Most honest CJ Stroud film analysis!!

[Eric4280]

15 minutes ago, gibran said:

We need to get Bryce young. Pj and Sam could both make every throw this guy can but have the same problem. Young does not 

This times 1000. 

[frankw]

1 minute ago, Jon Snow said:

Is there a thread on here that is not biased?

Of course but OP is very pro Bryce Young. It's like asking the Ohio St fan here about Stroud.

[*FreeFua*]

Just now, frankw said:

Of course but OP is very pro Bryce Young. It's like asking the Ohio St fan here about Stroud.

Didn’t know that. Makes sense now

[Rags]

6 minutes ago, Ivory Panther said:

I one hundred percent disagree that CJ is more athletic than CARR/COUSINS/GOFF.

there is a reason he declined running at the combine. 

there's not liking a guy and then there's being willfully ignorant.

Stroud probably runs somwhere around a low 4.6 hig 4.7 which would put him in line with someone like Mahomes. He scrambles a lot like Mahomes too. Only when he has too. 

Stroud can move. He's more athletic than Goff and Cousins. 

[Eric4280]

10 minutes ago, Ivory Panther said:

Players like CJ/CARR/GOFF/COUSINS are frustrating.

they have the tangible that most ppl can see (accuracy) & decent mobility.

but when it comes down to it, they are only as good as the ppl around them.

they do just enough to be paid top 10 money but play like top 20 depending on their cast.

problem is after paying them, u can’t put a good cast together, so mediocrity soon follow.

That is the floor and ceiling that I honestly see with Stroud. It’s not terrible but you know..

[MHS831]

I don't like getting my football knowledge from Braveheart.

[ThPantherFan]

35 minutes ago, Ivory Panther said:

most honest & accurate I’ve seen so far.

He's got good protection.  He will have a different situation in the NFL.  I think he'll learn quickly with our QB coaching staff (if we take him).

[Tbe]

16 minutes ago, gibran said:

We need to get Bryce young. Pj and Sam could both make every throw this guy can but have the same problem. Young does not 

There is a breakdown of Bryce on YouTube where they show wide open receivers in the middle of the field that Bryce clearly can’t see because of his height.

This happened over and over again.

Its going to be an issue.

[ThPantherFan]

23 minutes ago, Jon Snow said:

Which he will be a lot in the nfl.

Big learning curve for him to take in.

[Eric4280]

8 minutes ago, frankw said:

Totally NOT biased thread right?

Like the one named “Stroud should be the starter no questions asked”

God forbid someone brings concern into conversation and you sit there and call them a Bama head. You have your own 371 pro Stroud threads. Leave the objective one alone.

[Sub Zero]

 

[Rags]

My biggest concern abt Young is the guys he gets compared to -- Russ and Murray -- are improvisers at a time where Improvisinal play is being schemed against more and more. 

On top of that, his arm strength is Matt Ryan tier.  It's not just the height for me. 

[PantherOnTheProwl1523]

Things were said about Stroud not being able to do or do that but we have a very good coaching staff that remedy a lot of this. How do you know Young will survive the onslaught of defensive players coming after him in games. Stroud plays better than Young in different ways and Young plays different ways. With good coaching a lot of weaknesses each player has can be fixed.

[frankw]

Just now, Eric4280 said:

Like the one named “Stroud should be the starter no questions asked”

God forbid someone brings concern into conversation and you sit there and call them a Bama head. You have your own 371 pro Stroud threads. Leave the objective one alone.

Weren't you the one calling Stroud OSU trash? You are the complete opposite of objective bub