This Bryce Guy (General BY Discussion)

[PantherChris]

21 minutes ago, dep said:

This is not at all relevant because he is not a rushing threat. Comparing one skillset means nothing. You may as well compare Bryce to Brady's third year passing stats which are closer anyway.

I literally said not close to his total effect or rushing bro

[PantherChris]

1 hour ago, electro's horse said:

4700 yds, 37 td, 12 interception

that’s what Goff did last season 

you’re insane 

Jared Goff can see over his offensive line and isnt a chicken sh*t

[PantherChris]

1 hour ago, fanpanther said:

I was curious so looked up a trent dilfer stats and all from the superbowl and years around it... Byoung and trent dilfer are very simliar and both got 90% of their teams wins by the rest of the team doing what it had to to win despite of the QB.  who knows maybe the panthers make the playoffs go on to win the superbowl and Byoung will be talked about like dilfer is when people talk about his superbowl 

WE ARE A LONG WAY FROM HAVING THE 2000 RAVENS DEFENSE.... 

[PantherChris]

6 hours ago, *FreeFua* said:

And that’s where a lot of people struggle to see it with Bryce

Bryce is never physically going to “wow” anyone. Which will ultimately keep him out of that elite QB tier. 

Burrow, Mahomes, Allen, Lamar, Maye, Stafford

People want to put Herbert in that tier because he’s the ultimate highlight type QB. Highlights in this day and age trump just about everything. I’m more inclined to put Dak in that category than Herbert. 

Then there’s the tier before the elite group. That’s where I believe Young’s ceiling is. Which is fine. You better have a good team and a good coach around these types though. 

I believe Bryce has a higher ceiling than Goff. Put Young on Detroit and that team has a higher ceiling. Would also have a lower floor but you’d take that. 

Bryce doesn’t have many true ‘wtf’ moments. He definitely did his rookie year. Granted the bulk of his “supporting cast” and HC are out of the league now and were well on their way out when the arrived here. 

Due to lack of physical traits and what made Bryce good at Bama this NFL thing was and still is going to take time with him. He’s adjusting to NFL defenses. 

So sure, we’re kind of in a pickle. Do we keep Bryce and have something like the 10th best QB in the league paired with Canales whose ceiling is probably similar at his position or do we keep doing what we’ve been doing since 2017? This team has been an absolute mess since Tepper took over. He’s finally seeing some wins. I’m all for spending a day 3 pick every year on a QB with traits. But for the time being Young is definitely our best option in 2026 and it would be tough to imagine us having a better option at this point in 2027 as well

I know how much the huddle loves charts but this wasn’t happening his rookie year. This chart is 2 weeks old but point remains. It’s also why I said Dalton would be useless against Buffalo. Bryce has done a real good job at avoiding sacks this year and then making something happen. Bryce is fully capable of giving you those 4-5 big plays you need from a QB a game. Those 4-5 big plays just look a lot different than the 4-5 big highlight type plays you get from those physically gifted QB’s

What it doesn't tell you his how many of those are from holding the ball to long being a to conservative and  not being able to see his WRs.

[fanpanther]

11 minutes ago, PantherChris said:

WE ARE A LONG WAY FROM HAVING THE 2000 RAVENS DEFENSE.... 

100% agree just meant Byoung and Tdilfer was the best comparison I have seen .  A terrible QB whose team wins despite him most of the time and every so often will have a decent game. With that being said this year in particular alot of teams are winning despite not having really good qb play...the bears and broncos for example

[kungfoodude]

@LinvilleGorge would it be possible for the mods to start merging some of these rather pointless and redundant Bryce reaction threads into this one? 

I mean....it's a little messy at the moment. 

[fanpanther]

https://www.nbcsports.com/nfl/profootballtalk/rumor-mill/news/ben-johnson-were-winning-in-spite-of-our-passing-game-not-because-of-it

 

This should be what canales is saying .