his floor was raised with the benching. I'm not sold though. The best I can give him so far is that he plays to the level of those around him. I think he could win in the right offense but that he goes back to being the worst QB in football in the wrong offense.

[catnip]

Draft a QB in the late rounds or bring in a vet .  Our current backup is aging out .