Philly Browns TD

[TheCandyMan]

2 fumbles, only 1 lost. He's been a beast at WR in the little time that he got and solid for the most part as a punt returner. 

 

Give up Dizzy.  Some of these fugs are always going to find a way to bi%ch.  It doesn't matter that he's come in as an UDFA and only played 5 professional games.  If you aren't an all-star, some in this fan base are always going to sh^t on everything you do.

Philly has a lot of room for improvement, no doubt there.  We have to fix securing the ball, no doubt there either.  But I'm not ready to give up on him yet.

[Growl]

You people are stupid.

Guy has shown ability on offense and STs.

It's pathetic and honesty kind of laughable that the standard that Panther fans demand from their punt returners is Mark Jones.

"JUST TAKE THE SAFE TWO YARDS SONNY BOY, STOP ACTING RIDICULOUS OUT THERE"

[Evodion]

2 fumbles, only 1 lost. He's been a beast at WR in the little time that he got and solid for the most part as a punt returner. 

 

Which is why i said I like him as a WR, but two fumbles in 4 games is a problem. 

[davos]

Minus that, he hasn't played well on ST but has NFL quickness IMO.  With some refinement via the School of Proehl, he could be a solid WR3/4 for us down the road.  It's just year one and we don't need his shakiness right now on PRs but I still like what I see for some reason.    

[Rags]

Because its been a consistent thing with him since preseason. He's been shaky since then.

 

And what of Kelvins drops? Do we need to completely replace Kelvin too?

 

Philly has had bad games but he's a rookie. He can improve and I think he will. He needs to learn when to call for a fair catch. A lot of this is "I've got to prove my worth" mentality he's had sense preseason and he needs to know he has earned his place on the roster. 

[Evodion]

Nobody is saying bench the guy permanently, but if he keeps putting balls on the ground every other game then he can't return punts right now. He seems like a hard worker and he will get better, but it's an issue right now.

[KillerKat]

And what of Kelvins drops? Do we need to completely replace Kelvin too?

 

Philly has had bad games but he's a rookie. He can improve and I think he will. He needs to learn when to call for a fair catch. A lot of this is "I've got to prove my worth" mentality he's had sense preseason and he needs to know he has earned his place on the roster.

Kelvin even with his drops is still our best WR.

Punt returning is something that can cost you games and Philly already has contributed to that once this season. Every catch today he was shaky. Even when fair catching it he has trouble with the ball. Did you see him just fall down after fair catching it with no one around? He had a couple mistakes today that were lucky not to cost the team again. Can't rely on luck every game of the season. He's good as a receiver, just terrible as a returner. I don't want it costing us close games.

[Ruff]

Honestly, the ball bounced off of #24, so it should've died where it landed. :/

[RJK]

kelvin dropping a pass every now and then isn't the same as fumbling and muffing punts the other team either recovers or scores on. those are turnovers son

[Rags]

Kelvin even with his drops is still our best WR.

Punt returning is something that can cost you games and Philly already has contributed to that once this season. Every catch today he was shaky. Even when fair catching it he has trouble with the ball. Did you see him just fall down after fair catching it with no one around? He had a couple mistakes today that were lucky not to cost the team again. Can't rely on luck every game of the season. He's good as a receiver, just terrible as a returner. I don't want it costing us close games.

 

And who's better on our roster at PRs than Philly? Beneand Cason were dropping punts in Camp, and while Philly was at one point, he improved dramatically.  

 

You don't think the coaches are going to talk to him about learning how to Fair Catch?

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

Wow, I missed the first half of the game. When I saw the box score, I thought it was a legit return

[KillerKat]

And who's better on our roster at PRs than Philly? Beneand Cason were dropping punts in Camp, and while Philly was at one point, he improved dramatically.  

 

You don't think the coaches are going to talk to him about learning how to Fair Catch?

Well I know Philly sucks. IDK how Cason would do. I guess an unknown is better than the known in this case. I would like to sign a reliable returner in free agency though.

[Clicheking]

He seems to be getting worse. Sometimes I question if he is even practicing fielding. He has a bad habit of moving backwards instead of running to punt, can't catch it cleanly, and has no idea when to fair catch. He literally flew backwards from the force of a punt today........backwards

[pamlicopanther]

I am certainly rooting for the guy, but I have to admit I am on the edge during every punt.  Hopefully he can get it together as I don't see what other option we have.