Is Mike Jack already the 2nd best trade in Panthers history?

[Basbear]

Long ways to catch goat-status Olsen for a 3rd, but what are the other trades that can complete with the rare positive Panthers out-come??

 

 

Bonus comment- When Coker is back and that should be soon(within one full week), Im about 87.41983% sure Jimmy Horn will be cut....rip PS lovefest, Prepare thy self.....

[Lurk21]

Mike Jack is the perfect complement to Horn. Definitely  a sleeper vs compensation!  As for Horn, the way wrs get hurt, I doubt he gets cut. He may honestly get active status over Etienne bc of special teams. 

[SOJA]

won't call him out but one of our resident negative posters was calling this trade a flop before he ever even played a snap for us lol 

[Basbear]

3 minutes ago, Lurk21 said:

Mike Jack is the perfect complement to Horn. Definitely  a sleeper vs compensation!  As for Horn, the way wrs get hurt, I doubt he gets cut. He may honestly get active status over Etienne bc of special teams. 

 

I honestly thought last season if you took away names and numbers, he played a little better(like 1-2%) than Horn and he didn't miss a snap either. Same this season, he's ballin without the Panthers getting sacks. Given his contract, he's a super bargain on early returns too....

 

I think Jimmy Horn is the cut, the WR I thought would be cut Campbell made a great ST play and has the frame that Dave looks for in WRs. I will cry PS hype tears when it happens..... 

[Basbear]

7 minutes ago, SOJA said:

won't call him out but one of our resident negative posters was calling this trade a flop before he ever even played a snap for us lol 

F that nice stuff, serve them a fresh boil plate of crow!!

[LinvilleGorge]

Hell, we've been so bad at trading for players I'm honestly trying to remember another positive one.

[CRA]

probably too early given our 3 game stretch of competition to put him over Jared Allen.  We got him for a 6th and was a really nice vet cog to that 15-1 machine that was just as much defense as it was Cam

[jb2288]

Jared Allen really the only other one I can think of. On one side he only played 1 season and wasn’t that massive a difference maker on the other it was a really damn good season. 

Edited September 23, 2025 by jb2288

[electro's horse]

Chris Harris. 

[CRA]

1.  Olsen

2.  Allen

3.  THE JJ Jansen

4. Mike with potential to move up or down 

[electro's horse]

5 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Hell, we've been so bad at trading for players I'm honestly trying to remember another positive one.

Stephon Gilmore erasure smdh 

[frankw]

Undoubtedly he's a very solid player and was a really good acquisition.

Now the question is how will he Jaycee and the rest of the secondary fare when we go up against a really good QB and our offense has to sustain drives to keep them off the field too long.

[BlazeCarolina]

I mean we got a third and a seventh for Kelvin Benjamin...

I know that doesn't hit the same, but still.

[mrcompletely11]

31 minutes ago, SOJA said:

won't call him out but one of our resident negative posters was calling this trade a flop before he ever even played a snap for us lol 

Link?