Would you be mad if gettleman chose Todd Gurley as our first round pick?

[scarface]

kugbila, barner, gaffney

 

Benewikere, Boston, Klein

 

 

 

...and Gaffney was stolen by the Patriots not sure why he is on this list.

[nickzz]

I'd be very mad

[Car123]

Yes

[*FreeFua*]

That's just dumb. If you can't see that DG has an eye for talent in later rounds that Hurney never had you are either not paying attention or are just retarded.

If you knew how to read you'd see I was responding to topdawg talking about finding 1st round gems NOTHING ELSE, would you not agree Marty was good at that as well?

But since you want to bring up DG's "eye for talent" in the later rounds ill play...

2013

4- Kugz (garbage)

5- Klein (serviceable, however Glanton did a better job once he came in due to AJ's injury)

6- Barner (garbage)

2014

4- Boston (going to tred lightly here since he's from UNC but I thought DG reached, Boston played well before getting abused in Seattle. Way too early to judge this pick though)

5- Bene (very solid)

6- Gaffney (injured, waived, lost)

So leaving Boston out of this, he's gone 1/5 - 1.5/5 with Klein being serviceable.

You would've been better off saying Gettleman has done a better job finding UDFA's or players off the streets/waivers. (Brown, Norwell, Glanton, Remmers, Fozzy) I know I'm missing a few others too

[C47]

I am more concerned with his ability to pick up the pass rush.

Which he does very well for a college back.

[Toker Smurf]

No. If he is BPA, get him. I hope BPA is at another position but he could turn out to be a stud RB and those van have a huge impact.

[Harris Aballah]

Which he does very well for a college back.

I'm an SEC fan, but hate GA. So I very rarely watch their games. I know his obvious strengths. But pass rush concerns me about any RB coming out of college. So, if he's good there, than count me as a yes

[TylerVagyler]

If you knew how to read you'd see I was responding to topdawg talking about finding 1st round gems NOTHING ELSE, would you not agree Marty was good at that as well?

But since you want to bring up DG's "eye for talent" in the later rounds ill play...

2013

4- Kugz (garbage)

5- Klein (serviceable, however Glanton did a better job once he came in due to AJ's injury)

6- Barner (garbage)

2014

4- Boston (going to tred lightly here since he's from UNC but I thought DG reached, Boston played well before getting abused in Seattle. Way too early to judge this pick though)

5- Bene (very solid)

6- Gaffney (injured, waived, lost)

So leaving Boston out of this, he's gone 1/5 - 1.5/5 with Klein being serviceable.

You would've been better off saying Gettleman has done a better job finding UDFA's or players off the streets/waivers. (Brown, Norwell, Glanton, Remmers, Fozzy) I know I'm missing a few others too

 

Bringing in solid UDFAs = having an "eye for talent"

[*FreeFua*]

You would've been better off saying Gettleman has done a better job finding UDFA's or players off the streets/waivers. (Brown, Norwell, Glanton, Remmers, Fozzy) I know I'm missing a few others too

Bringing in solid UDFAs = having an "eye for talent"

Duh.

He said later rounds, because he thought I compared Marty's drafting ability to DG's when I was really only talking about the 1st round

[TheNewStandard]

any RB taken high in the draft has to be durable. there are definitely durability issues but before he got hurt, there was talk of him going #1 overall.

he's big and physical but so are DLs and LBs. Marshawn Lynch is one of the few rbs in the past 10 years that has made it mostly unscathed...it's just a question of how much stock you feel like investing...I want my 1st rounders to be core players that stick as sure-fire starters without durability questions.

[GoobyPls]

Yes I'll be pretty upset

The only rb worth a first round pick is AP maybe Marshawn. People keep saying this RB class is deep so why draft one in the first? And that's a guy coming off injury.

[Khaki Lackey]

If you knew how to read you'd see I was responding to topdawg talking about finding 1st round gems NOTHING ELSE, would you not agree Marty was good at that as well?

But since you want to bring up DG's "eye for talent" in the later rounds ill play...

2013

4- Kugz (garbage)

5- Klein (serviceable, however Glanton did a better job once he came in due to AJ's injury)

6- Barner (garbage)

2014

4- Boston (going to tred lightly here since he's from UNC but I thought DG reached, Boston played well before getting abused in Seattle. Way too early to judge this pick though)

5- Bene (very solid)

6- Gaffney (injured, waived, lost)

So leaving Boston out of this, he's gone 1/5 - 1.5/5 with Klein being serviceable.

You would've been better off saying Gettleman has done a better job finding UDFA's or players off the streets/waivers. (Brown, Norwell, Glanton, Remmers, Fozzy) I know I'm missing a few others too

So you aren't counting Boston for whatever reason, and serviceable doesn't count on late round picks but injuries DO count against Gettleman. Mmmkay. Got it.

But yeah, I agree with your sentiment about Hurney, he could hit those first round slow pitches out of the park.

[cardiackat88.]

Why when you could get Yeldon super late round? Vastly underrated in my eyes.

[thefuzz]

I don't want a RB or a LB in the first.