Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Cam optioned to that terrible 4th and 1 call


Tr3ach
 Share

Recommended Posts

30 minutes ago, Tr3ach said:

Yea I'm not really posting it to blame Cam but Rhule was getting flamed on here when that happened and then everyone was freaking out when Rhule was angry with him on the sidelines.   This just shines a little light on that one specific situation that was definitely getting a lot of flack. 

I’d like to hear Cam’s version of that but we won’t 

it seems to me Teddy had a different version of Rhule’s stories too

perhaps he souldve brought in his dog PJ

Edited by raleigh-panther
  • Pie 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

So, why does a coach give the QB an option to throw the screen when the LoS is loaded, and then blame the QB for the coach allowing the option to a screen when the defense is loaded up on the LoS.

It was a 4th and 1. Bills defense loaded the LoS. Coach had Newton in the shotgun for a zone read run play. That zone read run play in the shotgun on 4th and 1 had no chance to deveolp. Newton knew it. Coach allowed to option to a screen, which had a better chance at success and was still a garbage option.

Play calling was garbage on that 4th and 1. Don't blame a QB when you put him in that position. QB sneak. Power run if your OL is so good. Quick out or swing if the CBs are playing off or cheating in. That college garbage 4th and 1 play calling wont work in the NFL.

Coach put QB in a no win 4th and 1 and blamed the QB for not developing a zone read from the shotgun with the entire defense pressed up to the line.

I think we all knew that play was a loss when we saw the shotgun followed by a timeout only to go right back to the shotgun.

  • Flames 9
Link to comment
Share on other sites

newton_david.png&w=160&h=160&scale=crop

David NewtonESPN Staff Writer 

Matt Rhule hasn't called out Cam Newton often since the QB returned, but he did on the fourth-and-1 incompletion from midfield with 2:05 left in the first quarter Sunday. "It's a zone-read play. It shouldn't be thrown. There's a bubble in there in case an unblocked blitzer comes. To my point, we had that guy blocked. That's just an error by the quarterback. It should be handoff, first down, or he pulls the ball. Only one guy over there. Just poor execution.''

  • Poo 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, CPantherKing said:

So, why does a coach give the QB an option to throw the screen when the LoS is loaded, and then blame the QB for the coach allowing the option to a screen when the defense is loaded up on the LoS.

It was a 4th and 1. Bills defense loaded the LoS. Coach had Newton in the shotgun for a zone read run play. That zone read run play in the shotgun on 4th and 1 had no chance to deveolp. Newton knew it. Coach allowed to option to a screen, which had a better chance at success and was still a garbage option.

Play calling was garbage on that 4th and 1. Don't blame a QB when you put him in that position. QB sneak. Power run if your OL is so good. Quick out or swing if the CBs are playing off or cheating in. That college garbage 4th and 1 play calling wont work in the NFL.

Coach put QB in a no win 4th and 1 and blamed the QB for not developing a zone read from the shotgun with the entire defense pressed up to the line.

I think we all knew that play was a loss when we saw the shotgun followed by a timeout only to go right back to the shotgun.

Or he could have just ran it for a yard like the main play was called.

  • Poo 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Matt Rhule’s offense has had horrific situational playcalling for 2 seasons.  So even if that one play was on Cam….it doesn’t change the fact that Rhule sucks. 
 

first drive.  3rd and long and we know we are going for it on 4th yet they throw long.  Incomplete.  Should of played a high percentage play to gain yardage that gave us more options on 4th.  It’s all Matt Rhule.   It’s not Joe Brady.  It’s not Cam.  Rhule is problem #1.  

  • Pie 3
  • Beer 1
  • Flames 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, CRA said:

Matt Rhule’s offense has had horrific situational playcalling for 2 seasons.  So even if that one play was on Cam….it doesn’t change the fact that Rhule sucks. 
 

first drive.  3rd and long and we know we are going for it on 4th yet they throw long.  Incomplete.  Should of played a high percentage play to gain yardage that gave us more options on 4th.  It’s all Matt Rhule.   It’s not Joe Brady.  It’s not Cam.  Rhule is problem #1.  

He doesnt normally call the offense though.   That's not something many head coaches are responsible for.  Not unheard of but not commonplace. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, CRA said:

Matt Rhule’s offense has had horrific situational playcalling for 2 seasons.  So even if that one play was on Cam….it doesn’t change the fact that Rhule sucks. 
 

first drive.  3rd and long and we know we are going for it on 4th yet they throw long.  Incomplete.  Should of played a high percentage play to gain yardage that gave us more options on 4th.  It’s all Matt Rhule.   It’s not Joe Brady.  It’s not Cam.  Rhule is problem #1.  

This all day.

  • Flames 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Tr3ach said:

He doesnt normally call the offense though.   That's not something many head coaches are responsible for.  Not unheard of but not commonplace. 

Every play runs through his ear.   And if a HC isn’t involved in key moments in the red zone, 4th down, etc? 

image.jpeg.af312c7b893edcef27eb285a971b493b.jpeg

  • Flames 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Hey, Rhule! So, who actually made a block on this play?

I see about 4 defenders running free around their blocks and Ian Thomas laying himself on the ground to give the outside defender and easy look into the backfield. There are 3 to 4 Bills 2 yards in the backfield in half a second.

Not to mention Zylstra doesn't even attempt to block on a bubble screen where there is only 1 defender on an island.

Yeah, looks like that was all Cam's fault you idiot of a coach. Not even smart enough to go to study the tape before you comment on that play. Moron.

  • Pie 2
  • Flames 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 minutes ago, CPantherKing said:

So, why does a coach give the QB an option to throw the screen when the LoS is loaded, and then blame the QB for the coach allowing the option to a screen when the defense is loaded up on the LoS.

It was a 4th and 1. Bills defense loaded the LoS. Coach had Newton in the shotgun for a zone read run play. That zone read run play in the shotgun on 4th and 1 had no chance to deveolp. Newton knew it. Coach allowed to option to a screen, which had a better chance at success and was still a garbage option.

Play calling was garbage on that 4th and 1. Don't blame a QB when you put him in that position. QB sneak. Power run if your OL is so good. Quick out or swing if the CBs are playing off or cheating in. That college garbage 4th and 1 play calling wont work in the NFL.

Coach put QB in a no win 4th and 1 and blamed the QB for not developing a zone read from the shotgun with the entire defense pressed up to the line.

I think we all knew that play was a loss when we saw the shotgun followed by a timeout only to go right back to the shotgun.

Exactly 

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • My very UNPOPULAR opinion:   First, I would want to know the locker room.  Have they turned on Canales?  If not, I would stay with him.  Here is why: Switching coaches every year or two is not the answer to long term success.  We are chasing hope instead of building a program around a young coach.  There were not many applicants for this job and if you think they are suddenly dying to be here now, that MIGHT justify a coaching change Canales has made some tough decisions (like benching Bryce), but his weaknesses (the team's weaknesses) have been in the areas in which we have neglected or sucked for years.  Who did we get for CMC?  Who made the trade with the Bears when we had no idea at the time who we wanted?  Who drafted Mingo, Marshall, XL, etc.?  Who signed a frequently-injured CB to the biggest contract in NFL history at the time for a CB?  I look at the personnel decisions and the play calling.  Our edge players are injured and not that good when healthy. He played Johnson because he had nothing left.  Johnson was terrible Sunday.  He has nothing at LB and two starting OL are now out.  XL is pouting because he does not seem to have paid the price to be paid the price of a first round pick.  AT was sent packing.  Bryce's resurgence last year may have been Canales and not Bryce. Evero still does not have the tools he needs to succeed--on the field or perhaps between his ears.   If Canales fires Evero, he is probably doing the right thing.  Remember, we had a lot of money in dead cap when Canales took over.  Fitterer was the worst GM since Matt Millen in the NFL, and we have sucked recently in the first round of the draft (Bryce, XL) until this season.   When the GM is trying to give the coach what he needs to be successful and you keep changing coaches, it is difficult.   I think this--stay with Canales, but bring in a veteran DC.  Some argue that Canales needs to move on from Bryce, but this team is not set up to give him options.  Andy aint the answer.  We never seem to take the PS QB seriously--all eggs are in one basket.  Canales needs options. This team needs to address the QB situation.  Bryce's best games are not Lombardi worthy, so move on.  He is not the Alpha a young coach needs on the field.  Give him options at QB, some LBs and a good coordinator on defense, and I think we could use another stud WR.  It is time to start drafting developmental OL and start grooming them to replace our aging OL. This draft is solid at QB as it stands now.  We need to focus on drafting the right guy and signing a veteran backup who is not the starting QB's BFF.  Compete.  Heck, i have no problem doing what Cleveland did--draft a QB in round 1 and then another QB if one falls into day 3.   I think we need stability and I am not confident any respectable coach comes to Carolina.  Canales is frustrated, but the front office has failed him, as have injuries, and a really bad draft a few years ago that brought them Bryce.  He was hired to fix Bryce--so I say neuter him so he does not sire any more 5'8" QBs.   Canales is better that Rivera was--Canales just has so much less talent.  Rivera was coach of the year a few times because he had Cam Newton, but could never put two winning seasons together.  That is a crime.
    • The Tepper move is 100% to want Belichick thinking that fixes our problems after striking out so much Let's see how much more he can screw up the franchise when JordON and Nicole are assistant GMs
×
×
  • Create New...