Is McCaffrey already our best non-QB offensive player in franchise history?

[1of10Charnatives]

7 minutes ago, t96 said:

I think the argument is him vs Smith. Smith was a complete beast but even at his best was he as good as McC has been?

I think the argument is clearly that, and I would say at this point no, only because Smith has more track record, but CMC has a chance to eclipse him at this rate.

[Cpt slay a ho]

Steve Smith not even close yet 

[332nd]

No. It's still Steve Smith & will be for a while. To be best of all time requires a body of work much larger than three years.

[WarHeel]

8 minutes ago, t96 said:

I think the argument is him vs Smith. Smith was a complete beast but even at his best was he as good as McC has been?

I think he’s  the best player in the NFL at the moment. Guess that warrants the discussion.

[LinvilleGorge]

Over Smitty? No, not even close. He has a lot of years to go to match Smitty's body of work 

[BrizzMachete]

Pep and Smith still ahead of him but he on they ass 

[Doc Holiday]

Smitty still the best. Sorry he ain’t there.... yet...

[BurnHurnBurn]

No.

[rodeo]

prime Smitty and, i anticipate several poopoo emojis for this, but prime Deangelo in 2008ish was a threat to go the distance every single time he touched the ball.

[Cpt slay a ho]

I know cmc is our here big dickin it but do you mfs forget how DOMINANT Steve was? I’m talking regular season and playoffs? Ended Fred smoots career and put a clown suit on the bears defense and this is just naming a few out of 100’s of memorable performances 

[jopie87]

89. It's 89 and it will be for a long time. 

[Green_Tea]

Way too early to put him ahead of Steve Smith but McCaffrey is amazing though. Definitely has the potential to be if he keeps it up. 

[Car123]

3 hours ago, rodeo said:

prime Smitty and, i anticipate several poopoo emojis for this, but prime Deangelo in 2008ish was a threat to go the distance every single time he touched the ball.

What a great year that was.

[Ship]

I think CMC has the potential to be because as a RB he’s touching the ball regardless of how well the QB throws it. Also he can catch it. In terms of touches, CMC will have the opportunity to do more than Smith could- despite his ability to make catches that shouldn’t be caught. The discussion should really heat up if he can go 1000/1000 this year