For the Size Bros

[ncfan]

 

[kungfoodude]

Team doctor??

[mrcompletely11]

You had me at alabamas team doctor.  He absolutely has no vested interest in this.   Great thread and great find.  You’ve solved the puzzle 

[Waldo]

HAHAHA. Quoting his school doctor about anything NFL is irrelevant and showing how hard yall are trying to prop up this mess. Just lol. It feels like when we traded for Sam again. Just lol

[MHS831]

This is where people who have watched him play less and people without medical degrees resort to their "common sense" to argue against his points. 

Before you go there:

"Dr. Cain's research interest involves the evaluation and prevention of injuries in youth sports, as well as the treatment of adult injuries in the shoulder, elbow and knee, including cartilage and meniscal transplantation....Dr. Cain has presented papers and instructional courses for the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, American Orthopaedic Society for Sports Medicine and The International Society for Arthroscopy and Knee Surgery on the evaluation, diagnosis and treatment of knee, shoulder and elbow injuries."  Quarterbacks' #1 area for injuries is the shoulder by far.

This supports the research about smaller players getting hurt LESS than larger players (posted a few weeks ago).  But go ahead, challenge the good doctor with your "common sense."

Yes, injuries happen (eventually) to all football players, but there is reason to suggest that Young is no more vulnerable than any other player.

 

[therealmjl]

This is exactly what Luke said about him during his interview on WFNZ last week….but that guy doesn’t know anything about football

Edited April 23, 2023 by therealmjl

[MHS831]

To the doctor's critics:  Would you prefer a doctor less familiar with Young's playing style to provide an opinion?  If so, would that not be a less informed opinion?
You imply the presence of bias in your biased comments as if it discredits all he says.  Think about that level of hypocrisy.

[frankw]

5 minutes ago, kungfoodude said:

Team doctor??

This is a good example of why even folks who are warming up to BY as the pick are giving odd looks to the most ardent supporters of him as the pick. The lengths to which they are going to attempt to eliminate his one very real concern are at times simply hilarious.

[mrcompletely11]

5 minutes ago, MHS831 said:

This is where people who have watched him play less and people without medical degrees resort to their "common sense" to argue against his points. 

Before you go there:

"Dr. Cain's research interest involves the evaluation and prevention of injuries in youth sports, as well as the treatment of adult injuries in the shoulder, elbow and knee, including cartilage and meniscal transplantation....Dr. Cain has presented papers and instructional courses for the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, American Orthopaedic Society for Sports Medicine and The International Society for Arthroscopy and Knee Surgery on the evaluation, diagnosis and treatment of knee, shoulder and elbow injuries."  Quarterbacks' #1 area for injuries is the shoulder by far.

This supports the research about smaller players getting hurt LESS than larger players (posted a few weeks ago).  But go ahead, challenge the good doctor with your "common sense."

Yes, injuries happen (eventually) to all football players, but there is reason to suggest that Young is no more vulnerable than any other player.

 

thats awesome and all but he is still going to get hit, to act like he is some magician and will evade all punishment is just ignorant

 

Come thursday night I am on board but I have watched this game for far too long to know how this ends up.  I think this merry go round we are about to get on is going to be incredibly frustrating but alas here we go

[MillionDollarCam]

If anything, I’d say the team doctors’ comments warrant more concern rather than alleviating it.

So Young has already suffered from a sprained AC joint, and as the team doctor mentioned, it wasn’t from a big hit… it was from a routine play that could easily happen at least once a game. So what happens when he actually gets lit up?

Young’s size is a concern just like Stroud’s test score, anyone saying otherwise is kidding themselves.

Edited April 23, 2023 by MillionDollarCam

[Icege]

People with GEDs from the Carolinas dismissing a PhD's input because he's in Bama is funny af to me

Edited April 23, 2023 by Icege

[Move the Panthers to Raleigh]

8 minutes ago, Icege said:

People with GEDs from the Carolinas dismissing a PhD's input because he's in Bama is funny af to me

He’s actually an MD, not a PhD

[frankw]

Just now, Move the Panthers to Raleigh said:

He’s actually an MD, not a PhD

Ironic that is lost on him as he generalizes an entire region as being intellectually inferior. What a dick.

[Manna]

Again, I’m team Stroud but whoever we take I’ll support. Whoever it is I hope he leads us to multiple Super Bowl wins in his short time as a Panthers QB because they’re never old enough to get calls, nor will QB protection rules apply which WILL lead to injuries.