Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Would you be upset if Sam was KC version of Alex Smith?


Panthercougar68
 Share

Recommended Posts

12 minutes ago, BrianS said:

No, wrong again.

Smith's last year in KC he averaged 8.6 air yards per attempt, with a 67.5% completion rate.  By way of comparison, Mahomes last year averaged 8.9 air yards per attempt, with a 66% completion rate.

Need more?  Ok.  Look at Tyreek Hill.  In Hill's first season starting, Smith's last season in KC, Hill had his second highest yards per reception and his highest yards per target over his career.

I am in no way saying Smith is close to Mahomes.  What I'm illustrating here is that KC parted with Alex Smith because they had an absolutely GENERATIONAL talent on their hands and after the years Smith had in KC, he was clearly not a backup.

Not saying I would want an Alex Smith here, but the comparisons to TB5 are grossly wrong.  TB5 doesn't come close.

If you want to argue that Alex Smith isn't a risk adverse QB that  refused to pull the trigger.....have at it.   

It's why a playoff team spent a top 10 pick on a QB in Mahomes despite winning for years with Alex Smith....because he wouldn't make the throws Reid needed.   He had the physical ability to. 

Teddy Bridgewater and Alex Smith are the same type QBs.  That isn't new.  It was all discussed last year on this very board.   And it isn't new why Andy Reid was ready to move on from Alex Smith. 

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

45 minutes ago, stbugs said:

Smith has only played a full season 3 times. Health was always an issue, but in the 5 year stretch where he actually played 15/16 games, he averaged over 20 TDs a year. Smith peak isn’t Mahomes but he was a level above Bridgewater. That was also when Smith was 29-33, so unfortunately he missed a lot of time during his early years.

That said, Darnold isn’t Smith or Bridgewater. He’s got a more dynamic arm. I think he’s boom or bust and maybe he can become more consistent but I’d be happy to get the playoff streak of healthy Smith. I just can’t compare Darnold to either because he doesn’t play like either of them.

I think Alex Smith actually missed 1 game during his 5 years in KC.  Health wasn't an issue.  Being risk adverse was, which was holding the team back.   Which is why they drafted a QB that would sling it despite being a consistent playoff team with Smith. 

He was routinely sitting out week 17 those seasons as they headed into the playoffs. 

Alex Smith is a better version of Teddy.  Yes.  But again, They are the same type of QB.  So if you want Sam Darnold to be an Alex Smith type.....you are wanting him to be a Teddy.   To which I say, no thank you.  I didn't want Teddy because he was a poor man's Alex Smith.   You need a QB that makes plays downfield in today's NFL.  The selling of Sam Darnold keeps taking dramatic shifts IMO.   

Should of drafted Fields.  Should of drafted Mac.   And I disliked Mac Jones.  But Mac Jones is making plays downfield in preseason.    That is, if the goal for Sam Darnold is now becoming to play like Teddy/Alex. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, OldhamA said:

Let's be honest, if he came in and performed like Alex Smith did with the Chiefs (5 winning seasons in a row) he'd be the best QB to ever suit up for the Panthers. 

But once again it's more people disrespecting how good a QB Alex Smith was more than anything. 

Agreed. He leaned game manager but he was a very effective NFL player. Now, admittedly, I think a bunch of that credit probably lies with Andy Reid but Smith played his part. 

I would definitely take "prime" Alex Smith over Sam Darnold, lower ceiling or not.

And for the people complaining about Smith not being a true franchise QB, okay, fine. But pair that with the success he had in those five years and now we are a serious NFL team to contend with.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

2 hours ago, Jon Snow said:

I still don't trust USC qb's.  They flame out as much as OSU QB's.  Besides, we are not lucky enough to find a diamond in the trash pile.

People think of Mark Sanchez when they think USC QB's and their utter flame-outs now.

Hope Sam can break that crappy mold and rise above it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, top dawg said:

Anyone that would be happy with a ceiling of Alex Smith has lowered their expectations. Alex Smith's a nice backup--was a nice backup.

The rationalization gymnastics are fun to watch 😅

Alex was cast in a negative light in order to denigrate Teddy...

...now in a flip-flop John Kerry would be proud of Smith is held out as a beacon of light for Silver Platter Sam to follow to the promised land 😂🙌

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Darnold could play like Alex Smith and with this offensive talent win consistently. Right now I want Darnold to be smart and conservative and take what the defense is giving him.  He needs to take care of the ball and let his players do the work while we improve the talent on this team.  But down the road when he has mastered the system and is comfortable with his line I want him throwing downfield and using that strong arm to keep safeties deep and make teams pay for blitzing us. If that can happen sooner then great. But I expect Darnold to be the best version of himself which could potentially be better than Smith if he can get his mojo here.

  • Beer 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 hours ago, Tinamedina said:

There was nothing wrong with Alex Smith, he just was outplayed in almost every situation he was in. Thats not really on him, there was some bad luck involved as well. With the chiefs, alex smith was good, even went to the playoffs? but Mahommes was/is more flashy,athletic,basically had that "it" factor, kind of hard to deny that. Then he broke his leg in Washington, that was the bad luck. I wouldn't mind Alex Smith but with this oline the panthers need an athletic qb who can use his legs when he needs to.

does Mahomes have the same “it” that PJ has?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Mother Grabber said:

does Mahomes have the same “it” that PJ has?

 

All of the mobile qb's have the same "it" factor. Its why andy dalton was booed and justin fields got a standing ovation, yes our oline needs to be more solidified BUT we still need a mobile qb.

Edited by Tinamedina
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, PghPanther said:

He's Steve Beuerlein 2.0.....manage the game okay but don't put the team on his back to pull out a big win when needed. 

...he's a career .481 gamer at best.

Good luck Panther fans...........find a team to root for in the post season because you won't be there. 

Kindly change your username to the actual team you're rooting for.

Thanks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Bryce scored 5 TDs that game, not 3
    • I get the feeling  but unfortunately that is both pro and college sports right now.     i mean, In what world, with education being what, 49th or thereabouts, in the country should,LSU, a state school, supported by state taxes,  be paying Kiffin  the money he is getting 
    • By Joseph Person Dec. 8, 2025Updated 3:07 am PST CHARLOTTE, N.C. — Jonathon Brooks will spend Monday like he’s spent nearly every other day over the past two years: Rehabbing his twice-repaired right knee while an NFL season continues without him. Monday marks one year since the Carolina Panthers running back tore his ACL a second time on a non-contact play in the first quarter of a 22-16 loss at Philadelphia. Brooks didn’t realize a year had passed since he went down at Lincoln Financial Field on his only carry against the Eagles, but he appreciates the significance of the day. “Honestly, it just makes me see how far I’ve come,” Brooks told The Athletic during a phone interview during the Panthers’ bye week. “I feel pretty much almost 100 percent again. From the moment it happened, I knew that God had a plan. I knew that it was all gonna be OK and I was gonna be right back to where I was.” Brooks isn’t all the way back, but he’s doing straight-line running while improving his speed most weeks. He hopes to start incorporating full-speed cutting and route running soon and return to the practice field in the spring in time for OTAs. Brooks, the Panthers’ second-round pick in 2024, has endured some down days over the past year, particularly in the immediate aftermath of his re-injury. “When it first happened, he was devastated. I was, too. I just couldn’t believe it,” said Jennifer Donovan, Brooks’ mother. “I thought for sure he was healed completely. Just didn’t hear too many times that it happened again and again like that. And only just a year later, I was devastated. And I know he was, too, at first.” But he pushed through thanks to the support of his family, his Christian faith and his teammates. He received guidance from two members of the training and strength and conditioning departments and drew inspiration after hearing from players like Baltimore Ravens running back Derrick Henry and former Panthers linebacker Thomas Davis. Davis famously became the first NFL player to return from three torn ACLs in the same knee, playing another nine seasons that included a Super Bowl appearance and three Pro Bowl berths. Davis reached out to Brooks right after the injury to express his concern, and later joined Brooks for workouts during which Davis would show him exercises that worked well for him during his recovery. The two have stayed in touch, with Brooks shooting Davis texts or an occasional picture from a training session. That’s a legend in the locker room,” Brooks said. “That’s a legend who’s played for the Panthers, so I’ve got all the utmost respect for him and a lot (of) respect for helping me when he doesn’t have to.” Brooks has watched the replay of his injury more than 20 times. He blames himself for trying to run outside rather than hitting the hole between left tackle Ikem Ekwonu and wide receiver Adam Thielen. But when Brooks spotted defensive back Avonte Maddox coming up in run support, he tried to beat him to the edge with a jump cut. “I had no business even trying to go outside. My read was there,” Brooks said. “My read was supposed to keep me inside. I chased what we call fool’s gold and I was gonna try to outrun the DB. But it was just the wrong read.” Brooks said he’d made harder cuts the previous week against Tampa Bay with no problems. He’s not sure why his knee gave out on the grass surface at Lincoln Financial Field. “I think it was just bad timing,” he said. Panthers coach Dave Canales announced the next day that Brooks had re-torn the ligament. Slavin, Brooks’ Dallas-based agent, was relieved the ACL was the only part of Brooks’ knee impacted. “It was an ACL-only, so it wasn’t like one of these devastating knee injuries that a lot of guys have. When it’s the one ligament, you think they’d be able to come back,” Slavin said. “If we could do it all over again, I’m sure they’d redshirt him last year and this year would’ve been his year. But they tried to get him out there. It’s tough to always look back. Moving forward, I think he’s gonna be an elite running back still.” After waiting a month for the swelling to subside, Brooks flew to Los Angeles for the surgery performed by renowned sports orthopedic Neal ElAttrache. Donovan said ElAttrache harvested part of the patellar tendon from Brooks’ left knee to reconstruct his ACL because the patellar from his right knee was used in the first surgery in Texas. Additionally, ElAttrache used a strip of the IT band from Brooks’ right leg as a graft to reinforce his ACL, according to Donovan. “I’m praying that is going to be the key thing in keeping him stronger. He felt very confident with it,” Donovan said of ElAttrache, who also handled Panthers guard Robert Hunt’s biceps surgery this fall. Brooks said both Dowdle and Hubbard have tried to make sure he still feels like part of the running back room while he’s recovered. Brooks also praised the training staff, especially the two staffers he’s worked most closely with — athletic trainer Harrison Grube and assistant strength and conditioning coach Thomas Barbeau. The team has said little about Brooks since last December. But any expectations the Panthers have for Brooks in 2026 naturally will be tempered by concerns of injury risk. Donovan tries not to let her mind go down that path. “Definitely the first time was worse just because he wasn’t sure what to expect. The second time it was devastating again, but at least we kind of knew,” she said. “So I’m just praying and praying and praying there surely won’t be another. I don’t even want to put it out there in existence.” Having been through all of this just last year, Brooks has a better feel for what works and what doesn’t. When he was experiencing pain in his knee after some of the strengthening exercises, the Panthers’ trainers changed his lifts. The tips from Davis have also helped. If all goes according to plan, Brooks will on the practice field in the spring. And while some might be inclined to hold their breath the first time he gets the call or makes a cut, Brooks is turning it over to a higher power. “I want to be back for OTAs so I can get back on that football field and get back to running the plays full speed, being in a team setting. Just so whenever we do hit (training) camp, I can hit the ground running and ultimately, just prove myself,” he said. “I feel like I haven’t gotten that chance in the league to prove myself. And that’s OK. It’s a part of God’s plan. And I know that when I get out there, I trust in myself, trust in my teammates, trust in God that I’ll be able to get it done.”            
×
×
  • Create New...