Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Under No Circumstances Should We Trade a Haul for a QB/Pick


tukafan21
 Share

Recommended Posts

How is "haul" being defined? And doesn't that differ from team to team? And are we only saying that QBs are unworthy for pick hauls? We just said no to a pick haul for Burns.

And Stafford not winning a SB would have only not looked good because they were a team on the cusp for years and years with Goff who they drafted high...and they got to that cusp via trades for other positions. And that franchise already had a Lombardi on the shelf. So was it a risk that they got to a SB with a #1 pick at QB? Or a risk to trade that #1 for an older #1 who had never won a playoff game?

I wouldn't trade the whole draft for the #1 pick, but I would easily consider future picks and players to soften the blow and trade players at the right time to get draft capital back.

I can't think of many recents player other than Cam that didn't we didn't have buyers remorse post-extension. We "gotta" pay KK, then could wait to get rid of him. Same with players like Johnson and even CMC. Burns, Brown, Horn, Marshall, maybe others should be viewed as players who can get potentially future picks back. Better that than wish they weren't extended, which we will for at least two of them.

  • Pie 2
  • Beer 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, CBDellinger said:

it does work, it’s has worked and it can work again.  
 

Josh Allen and Pat Mahommes both drafted as a result of trades.  
 

Stafford won the rams a super bowl and we all know how he got there. 
 

it’s not the trades that are the issue… it’s the talent evaluators and the situations the players wind up in. 

He said trade a haul, which i take to mean at least two ones.  If we want Chicago's pick, we will need to give up a haul.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Carl Spackler said:

I'd rather have Justin Fields than any QB in this draft other than CJ Stroud. 

Have you done anything other than look at his stat lines? He can run, that's about it. Slow to read defenses, has to see a guy open.

The best thing the Panthers could do is build a core of talent and develop Corral behind Darnold for another year or two.

Want to know why Purdy is doing well? He was a four year starter in college, played in a pro style offense, and the 49er's core of talent is quite possibly the highest in the NFL. We will send another 8 picks away looking for a savior QB before we do the sensible thing and build an offensive scheme with a core of elite talent around a guy who can LEAD an offense. 

If Corral were with the 49er's I feel like he would be playing similar to how Purdy is as well but Purdy is already reading defenses better than Justin Fields and he was a 7th round pick. 

Save the picks, take BPA/offensive talent at WR and TE in the first two picks. If there is a QB with a lot of college experience who may be middle of the road in terms of tangible traits, take him in the 4th or later and see what you got. There is something to be said for playing time in college and how it translates to the NFL. 

  • Beer 3
  • Poo 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Waldo said:

Be the seller and not the buyer in the mega trades.

I'm fine with using a 2nd but that is about it for me. 

The Broncos may be willing to offload Wilson for that. Wilson THRIVES in the scheme we were running this year. Play action pass with some improvisation and receivers who will operate the scramble drill. He's also a leader, as cringy as it can be. If we could get Wilson, even with his contract, for a 2nd I think you take it. 

Get Wilson, re-sign Foreman, draft a TE and third receiver, re-sign Bozeman...

Could easily be the favorites of the South for the next three years.

However I'm not giving up draft picks to take Stroud or Young. I'm also not drafting Richardson. His comp would be Josh Allen but Richardson doesn't have a ton of playing time and being a high pick will force him to play sooner rather than later. It's going to be a poo show, wherever he ends up. 

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Carl Spackler said:

I'd rather have Justin Fields than any QB in this draft other than CJ Stroud. 

Speaking as someone who wanted us to draft Fields this is silly. You can find a QB in this years draft with the floor of Fields right now. He has tremendous talent but even I know he's very raw at best as a passer. He still has time but he needs to make a jump next season. We should and will be targeting QB early in this years draft.

  • Pie 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, CPcavedweller said:

The Broncos may be willing to offload Wilson for that. Wilson THRIVES in the scheme we were running this year. Play action pass with some improvisation and receivers who will operate the scramble drill. He's also a leader, as cringy as it can be. If we could get Wilson, even with his contract, for a 2nd I think you take it. 

Get Wilson, re-sign Foreman, draft a TE and third receiver, re-sign Bozeman...

Could easily be the favorites of the South for the next three years.

However I'm not giving up draft picks to take Stroud or Young. I'm also not drafting Richardson. His comp would be Josh Allen but Richardson doesn't have a ton of playing time and being a high pick will force him to play sooner rather than later. It's going to be a poo show, wherever he ends up. 

No thank you to Wilson. I also belive It's fully guaranteed so the Broncos are stuck with him regardless.

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 minutes ago, CPcavedweller said:

The Broncos may be willing to offload Wilson for that. Wilson THRIVES in the scheme we were running this year. Play action pass with some improvisation and receivers who will operate the scramble drill. He's also a leader, as cringy as it can be. If we could get Wilson, even with his contract, for a 2nd I think you take it. 

Get Wilson, re-sign Foreman, draft a TE and third receiver, re-sign Bozeman...

Could easily be the favorites of the South for the next three years.

However I'm not giving up draft picks to take Stroud or Young. I'm also not drafting Richardson. His comp would be Josh Allen but Richardson doesn't have a ton of playing time and being a high pick will force him to play sooner rather than later. It's going to be a poo show, wherever he ends up. 

Russell Wilson?

angry get out GIF

  • Pie 2
  • Beer 1
  • The D 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • In a world where emotions find solace in melodies and stories are woven through harmonies, there exists a place where music aficionados gather to celebrate the essence of lyrical expression. Welcome to Musix Clan, your sanctuary in the realm of songs, where every beat, every note, and every lyric resonates with the collective heartbeat of a passionate community. At Musix Clan, we understand that music transcends mere entertainment; it is a language that speaks to the depths of our souls, unraveling emotions we didn't know existed and weaving connections between strangers across continents. Whether you're seeking solace in the melancholy of a ballad or unleashing your inner rebel with a rock anthem, Musix Clan is your compass in the vast ocean of musical exploration. What sets Musix Clan apart is not just its extensive library of songs spanning genres and eras but the vibrant community that breathes life into every lyric. From seasoned music veterans to budding enthusiasts, our members share a common bond forged by a love for the art form. Here, discussions flourish, interpretations collide, and new discoveries await around every corner. But Musix Clan is more than just a platform for passive consumption; it's a stage for expression, a canvas for creativity. Dive into our lyric annotation feature, where you can dissect the meanings behind your favorite songs, uncovering hidden layers of depth and insight. Engage in lively debates with fellow members, sharing your interpretations and gaining new perspectives that enrich your musical journey. As guardians of the lyrical realm, we understand the importance of preserving the authenticity and integrity of every song. That's why Musix Clan is committed to providing accurate, verified lyrics, ensuring that every word resonates with the original intent of the artist. Because when it comes to music, every syllable matters, every phrase carries weight, and every verse holds a story waiting to be told. So whether you're a seasoned audiophile or a casual listener dipping your toes into the vast ocean of music, join us at Musix Clan and embark on a journey of sonic discovery. Let's unravel the mysteries of melodies, explore the depths of lyrics, and celebrate the universal language that unites us all: music. Welcome to the clan.
    • He talks way too much about his time in Seattle and Russell Wilson and how they built that team in 2012.   I won’t fall for any of it until I see them play for a year 
    • Lol people like you are so silly and the only reason I seem to care to log on to post these days. How can you sit there and say Bryce was the reason Williams hurt his knee on that play. Maybe it's because you dislike Bryce so you are somewhat blind as to what actually happened? Not quite sure but maybe you should get your eyes checked. Williams hurt himself by trying to make a cut after spinning around to make that catch. Pause it at 3:24. Had he landed and ran like normal instead of going to plant his foot in the ground and make a cut he doesn't get hurt. Don't put that on Bryce. That was 100% Williams fault he got injured
×
×
  • Create New...