Official Panthers at Falcons GameDay Thread!

[therealmjl]

41 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

 

Play action boot out of that look and we likely score a TD.

[Mr. Scot]

Just now, therealmjl said:

Play action boot out of that look and we likely score a TD.

I love play action on 4th and short

[Ricky Prickles]

30 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

There are people pining for the leadership of Marty Hurney right now.

We may have officially reached The Ninth Circle of Dumb

I wish Hurney could come in every year just to make a first round selection and then walk out the door after that first round selection not to return back until its time to make the next first round drafty selection. The dude usually drafted pretty well in the first. He sucked at most everything else but first round he was a whiz

[Jon Snow]

2 minutes ago, Ricky Prickles said:

I wish Hurney could come in every year just to make a first round selection and then walk out the door after that first round selection not to return back until its time to make the next first round drafty selection. The dude usually drafted pretty well in the first. He sucked at most everything else but first round he was a whiz

Of course he was! We were always picking in the top 10 because of him. Hard to miss when you're picking that high.

[Carl Spackler]

56 minutes ago, Jon Snow said:

Of course he was! We were always picking in the top 10 because of him. Hard to miss when you're picking that high.

Tell that to Scott Fitterer

[Ricky Prickles]

2 hours ago, Jon Snow said:

Of course he was! We were always picking in the top 10 because of him. Hard to miss when you're picking that high.

True for the most part if you leave out guys like Jamarcus Russell and some other top 10 busts. Even his later first round picks turned out pretty well. terrible GM but the guy could scout a first rounder

 

[Billy Love]

3 hours ago, Mr. Scot said:

There are people pining for the leadership of Marty Hurney right now.

We may have officially reached The Ninth Circle of Dumb

Mr Scot - how many circles are there in the Circle of Dumb?

[Coheed]

1 hour ago, Carl Spackler said:

Tell that to Scott Fitterer

Ickey and Derrick Brown have been good??

 

horn is the only one you could arguably call a bad pick, and even then, he showed no issues staying healthy in college. Just bad luck. 
 

there are things to criticize Scott for but i don’t think first round selections are one of them. 

[Jon Snow]

20 minutes ago, Billy Love said:

Mr Scot - how many circles are there in the Circle of Dumb?

3

[Carl Spackler]

1 minute ago, Coheed said:

Ickey and Derrick Brown have been good??

 

horn is the only one you could arguably call a bad pick, and even then, he showed no issues staying healthy in college. Just bad luck. 
 

there are things to criticize Scott for but i don’t think first round selections are one of them. 

How could Fitterer have drafted Brown if he was hired 9 months after Brown was drafted?

[Coheed]

14 minutes ago, Carl Spackler said:

How could Fitterer have drafted Brown if he was hired 9 months after Brown was drafted?

Okay? The point still stands that the *only* first round pick of Scott’s that could be considered “bad” is Jaycee - and once again it’s due to an issue that never reared its head in college. So of Scott’s three first round picks you have

 

one that looks good and send to be on his way to being a stud (Ickey)

One who’s a great player but hurt too often (Horn)

and one who just played their first game (Bryce)

 

You can be bummed about Jaycee, I am too, but there’s nothing proving Scott is “bad” in the First round. 

 

Edited September 11, 2023 by Coheed

[Mr. Scot]

31 minutes ago, Billy Love said:

Mr Scot - how many circles are there in the Circle of Dumb?

 

10 minutes ago, Jon Snow said:

3

Well, if we're using Dante as a template, nine.

[Jon Snow]

3 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

 

Well, if we're using Dante as a template, nine.

[DavidEng]

9 hours ago, Harbingers said:

OL - B+ they actually pleasantly surprised me how cohesive they were on most plays already. That said 5 sacks is not a number they should allow.

QB - I’ll reserve that until we see a bit more of him. 
 

WR - Who? Do we have any WR’s on the team. Agree on the F.

Hurst - A

Defense - D-, the defense overall was, not good. 

Coaches - F. Those game plans sucked ass. 

Respect your ratings. As far as the sacks go, I attribute most of it to how long Young held onto the ball.

My QB and all my ratings were just for how they played for this game. I certainly expect Young to get better with more experience and practice, but he needs WR help and the timing was atrocious (half on WR half on Young).