Message to the 2025 Panthers Front Office

[Proudiddy]

37 minutes ago, CRA said:

It's totally the Panthers way to put out someone week 1 who isn't a punt returner in the NFL and just pray.....

It's like Donald Trump and Joe Biden had a baby....and then that baby was dropped on it's head.  That's the Panthers. 

I’m not worried about PR.  Horn did it some in college, but even watching him in preseason, he’s a natural at it.  He has shiftiness and playmaking ability naturally as well.  
 

but I absolutely do think HR, nursing a hammy or not, should 1000% be on this roster over Moore.

[frankw]

8 minutes ago, CRA said:

high drop %, horrific YAC per reception , and doesn't get open.  David Moore doesn't actually do anything well. 

He is a ST team warm body. 

There are reasons we are the worst team in all of pro sports.  It the decision makers.  I mean, forget Renfrow.  Moore still being on this roster highlights all you need to know about why we stink.  Easily better options everywhere to upgrade over dudes.  Now multiple it out.  If they can upgrade the glaringly east stuff.  You know they can't do it elsewhere. 

 

We'll see. I'll be keeping tabs on the snap counts for Moore versus the younger receivers.

[Murph]

11 minutes ago, CRA said:

 

There are reasons we are the worst team in all of pro sports. 

 

App

 

 

[CRA]

1 minute ago, Proudiddy said:

I’m not worried about PR.  Horn did it some in college, but even watching him in preseason, he’s a natural at it.  He has shiftiness and playmaking ability naturally as well.  
 

but I absolutely do think HR, nursing a hammy or not, should 1000% be on this roster over Moore.

I got no issue w/ Horn taking a spot. I don't love him as a week 1 PR guy though. 

I mean, if they cut Renfrow and Moore? I'd be like......sucks but I get it.  Moore being on the roster just highlights negatives about our decision makers....and you know it isn't going to just be Moore where they exercise their bad decision making.  We are where we are because of it.  

[Khaki Lackey]

51 minutes ago, Jay Roosevelt said:

I worry they're going to force XL onto the field to try and justify taking him so high, even when he's clearly not a starting-caliber player.

So you would have cut Bryce already? 

[Joe Bear]

6 minutes ago, Khaki Lackey said:

So you would have cut Bryce already? 

As bad as he was, I was more impressed with Bryce as a rookie than XL as a rookie.

[ClawOn]

48 minutes ago, CRA said:

high drop %, horrific YAC per reception , and doesn't get open.  David Moore doesn't actually do anything well. 

 

18 first downs last season as a 5th or 6th option. 3 TDs.  Don't get the hate.

 

[WarPanthers89]

You can’t tell me Moore and Tremayne are better playing WR than Renfrow 

[LinvilleGorge]

I wonder if the hammy is still an issue? He immediately reached for it after that hospital ball in the final PS game. I'd still rather have Renfrow on PUP vs. Moore active.

[ForJimmy]

17 minutes ago, ClawOn said:

18 first downs last season as a 5th or 6th option. 3 TDs.  Don't get the hate.

 

He looked decent filling in during that Kansas City game.  Regardless WRs this deep on the roster are special teams players primarily.  

[pantherclaw]

1 hour ago, Jay Roosevelt said:

I worry they're going to force XL onto the field to try and justify taking him so high, even when he's clearly not a starting-caliber player.

XL has the highest ceiling of any receiver we have. He damn well better be part of the game plan. 

[csx]

Yeah, they better put XL to the test. 

[PadresPanthersFan]

I've seen moore around the NFL for years. He offers nothing dozens of other players can do with 0 upside.

Renfrow IMHO offered slightly more with wayyy more upside and reasons to root for him and the team. 

That being said we are getting upset about a 5th or 6th wr. 

That also being said he'll probably sign with someone else, ball out and we can all say told you so

[frankw]

49 minutes ago, Joe Bear said:

As bad as he was, I was more impressed with Bryce as a rookie than XL as a rookie.

Makes no sense. Bryce Young as a rookie at times looked like a fish out of water as an NFL QB.

XL despite his issues with the drops was getting open and blowing past defensive backs.

Definitely noticing a tendency from certain people who harp on XL more than others.

Edited 1 hour ago by frankw