Round 1 - Panthers Select Tetairoa McMillan at Pick 8

[Icege]

Anger addiction is a wild thing

Edited April 25, 2025 by Icege

[ForJimmy]

7 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

Funny I remember you telling me the same thing last year when I was against the XL pick.  How did that work out?

I told you Brugler has him ranked as WR3 in the 24 class?  What are you even talking about with your endless whining?  You said he would be WR6 in last year's class.  I gave you two different solid sources disputing that.  Now you are crying about pick 32 from last year and comparing it? Maybe you need to get some fresh air and decompress for a little bit....

[Panthering]

1 minute ago, *FreeFua* said:

This is a good one to watch for those that don’t like the pick

His route running looks just fine to me, Dave Canales even shouted out how he "reduces" his routes really well which will get him separation.

[FuFuLamePoo]

4 minutes ago, Panthering said:

Yep. Back to back 1,300 yard seasons is nothing to scoff at. He's produced and he's got the measurables, rather than the XL method of he's got the measurables but hasn't produced as much. 

In addition to filling a GLARING need, there’s such a strong case he was simply the best and cleanest prospect on the board. I’m very pleased with how they approached last night.

[Panthering]

51 minutes ago, CPF4LIFE said:

So he is already super sensitive??

Typical volleyball player

[ForJimmy]

10 minutes ago, Bear Hands said:

Not to mention, how they’re ranked as prospects is never clean with the output. Marv Jr was this undeniable prospect but now people are really questioning if he’s a #1 with Nabers and BTJ looking like the absolute truth for their squads.

Also a lesson- never shy from the LSU receivers — minus that one we drafted lol

TMac is just a case of prospect fatigue.  Watching some of his highlights I'm surprised he played as well as he did with that QB play...

[ForJimmy]

11 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

no fuging way tet is a better prospect then thomas or ladd, come on man

You are confusing pre-draft prospect rankings with NFL performances.  

[mrcompletely11]

5 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

I told you Brugler has him ranked as WR3 in the 24 class?  What are you even talking about with your endless whining?  You said he would be WR6 in last year's class.  I gave you two different solid sources disputing that.  Now you are crying about pick 32 from last year and comparing it? Maybe you need to get some fresh air and decompress for a little bit....

again you were telling me the same fuging thing about XL last year and me being negative.  How is that working out for you now?

[Bear Hands]

1 minute ago, ForJimmy said:

TMac is just a case of prospect fatigue.  Watching some of his highlights I'm surprised he played as well as he did with that QB play...

Yeah there’s the guys that legit fall due to character/injury (Pearce, WJ) but then ones where it’s pure fatigue of discussion — think it happened with McMillan and Graham a bit this year.

[Panthers Rhule]

34 minutes ago, carpanfan96 said:

Highest I've seen him was PFF at 4 which is silly. Didn't see anyone else have a top ten grade on him. 

The Panthers did

[FuFuLamePoo]

Also it’s usually promising when it sounds like other teams were trying to get the player you drafted. We know he wasn’t falling past Dallas at 12, and the Rams were rumored to be trying to move up for him. This doesn’t feel like last year when for some reason we were way higher on Legette than everyone else.

[FuFuLamePoo]

1 minute ago, Panthers Rhule said:

The Panthers did

Panthers twitter goat Billy Marshall had him #4 on his big board. He’s been doing this for a long time and I value what he has to say.

[MHS831]

I hesitated to read this thread because I knew the butt-hurt bitches who attack others would be out if full force--spewing prophecies and personal attacks---so I won't respond to the second guessers.  The bottom line:  We drafted the top WR in the draft.   At some point, we would have to add a WR to our WR room.  There are a lot of Edges left today, a lot of safeties that should be available today.  Personally, I did not see the Walker or the Williams fit--but I too was convinced that we would take Walker.  That had to increase the sting in some anal cavities and the only cure for that is go on a discussion board and raise hell like a toddler with a moth stuck to his lollipop.

Some scholar said, "How did (XL) work out?"  Pure dumbassery.  We knew he was raw and only had a few starts under his belt.  Then he hurt his foot in camp. For many games, he had old Bryce and Dalton as his QB.

I was not a TMac endorser.  But that does not matter now.  He is a Panther.  XL is a Panther.  Coker is a Panther--that is a pretty solid core of young WRs if they play to their potential.  Gotta be hopeful and excited about the WR room.  Nobody gives a crap if you or I like the pick or not.

[Jon Snow]

2 minutes ago, MHS831 said:

I hesitated to read this thread because I knew the butt-hurt bitches who attack others would be out if full force--spewing prophecies and personal attacks---so I won't respond to the second guessers.  The bottom line:  We drafted the top WR in the draft.   At some point, we would have to add a WR to our WR room.  There are a lot of Edges left today, a lot of safeties that should be available today.  Personally, I did not see the Walker or the Williams fit--but I too was convinced that we would take Walker.  That had to increase the sting in some anal cavities and the only cure for that is go on a discussion board and raise hell like a toddler with a moth stuck to his lollipop.

Some scholar said, "How did (XL) work out?"  Pure dumbassery.  We knew he was raw and only had a few starts under his belt.  Then he hurt his foot in camp. For many games, he had old Bryce and Dalton as his QB.

I was not a TMac endorser.  But that does not matter now.  He is a Panther.  XL is a Panther.  Coker is a Panther--that is a pretty solid core of young WRs if they play to their potential.  Gotta be hopeful and excited about the WR room.  Nobody gives a crap if you or I like the pick or not.

Can I like the pick and still be butthurt? The rules around here seem to change daily.